文献速递关节外科运动医学

全肩关节置换术后术前功能与达到临床重要成功基准的关系是否取决于结局评估设计?

Does the Relationship Between Preoperative Function and Achievement of Clinically Important Benchmarks of Success After Total Shoulder Arthroplasty Depend on Outcome Assessment Design?
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2025-01-07

该回顾性多中心数据库研究纳入2041例解剖型全肩关节置换(aTSA)和3205例反式全肩关节置换(rTSA),评估术前功能与达到临床重要成功基准(CIBS)的关系。结果显示术前功能较差与达到MCID和SCB的几率较高相关,但与达到PASS的几率较低相关;对于无天花板效应的评分,术前评分较差与达到MCI-%MPI和SCI-%MPI的几率较高相关。作者结论认为患者达到CIBS的可能性部分取决于基线功能及成功定义方式,未来需进一步研究确定哪些CIBS最能代表临床相关获益。

要点

  • 术前活动度较差与达到MCID和SCB的几率较高相关,但与达到PASS的几率较低相关。
  • 对于SST及无天花板效应的Constant和SAS评分,术前评分较差与达到MCI-%MPI和SCI-%MPI的几率较高相关。
  • aTSA中75%报告「好很多」、15%报告「较好」,rTSA中76%报告「好很多」、18%报告「较好」。

核心结论

  • 大多数患者报告较术前「好很多」(aTSA 75%,rTSA 76%)或「较好」(aTSA 15%,rTSA 18%),但10%的aTSA和6%的rTSA为「无变化」或「更差」。
  • 患者达到CIBS的可能性部分取决于基线功能以及成功被定义为绝对改善、术后绝对状态还是相对改善。
  • 术前状态较好的患者更可能达到评估相对改善的CIBS(MCI-%MPI和SCI-%MPI)而非绝对改善的CIBS(MCID和SCB)。
  • 未来需要研究来确定哪些个体CIBS或其组合最准确地代表临床相关获益。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性查询多中心肩关节置换数据库,纳入初次解剖型全肩关节置换(aTSA)2041例和反式全肩关节置换(rTSA)3205例。
  • aTSA手术时平均年龄66±9岁,rTSA为72±8岁;aTSA中女性占51%(1049/2041),rTSA中女性占61%(1955/3205)。
  • aTSA最常见的术前诊断为骨关节炎伴肩袖完整(92% [1869/2041]);rTSA最常见的术前诊断包括肩袖撕裂关节病(40% [1280/3205])、骨关节炎伴肩袖完整(24% [780/3205])、骨关节炎伴肩袖撕裂(20% [632/3205])和巨大肩袖撕裂(10% [309/3205])。
  • 结局在末次随访时评估(aTSA 61±36个月,rTSA 47±26个月),包括活动度(外展、前屈、外旋和内旋)以及常用结局评分:简单肩关节测试(SST)、Constant评分、美国肩肘外科医师(ASES)评分、加州大学洛杉矶分校(UCLA)评分、肩痛与功能障碍指数(SPADI)和肩关节置换智能(SAS)评分。
  • 评估的CIBS包括最小临床重要差异(MCID)、实质性临床获益(SCB)、患者可接受症状状态(PASS)、最大可能改善的最小临床重要百分比(MCI-%MPI)和最大可能改善的实质性临床重要百分比(SCI-%MPI);假体特异性锚定CIBS取自该数据库患者既往发表文献。

主要发现

  • 对于所有活动度指标和结局评分,术前活动度较差与达到MCID和SCB的几率较高相关,但与达到PASS的几率较低相关。
  • 对于SST和两个无天花板效应的评分(Constant和SAS评分),术前结局评分较差与达到MCI-%MPI和SCI-%MPI的几率较高相关,但ASES、SPADI和UCLA评分未显示此关联。
  • 图形分析显示术前活动度和结局评分较高的患者达到MCID和SCB的概率较低,但达到PASS的概率较高。
  • 对于已知有天花板效应的结局评分,术前结局评分较好的患者达到MCI-%MPI和SCI-%MPI的可能性分别高于达到MCID和SCB的可能性。
  • 对于无天花板效应的结局评分,接受aTSA的患者达到MCID、MCI-%MPI和SCI-%MPI的可能性高于达到SCB,但rTSA患者未发现明确趋势。

