缺乏关节线压痛与半月板愈合一致,但阳性临床检查发现和MRI扫描在识别半月板修复术后失败方面不一致:一项系统综述与亚组Meta分析
本系统综述与Meta分析纳入评估半月板修复术后愈合的临床研究,比较临床检查与MRI或二次关节镜所见的相关性。结果未发现临床检查与MRI或二次关节镜所见显著相关,亚组Meta分析显示仅缺乏关节线压痛对愈合的半月板修复具有高特异性,对数诊断比值比为2.62(95%CI,0.47-4.76)。
要点
- 临床检查与MRI或二次关节镜所见之间未发现显著相关性。
- Barrett标准与非Barrett标准研究的亚组间无显著差异(χ12=0.24;P=0.62)。
- 仅缺乏关节线压痛对愈合的半月板修复具有高特异性,对数诊断比值比为2.62(95%CI,0.47-4.76)。
核心结论
- 本研究未发现任何特定临床检查与术后MRI和/或二次关节镜所见的半月板修复愈合状态显著相关。
- 评估术后半月板修复愈合状态时,应考虑MRI上无愈合(与完全或不完全愈合相比)和关节线压痛。
- 亚组Meta分析发现缺乏关节线压痛与愈合的半月板修复高度相关。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,证据等级为4级。
- 纳入所有研究半月板修复、半月板修复结局及半月板愈合的临床研究,需包含临床发现、MRI和/或二次关节镜,发表于同行评议期刊且全文为英文。
- 采用非随机研究方法学指数(MINORS)评估所有纳入研究的偏倚。
- 临床检查包括采用「Barrett标准」的评估,涵盖积液、关节线压痛、交锁、McMurray试验和X线片;该参数也被缩写为「改良Barrett标准」,仅包括关节线压痛、积液和McMurray试验。
主要发现
- 临床检查与MRI或二次关节镜之间未发现显著相关性。
- Barrett标准研究与非Barrett标准研究之间的亚组Meta分析未报告显著的亚组差异(χ12=0.24;P=0.62)。
- 基于7项报告二次关节镜真阳性、真阴性、假阳性和假阴性数据的研究进行的诊断准确性Meta分析显示,仅缺乏关节线压痛对愈合的半月板修复具有高特异性,对数诊断比值比为2.62(95%CI,0.47-4.76)。
关键数值与推荐
- Barrett标准包括积液、关节线压痛、交锁、McMurray试验和X线片评估。
- 改良Barrett标准仅包括关节线压痛、积液和McMurray试验。
- 缺乏关节线压痛对愈合的半月板修复具有高特异性,对数诊断比值比为2.62(95%CI,0.47-4.76)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The number of meniscal repairs being completed each year is increasing; however, the optimal, cost-effective postoperative assessment to determine the success or failure of a meniscal repair is not well known. PURPOSE/HYPOTHESIS: The purpose of this systematic review was to identify the clinical examination testing that correlates with objective magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) or second-look arthroscopy (SLA) findings to determine an optimal clinical workup for assessing postoperative meniscal repair healing. It was hypothesized that specific clinical tests would correlate with meniscal repairs that did not heal. STUDY DESIGN: Systematic review and meta-analysis; Level of evidence, 4. METHODS: This systematic review included all clinical studies investigating meniscal repairs, meniscal repair outcomes, and meniscal healing with clinical findings, MRI, and/or SLA, published in a peer-reviewed journal and with full English text available. All included studies were evaluated for bias using the Methodological Index for Non-Randomized Studies (MINORS). The clinical tests included those using "Barrett's criteria," with the assessment of effusion, joint line tenderness, locking, McMurray testing, and radiographs. This parameter has also been abbreviated to "modified Barrett's criteria" to include only joint line tenderness, effusion, and McMurray testing. RESULTS: No significant correlations were found between clinical tests and MRI or SLA. A subgroup meta-analysis between Barrett's and non-Barrett's studies reported no significant subgroup differences (χ12 = 0.24; P = .62). A meta-analysis of diagnostic accuracy using a group of 7 studies that reported on true-positive, true-negative, false-positive, and false-negative data for SLA demonstrated that only a lack of joint line tenderness had a high specificity for a healed meniscal repair, with a log diagnostic odds ratio of 2.62 (95% CI, 0.47-4.76). CONCLUSION: This study found no significant correlation with any specific clinical test for meniscal repair healing status using postoperative MRI and/or SLA findings. However, it was found that no healing (when compared with complete or incomplete healing) on MRI and joint line tenderness should be considered when assessing the status of postoperative meniscal repair healing. In addition, a subgroup meta-analysis found that a lack of joint line tenderness was highly correlated with a healed meniscal repair.
引用
- Schoenecker JH, Tollefson LV, Solaiman RH, et al. A Lack of Joint Line Tenderness Is Consistent With a Healed Meniscus, But Positive Clinical Examination Findings and MRI Scans Are Inconsistent in Identifying Failure After Meniscal Repair: A Systematic Review and Subgroup Meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2025. PMID: 39841079. doi:10.1177/03635465241295709
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。