全膝关节置换术后屈曲不稳定的定义与诊断标准在已发表文献中高度不一致
该系统综述纳入2010至2023年发表的19篇关于全膝关节置换术后屈曲不稳定的临床研究,评估其定义与诊断标准的使用情况。仅58%的研究明确给出了屈曲不稳定的定义,各研究在临床症状、体格检查、关节穿刺、实验室检查和影像学参数的使用上差异很大;仅16%的研究将屈曲不稳定与中期不稳定相区分。作者认为定义不统一可能妨碍临床研究之间的比较,并提出标准化定义可改善该领域的研究与临床诊疗。
要点
- 19篇合格文献中仅58%明确给出了全膝关节置换术后屈曲不稳定的定义。
- 定义屈曲不稳定的研究中,89%描述了临床症状与体格检查,74%使用影像学分析。
- 53%使用关节穿刺、47%使用实验室检查以排除假体周围感染等其他失败原因。
核心结论
- 不足三分之二的以全膝关节置换术后屈曲不稳定患者为对象的临床研究给出了清晰、具体的屈曲不稳定定义。
- 关节穿刺、实验室检查和影像学因素的使用高度不一致。
- 许多作者仅宽松地定义诊断而缺乏客观标准,可能妨碍临床研究之间的比较。
- 作者认为标准化的屈曲不稳定定义可改善该主题的研究与临床诊疗。
研究设计与样本
- 系统检索2010至2023年发表的、英文的、报告全膝关节置换术后屈曲不稳定患者的临床导向原始研究。
- 纳入文献由多位评价者独立评估以确定屈曲不稳定的定义方式。
- 对定义了屈曲不稳定的文献,评估其诊断标准在临床症状、体格检查、关节穿刺结果、实验室评估和影像学参数等方面的使用情况。
- 共纳入19篇合格文献。
主要发现
- 19篇合格文献中仅58%明确给出了屈曲不稳定的定义,各研究间差异很大。
- 在定义屈曲不稳定的文献中,89%直接描述了有助于诊断的临床症状和体格检查发现。
- 74%的作者描述了使用影像学分析,53%使用关节穿刺,47%使用实验室值以帮助排除假体周围感染等其他失败原因。
- 仅16%的作者将屈曲不稳定与中期不稳定相区分。
关键数值与推荐
- 19篇文献中58%明确给出了屈曲不稳定的定义。
- 定义屈曲不稳定的文献中,89%描述了临床症状与体格检查发现,74%使用影像学分析,53%使用关节穿刺,47%使用实验室值,16%区分了屈曲不稳定与中期不稳定。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Flexion instability (FI) is increasingly being recognized as a common reason for failure after total knee arthroplasty (TKA). However, the diagnosis remains loosely defined and is often described by a constellation of symptoms and findings with the exclusion of other clinical entities. The purpose of this study was to examine the definition and diagnostic criteria of FI used in the current peer-reviewed literature. METHODS: Clinically oriented primary research articles reporting on patients who have FI after TKA and published in English from 2010 to 2023 were systematically identified. Included publications were independently evaluated by multiple reviewers to determine how FI was defined. Of articles that defined FI, the diagnostic criteria were evaluated for several metrics including clinical symptoms, physical examination findings, aspiration results, laboratory evaluations, and radiographic parameters. RESULTS: Of 19 eligible articles, only 58% clearly defined FI, with substantial variation among studies. Of these publications, 89% directly described clinical symptoms and physical examination findings that aided in diagnosis. Also, 74% of authors described using radiographic analysis, 53% used aspiration, and 47% used laboratory values to aid in excluding other causes of failure such as periprosthetic joint infection. Only 16% of authors distinguished FI from mid-FI. CONCLUSIONS: Less than two-thirds of clinical studies focusing on patients who have FI after TKA provided a clear, concrete definition of FI. The use of aspiration, laboratory values, and radiographic factors was highly variable. Importantly, many authors defined the diagnosis loosely without objective criteria, which may hinder comparison between clinical studies. A standardized definition of FI could improve research and clinical care on this topic.
引用
- Ramamurti P, Barakat N, Meneghini RM, et al. The Definition and Diagnostic Criteria for Flexion Instability After Total Knee Arthroplasty Is Highly Variable in the Published Literature. J Arthroplasty. 2025. PMID: 39863060. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2025.01.022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。