水平半月板撕裂的半月板修复与半月板切除术的生物力学特性:系统综述
该系统综述纳入6项生物力学尸体研究,比较水平半月板撕裂(HMT)、半月板修复(MR)与半月板切除术后的膝关节接触力学。结果显示HMT后MR接触力学偏离最小,仅MR恢复至未损伤状态;部分或完全半月板切除均显著增加峰值接触压力并减少接触面积。作者认为这些发现支持MR的优越性,但需更多临床比较。
要点
- HMT后MR的峰值接触压力和接触面积与完整半月板无显著差异。
- 部分半月板切除后4/6研究显示峰值接触压力显著增加27.1%,5/6研究显示接触面积显著减少22.1%。
- 完全半月板切除后全部6项研究显示峰值接触压力显著增加54.5%,5项研究显示接触面积显著减少33%。
核心结论
- HMT后MR接触力学偏离最小,仅MR使接触力学恢复至未损伤状态。
- 这些发现支持MR的优越性,表明维持接触力学需要保留半月板组织,并与临床证据一致。
- 需要更多临床比较以理解不同治疗之间的差异。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,证据等级5级。
- 系统检索PubMed、EMBASE和CINAHL数据库至2023年1月16日,遵循PRISMA指南,纳入HMT的生物力学尸体研究。
- 排除标准包括:未研究MR或半月板切除、未报告接触面积或压力、合并损伤(如前交叉韧带撕裂)、非生物力学研究(如综述、技术、临床)及非英语文章。
- 最终纳入6项研究;测量了59个完整半月板、59个HMT、59个部分半月板切除(PM)、59个完全半月板切除(CM)和33个MR。
主要发现
- 所有HMT与完整状态相比,合并峰值接触压力(PCP)增加14.2%,合并接触面积(CA)减少7.1%。
- 所有PM与完整状态相比,4/6研究显示PCP显著增加27.1%,5/6研究显示CA显著减少22.1%。
- 所有CM与完整状态相比,全部6项研究显示PCP显著增加54.5%,5项研究显示CA显著减少33%。
- 3项直接比较PM与CM的研究中,2项发现PM较CM的PCP增加更小(23.3% vs 52.4%),CA减少更小(16.7% vs 28.1%)。
- 3项评估MR与完整状态的研究发现PCP或CA无显著差异。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 需要更多临床比较以理解不同治疗之间的差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Limited biomechanical evidence exists describing how horizontal meniscus tears (HMTs), meniscal repair (MR), and meniscectomy alter the knee's biomechanical environment. PURPOSE: To evaluate changes in knee contact mechanics following HMTs, MR, and meniscectomy. STUDY DESIGN: Systematic review; Level of evidence, 5. METHODS: PubMed, EMBASE, and CINAHL databases were systematically searched for biomechanical cadaveric studies of HMTs up to January 16, 2023, using the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines. Studies that (1) did not examine MRs or meniscectomies, (2) did not report contact area (CA) or pressure, (3) involved concomitant injuries (eg, anterior cruciate ligament tear), (4) were nonbiomechanical studies (eg, review, technique, and clinical), and (5) were non-English language articles were excluded. The endpoints were peak contact pressure (PCP) and mean CA. RESULTS: Out of 1526 initial results, 6 studies were included for final review. PCP and CA were measured in 59 intact menisci, 59 HMTs, 59 partial meniscectomies (PM), 59 complete meniscectomies (CM), and 33 MR. Among all HMTs versus the intact state, pooled PCP increased by 14.2%, and pooled CA decreased by 7.1%. Among all PMs versus the intact state, 4 of 6 studies found significantly increased PCP (27.1%), and 5 found significantly reduced CA (22.1%). Among all CMs versus the intact state, all 6 studies found significantly increased PCP (54.5%), and 5 found significantly reduced CA (33%). Among the 3 studies directly comparing PM to CM, 2 studies found PM to have significantly smaller increases in PCP (23.3% vs 52.4%) and significantly smaller reductions in CA (16.7% vs 28.1%) from the intact state.) The 3 studies evaluating MR versus the intact state found no significant difference in PCP or CA. CONCLUSION: After an HMT, MR had the smallest deviations in contact mechanics; only MR restored contact mechanics to the uninjured state. These findings support MR's superiority, illustrate that maintaining contact mechanics requires preserving meniscal tissue, and are consistent with clinical evidence. More clinical comparisons are needed to understand the differences among treatments.
引用
- Pearsall CA, Desai SS, Athanasian C, et al. Biomechanical Properties of Meniscal Repair Versus Meniscectomy for Horizontal Meniscal Tears: A Systematic Review. Am J Sports Med. 2025. PMID: 39799406. doi:10.1177/03635465241279844
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。