文献速递关节外科

骨水泥植入综合征真的由骨水泥引起吗?基于Bradford-Hill标准的系统文献综述

Is Bone Cement Implantation Syndrome Actually Caused by Cement? A Systematic Review of the Literature Using the Bradford-Hill Criteria.
PubMed 文献 · J Arthroplasty · 2025-01-28

该系统综述纳入2010至2023年发表的52篇关于骨水泥植入综合征(BCIS)的文章,采用Bradford-Hill九项流行病学标准评估骨水泥暴露与BCIS之间的因果关系。结果显示,五项标准(关联强度、特异性、剂量反应关系、一致性、实验)几乎无支持证据,时间性和合理性有中等支持,一致性和类比有强支持。结论认为目前证据不足以确立骨水泥与BCIS之间的因果关系,术中低血压、缺氧和/或心血管崩溃并非骨水泥使用所独有。

要点

  • 基于52篇文章的Bradford-Hill标准评估显示,骨水泥与BCIS因果关系的证据不足。
  • 术中低血压、缺氧和/或心血管崩溃可发生于骨水泥手术,但并非骨水泥使用所独有。
  • BCIS的诊断和时间线高度模糊,非致命性BCIS的临床相关性不明确。

核心结论

  • 目前似乎没有足够证据能确切确立骨水泥与BCIS之间的因果关系。
  • 骨科医生和麻醉医生在将术中并发症仅归因于骨水泥使用时应该谨慎,并考虑其他解释。
  • BCIS这一术语本身可能是一个误称,因为该现象可能在无骨水泥的情况下发生。
  • 在建立骨水泥使用与BCIS之间因果关系的更强证据出现之前,避免BCIS似乎不是反对骨水泥固定的有力论据。

研究设计与样本

  • 对2010年至2023年发表的关于BCIS的文章进行了系统综述。
  • 使用Bradford-Hill标准,制定了一套九项流行病学原则来评估暴露与结局之间的关系。
  • 两名评价者独立审阅文章,并确定每项标准及骨水泥-BCIS总体关系的支持水平。
  • 基于52篇符合条件的文章进行分析。

主要发现

  • 五项标准几乎无或没有支持:关联强度、特异性、剂量反应关系、一致性、实验。
  • 时间性和合理性有中等支持。
  • 一致性和类比有强支持。
  • 术中低血压、缺氧和/或心血管崩溃可能在骨水泥手术期间出现,但其发生并非骨水泥使用所独有,可归因于多种其他潜在原因。
  • BCIS的诊断和时间线高度模糊,非致命性BCIS的临床相关性不明确。

临床怎么用

  • 骨科医生和麻醉医生在将术中并发症仅归因于骨水泥使用时应该谨慎,并考虑其他解释。
  • 在建立骨水泥使用与BCIS之间因果关系的更强证据出现之前,避免BCIS似乎不是反对骨水泥固定的有力论据。

局限性

  • BCIS的诊断和时间线高度模糊,非致命性BCIS的临床相关性不明确。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Debate surrounding the use of cemented femoral components in hip arthroplasty persists. A proposed risk of cement fixation is bone cement implantation syndrome (BCIS), a phenomenon characterized by intraoperative hypotension, hypoxia, and/or cardiovascular collapse. The purpose of this study was to analyze the literature to determine if enough evidence exists to support a causal relationship between cement and BCIS. METHODS: A systematic review of articles on BCIS published from 2010 to 2023 was performed. Using the Bradford-Hill criteria, a set of nine epidemiological principles were developed to evaluate the relationship between exposure and outcome, and two reviewers independently reviewed the articles and determined the level of support for each criterion and the overall cement-BCIS relationship. RESULTS: Based on 52 eligible articles, there was little to no support for five criteria: strength of association, specificity, dose-response relationship, coherence, and experiment. There was moderate support for temporality and plausibility and strong support for consistency and analogy. Although intraoperative hypotension, hypoxia, and/or cardiovascular collapse may manifest during cemented surgeries, their occurrence is not exclusive to cement utilization and can be attributed to multiple other potential causes. Furthermore, the diagnosis and timeline of BCIS are highly ambiguous, and the clinical relevance of nonfatal BCIS is unclear. CONCLUSIONS: There appears to be insufficient evidence to conclusively establish a causal link between cement and BCIS. Orthopaedic surgeons and anesthesiologists should exercise caution when attributing intraoperative complications solely to cement usage and consider alternative explanations. The term "BCIS' itself may be a misnomer, as this phenomenon may occur in the absence of cement. Until there is stronger evidence to establish a causal link between cement use and BCIS, avoidance of BCIS does not appear to be a strong argument against cementation.

来源:J Arthroplasty,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Barakat N, Browne JA. Is Bone Cement Implantation Syndrome Actually Caused by Cement? A Systematic Review of the Literature Using the Bradford-Hill Criteria. J Arthroplasty. 2025. PMID: 39884480. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2025.01.039

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。