关键数值与推荐

  • aTSA中92%(1869/2041)术前诊断为骨关节炎伴肩袖完整;rTSA中40%(1280/3205)为肩袖撕裂关节病,24%(780/3205)为骨关节炎伴肩袖完整,20%(632/3205)为骨关节炎伴肩袖撕裂,10%(309/3205)为巨大肩袖撕裂。
  • aTSA末次随访时间61±36个月,rTSA为47±26个月。
  • aTSA患者报告「好很多」占75%、「较好」占15%;rTSA患者报告「好很多」占76%、「较好」占18%;10%的aTSA和6%的rTSA为「无变化」或「更差」。
  • ROC曲线分析中,所确定阈值对MCID和SCB的曲线下面积>0.7,对PASS、MCI-%MPI和SCI-%MPI则不然。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 未来需要研究来确定哪些个体CIBS或其组合最准确地代表临床相关获益。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: A variety of clinically important benchmarks of success (CIBS) have been defined for total shoulder arthroplasty (TSA) to quantify success. However, it is unclear how the preoperative status of the patient influences their likelihood of achieving each CIBS. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) What proportion of patients achieve commonly used CIBS after TSA? (2) Is there a relationship between a patients' preoperative function and their probability of achieving different CIBS? (3) Does there exist preoperative ranges for each outcome measure that are associated with greater achievement of CIBS? METHODS: We retrospectively queried a multicenter shoulder arthroplasty database for primary anatomic TSA (aTSA) and reverse TSA (rTSA). A total of 2041 aTSAs and 3205 rTSAs were included. The mean ± SD age at time of surgery was 66 ± 9 years for aTSAs and 72 ± 8 years for rTSAs. In all, 51% (1049 of 2041) of aTSAs and 61% (1955 of 3205) of rTSAs were in patients who were women. For aTSAs, osteoarthritis with an intact rotator cuff was the most common preoperative diagnosis (92% [1869 of 2041]). For rTSAs, the most common preoperative diagnoses included rotator cuff tear arthropathy (40% [1280 of 3205]), osteoarthritis with an intact rotator cuff (24% [780 of 3205]), osteoarthritis with a torn rotator cuff (20% [632 of 3205]), and massive rotator cuff tear (10% [309 of 3205]). Outcomes were evaluated at latest follow-up (aTSA 61 ± 36 months, rTSA 47 ± 26 months) and consisted of ROM (abduction, forward elevation, external and internal rotation) as well as the most commonly used outcome scores: the Simple Shoulder Test (SST), Constant score, American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES) score, University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) score, Shoulder Pain and Disability Index (SPADI), and the Shoulder Arthroplasty Smart (SAS) score. The CIBS that we evaluated included the minimum clinically important difference (MCID), substantial clinical benefit (SCB), patient acceptable symptom state (PASS), minimum clinically important percentage of maximal possible improvement (MCI-%MPI), and substantial clinically important percentage of maximal possible improvement (SCI-%MPI). Prosthesis-specific anchor-based CIBS were adopted from prior publications on patients from this database. Multivariable regression was performed to identify the relationship between preoperative outcome measures and achievement of CIBS. Additionally, receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analyses were performed to determine whether thresholds in preoperative outcome measures were associated with achieving CIBS. RESULTS: For all ROM measures and outcome scores, poorer preoperative ROM was associated with greater odds of achieving the MCID and SCB but lower odds of achieving the PASS. For the SST and the two scores without ceiling effects (the Constant and SAS scores), poorer preoperative outcome scores were associated with greater odds of achieving the MCI-%MPI and SCI-%MPI, but no association was demonstrated for the ASES, SPADI, and UCLA scores. Graphical analysis demonstrated that patients with greater preoperative ROM and outcome scores had a lower probability of achieving the MCID and SCB but a higher probability of achieving the PASS. For outcome scores with known ceiling effects, patients with more favorable preoperative outcome scores were more likely to achieve the MCI-%MPI and SCI-%MPI than the MCID and SCB, respectively. For outcome scores without ceiling effects, patients undergoing aTSA were more likely to achieve the MCID, MCI-%MPI, and the SCI-%MPI than the SCB, but no clear trend was identified for patients undergoing rTSA. On ROC curve analysis, identified thresholds were reasonably accurate (area under the curve > 0.7) for achievement of measures of absolute improvement (the MCID and SCB), but not for absolute postoperative status (the PASS) or relative improvement (the MCI-%MPI and SCI-%MPI). CONCLUSION: While most patients reported being "much better" (aTSA 75%, rTSA 76%) or "better" (aTSA 15%, rTSA 18%) compared with before surgery, 10% of aTSAs and 6% of rTSAs were either "unchanged" or "worse." Patients' likelihood of achieving CIBS depends in part on their baseline function and whether success is defined as absolute improvement, absolute postoperative status, or relative improvement. Patients with more favorable preoperative status are more likely to achieve CIBS that evaluate relative improvement (the MCI-%MPI and SCI-%MPI) than absolute improvement (the MCID and SCB). Future studies are needed to determine which individual CIBS or combinations thereof most accurately represent clinically relevant benefit. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hao KA, Hones KM, O'Keefe DS, et al. Does the Relationship Between Preoperative Function and Achievement of Clinically Important Benchmarks of Success After Total Shoulder Arthroplasty Depend on Outcome Assessment Design? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2025. PMID: 39778205. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003347

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。