青少年特发性脊柱侧凸患者椎旁肌激活起始不对称性与对称脊柱者的差异
该横断面研究纳入24例女性青少年特发性脊柱侧凸(AIS)患者(平均年龄14±2岁)和20名年龄性别匹配的对照(13±2岁),在快速双侧抬臂任务中记录竖脊肌表面肌电。结果发现T9/顶点水平竖脊肌激活时间不对称性在组间存在差异,AIS组右侧(凸侧)较左侧提前6±17毫秒,对照组左侧较右侧提前8±19毫秒。AIS组T9/顶点激活不对称幅度与Cobb角或Risser分期无关联。
要点
- AIS组T9/顶点水平竖脊肌激活右侧(凸侧)较左侧提前6±17毫秒,对照组左侧较右侧提前8±19毫秒。
- 组间T9/顶点激活时间不对称差异为14±23毫秒(p<0.01),源于AIS组左侧(凹侧)T9竖脊肌激活较对照组延迟13±26毫秒(p=0.01)。
- AIS组T9/顶点竖脊肌激活不对称幅度与Cobb角或Risser分期无关联。
核心结论
- 快速双侧抬臂任务中,竖脊肌激活在T9/顶点椎体水平呈不对称,AIS组与对照组方向相反,AIS组左侧激活延迟。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,2022年8月至2023年9月在澳大利亚布里斯班一家脊柱门诊和一家脊柱侧凸康复门诊通过传单招募受试者。
- 纳入24例女性AIS患者(平均±标准差年龄14±2岁,均为原发性右胸弯,由骨科专家诊断)和20名年龄性别匹配的无AIS对照(年龄13±2岁,从当地社区招募)。
- 排除有脊柱手术史、神经疾病或肌肉骨骼疾病(AIS除外)者;任务为视觉提示下快速双侧屈臂,表面电极置于双侧三角肌前束及C7、T9(AIS顶点)、T12、L5相邻竖脊肌。
主要发现
- T9/顶点水平竖脊肌激活时间不对称性组间差异为14±23毫秒(p<0.01);AIS组右侧(凸侧)较左侧提前6±17毫秒,对照组左侧较右侧提前8±19毫秒。
- 组间差异源于AIS组左侧(凹侧)T9/顶点竖脊肌激活较对照组延迟,平均组间差异13±26毫秒(p=0.01)。
- 其他椎体水平无组间差异;AIS组内T9/顶点竖脊肌激活不对称幅度与Cobb角或Risser分期无关联。
- 两组间双侧三角肌相对光信号的激活起始或手臂峰值速度无差异。
临床怎么用
- 作者指出,结合既往研究,这些结果支持进一步研究不对称椎旁肌力是否可能促进AIS的侧弯进展和不对称骨发育。
- 作者指出这一点重要,因为肌力可通过针对性康复进行调节。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) is characterized by an asymmetrical formation of the spine and ribcage. Recent work provides evidence of asymmetrical (right versus left side) paraspinal muscle size, composition, and activation amplitude in adolescents with AIS. Each of these factors influences muscle force generation. The timing of paraspinal muscle activation may also contribute to an asymmetry in the timing of forces applied to the spine. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: The main objectives were to determine (1) whether the timing and asymmetry of erector spinae muscle activation during a rapid bilateral arm raise task differs between adolescents with AIS and those without AIS and (2) whether the magnitude of erector spinae activation asymmetry in AIS is associated with scoliosis curve severity (Cobb angle) or skeletal development level (Risser stage). Finally, (3) we investigated potential kinematic confounders to determine whether symmetry of bilateral rapid arm movements differed between those with and without AIS, and whether any asymmetry in arm movement was associated with erector spinae activation asymmetry. METHODS: All patients were made aware of the project through flyers at one outpatient spine clinic and a scoliosis rehabilitation clinic in Brisbane, Australia. They were invited between August 2022 and September 2023 to contribute if they met the selection criteria. This cross-sectional study included females with AIS who agreed to participate (n = 24, mean ± SD age of 14 ± 2 years). They all had a primary right-thoracic curve, diagnosed by an orthopaedic specialist. Twenty age- and sex-matched controls (age 13 ± 2 years) who did not have AIS were recruited from the local community. Volunteers (from either group) were excluded if they had any history of spinal surgery, neurological disorders, or musculoskeletal disorders (other than AIS). The experimental task required participants to perform a bilateral rapid arm flexion in response to a visual cue. Muscle activation was recorded using surface electrodes, placed bilaterally on the anterior deltoid and erector spinae adjacent to the C7, T9 (the curve apex for AIS), T12, and L5 vertebrae. Muscle activation onsets were determined from 6 of 10 trials with the quickest deltoid onset for each participant. A linear mixed model (with fixed factors) was used to determine whether activation asymmetry (left-right onset difference) differed between groups (AIS, control) and vertebral level (C7, T9/apex, T12, and L5). Where a group difference in onset asymmetry was identified, the relation of the Cobb angle and Risser stage with the magnitude of asymmetry was evaluated in the AIS cohort using a linear mixed model. Task kinematics, including peak angular arm movement velocity and deltoid onset relative to the light signal, were analyzed using a linear mixed model with group and side as fixed factors. RESULTS: Erector spinae activation timing asymmetry differed between groups at the T9/apex (mean difference 14 ± 23 ms; p < 0.01). In the AIS group, muscle activation was 6 ± 17 ms earlier on the right (convex) relative to the left side of the spine, whereas in controls, activation was 8 ± 19 ms earlier on the left relative to the right side. This difference in activation timing asymmetry between groups was explained by later activation of the T9 level erector spinae muscles on the left (concave) side of the spine in AIS compared with controls (mean group difference of left T9/apex erector spinae onset 13 ± 26 ms; p = 0.01). There were no between-group differences at other vertebral levels. Within the AIS group, no association was observed between the magnitude of the erector spinae activation asymmetry measured at T9/apex and Cobb angle or Risser stage. There were no differences between groups in either the bilateral deltoid onset relative to light or arm peak velocity. CONCLUSION: Erector spinae muscle activation is asymmetrical at the T9/apex vertebral level during a rapid bilateral arm raise task. This asymmetry was opposite between the AIS and control cohorts, with left-side activation delayed in AIS. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: It is well established in conditions such as cerebral palsy that muscles forces can influence bone development in children. In children with AIS, there is growing evidence of asymmetrical paraspinal muscle size, composition, and activation amplitude. Each of these factors contribute to paraspinal muscle force generation. Our findings add to what we know by identifying an asymmetry in the timing of erector spinae activation during a well-controlled, bilateral movement task. Combined with previous research, these results support further investigation into whether asymmetrical paraspinal muscle forces might contribute to the curve progression and asymmetrical bony development in AIS. This is important as muscle forces are modifiable through targeted rehabilitation.
引用
- Dupuis F, Ng PTT, Duncombe P, et al. Asymmetry in the Onset of Paraspinal Muscles Activity Differs in Adolescents With Idiopathic Scoliosis Compared With Those With a Symmetrical Spine. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2025. PMID: 39774429. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003364
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。