关节镜下肩袖修复联合或不联合肩峰成形术功能结局的统计脆弱性:系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析纳入截至2024年2月5日的6项随机对照试验共609例患者,采用反向连续脆弱指数评估关节镜下肩袖修复联合或不联合肩峰成形术功能结局的统计脆弱性。结果发现脆弱性 largely 取决于所用统计检验,Wilcoxon秩和检验和Student t检验下结果脆弱,结合研究数量少和失访接近或超过20%,提示缺乏强证据支持既往结论。
要点
- Welch t检验下所有研究结局的中位RCFI为20(IQR 17-24)。
- Student t检验下中位RCFI为14(IQR 13-19),中位RCFQ为0.18(IQR 0.15-0.20)。
- Wilcoxon秩和检验下中位RCFI为14(IQR 13-17),中位RCFQ为0.17(IQR 0.13-0.19)。
核心结论
- 这些研究的脆弱性 largely 取决于分析结果所用的统计检验。
- Wilcoxon秩和检验和Student t检验似乎最适合发现治疗组间的差异,使用这些检验时发现结果脆弱。
- 结合研究数量少和失访接近或超过20%,表明整体缺乏强证据支持既往已接受的结论。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,证据等级3。
- 纳入截至2024年2月5日的所有随机对照试验,研究关节镜下肩袖修复联合或不联合肩峰成形术。
- 共分析6项临床试验,包含609例患者的功能结局评分。
主要发现
- 使用Welch t检验时,所有研究结局的中位RCFI为20(四分位距[IQR] 17-24)。
- 使用Student t检验时,所有研究结局的中位RCFI为14(IQR 13-19),中位RCFQ为0.18(IQR 0.15-0.20)。
- 使用Wilcoxon秩和检验时,中位RCFI为14(IQR 13-17),中位RCFQ为0.17(IQR 0.13-0.19)。
- 使用Welch t检验时,64%的研究结局的RCFI大于失访(LTFU)。
- 使用其他检验时,32%的研究结局的RCFI大于失访。
关键数值与推荐
- 反向连续脆弱指数(RCFI)定义为需要从较低均值组移动到较高均值组以改变显著性的合格数据点的数量。
- 反向连续脆弱商(RCFQ)通过将RCFI除以样本量确定。
- RCFI针对Welch t检验、Student t检验和Wilcoxon秩和检验在各种数据假设下计算。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文指出研究数量少。
- 原文指出失访接近或超过20%。
- 原文指出整体缺乏强证据支持既往已接受的结论。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Views surrounding acromioplasty at the time of arthroscopic rotator cuff repair (RCR) have shifted dramatically over time. In recent years, various studies have argued against acromioplasty, citing equivocal functional outcomes after arthroscopic RCR with or without acromioplasty. PURPOSE: To assess the statistical fragility of functional outcomes after arthroscopic RCR with and without acromioplasty using the reverse continuous fragility index (RCFI). STUDY DESIGN: Systematic review and meta-analysis; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: A systematic review and meta-analysis was performed including all randomized controlled trials through February 5, 2024 investigating arthroscopic RCR with and without acromioplasty. The RCFI, defined as the number of qualifying data points required to be moved from the lower mean group to the higher mean group to alter the significance, was calculated for the Welch t test, Student t test, and Wilcoxon rank-sum test under various data assumptions. The reverse continuous fragility quotient (RCFQ) was determined by dividing the RCFI by the sample size. RESULTS: A total of 6 clinical trials consisting of 609 patients with functional outcome scores were analyzed. Using the Welch t test, the median RCFI across all study outcomes was 20 (interquartile range [IQR], 17-24). For the Student t test, the median RCFI across all study outcomes was 14 (IQR, 13-19), with a median RCFQ of 0.18 (IQR, 0.15-0.20). For the Wilcoxon rank-sum test, the median RCFI was 14 (IQR, 13-17), with a median RCFQ of 0.17 (IQR, 0.13-0.19). While using the Welch t test, 64% of study outcomes had an RCFI greater than the loss to follow-up (LTFU). When using the other tests, 32% of study outcomes had an RCFI greater than the LTFU. CONCLUSION: The fragility of these studies was largely dependent on the statistical test used to analyze the results. The Wilcoxon rank-sum test and Student t test appeared to be most appropriate to find differences in treatment arms. When using these tests, we found the results to be fragile. This, in combination with a small number of studies and the LTFU close to or exceeding 20%, indicates an overall lack of strong evidence to support previously accepted conclusions.
引用
- Clark DS, Tingey BC, Shi JL, et al. The Statistical Fragility of Functional Outcomes for Arthroscopic Rotator Cuff Repair With and Without Acromioplasty: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2025. PMID: 39836369. doi:10.1177/03635465241302797
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。