SECEC Grammont奖2024:姿势调整在反式全肩关节置换术前规划中对活动度模拟的关键作用
本研究将全肱骨与肩胛骨的统计形状模型拟合入10例反式全肩关节置换患者的肩部CT,由6名肩外科医生使用原型软件分别在调整与不调整肩胸朝向的情况下模拟活动度。结果显示所有运动平面的模拟活动度在调整姿势后均显著降低,外旋从62°降至25°,作者认为需重新评估既往基于传统规划软件的研究。
要点
- 调整肩胸朝向后,模拟外旋由62°(SD 16°)降至25°(SD 9°),差异有统计学意义(p < 0.001)。
- 调整姿势后模拟伸展由57°(SD 18°)降至24°(SD 11°),C型姿势平均差异最大为47°(SD 18°)。
- 调整姿势后模拟外展内旋由69°(SD 11°)降至31°(SD 6°),C型姿势平均差异最大为51°(SD 11°)。
核心结论
- 考虑肩胸朝向对所有运动平面的反式全肩关节置换模拟活动度均有显著影响,尤其是外旋、伸展和高位内旋的数值大幅降低。
- 作者认为本研究观察到的显著差异需要批判性重新评估所有既往使用传统术前规划软件研究假体选择与放置以优化活动度的已发表研究。
研究设计与样本
- 将全肱骨与肩胛骨的统计形状模型拟合入从162例接受反式全肩关节置换患者中随机选取的10例肩部CT扫描。
- 6名肩外科医生使用原型开发软件独立规划反式全肩关节置换,该软件可调整肩胸朝向、肱骨起始位置及全局参考系中的运动学平面,模拟先前描述的A、B、C型姿势。
- 计算并比较所有运动平面中调整与不调整姿势的活动度。
主要发现
- 所有运动平面在调整与不调整姿势的方案间均显示显著差异。
- 不调整时平均外旋为62°(SD 16°),调整姿势后为25°(SD 9°)(p < 0.001),C型姿势平均差异最大为49°(SD 15°)。
- 不调整时平均伸展为57°(SD 18°),调整后为24°(SD 11°)(p < 0.001),C型姿势平均差异最大为47°(SD 18°)。
- 不调整时平均外展内旋为69°(SD 11°),调整姿势后为31°(SD 6°)(p < 0.001),C型姿势平均差异最大为51°(SD 11°)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: The objective of this study was to compare simulated range of motion (ROM) for reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (rTSA) with and without adjustment for scapulothoracic orientation in a global reference system. We hypothesized that values for simulated ROM in preoperative planning software with and without adjustment for scapulothoracic orientation would be significantly different. METHODS: A statistical shape model of the entire humerus and scapula was fitted into ten shoulder CT scans randomly selected from 162 patients who underwent rTSA. Six shoulder surgeons independently planned a rTSA in each model using prototype development software with the ability to adjust for scapulothoracic orientation, the starting position of the humerus, as well as kinematic planes in a global reference system simulating previously described posture types A, B, and C. ROM with and without posture adjustment was calculated and compared in all movement planes. RESULTS: All movement planes showed significant differences when comparing protocols with and without adjustment for posture. The largest mean difference was seen in external rotation, being 62° (SD 16°) without adjustment compared to 25° (SD 9°) with posture adjustment (p < 0.001), with the highest mean difference being 49° (SD 15°) in type C. Mean extension was 57° (SD 18°) without adjustment versus 24° (SD 11°) with adjustment (p < 0.001) and the highest mean difference of 47° (SD 18°) in type C. Mean abducted internal rotation was 69° (SD 11°) without adjustment versus 31° (SD 6°) with posture adjustment (p < 0.001), showing the highest mean difference of 51° (SD 11°) in type C. CONCLUSION: The present study demonstrates that accounting for scapulothoracic orientation has a significant impact on simulated ROM for rTSA in all motion planes, specifically rendering vastly lower values for external rotation, extension, and high internal rotation. The substantial differences observed in this study warrant a critical re-evaluation of all previously published studies that examined component choice and placement for optimized ROM in rTSA using conventional preoperative planning software.
引用
- Moroder P, Poltaretskyi S, Raiss P, et al. SECEC Grammont Award 2024: The critical role of posture adjustment for range of motion simulation in reverse total shoulder arthroplasty preoperative planning. Bone Joint J. 2024. PMID: 39481444. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.106B11.BJJ-2024-0110.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。