文献速递骨肿瘤关节外科

自由hand、患者特异性器械或手术导航在肿瘤切除后同种异体骨重建中表现更优吗?一项临床前合成骨研究

Does Freehand, Patient-specific Instrumentation or Surgical Navigation Perform Better for Allograft Reconstruction After Tumor Resection? A Preclinical Synthetic Bone Study.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2024-05-15

该临床前合成骨研究让7名外科医生按相同顺序使用自由hand、患者特异性器械和手术导航三种方式,为标准化骨缺损塑形合成骨以模拟肿瘤切除后重建。结果显示三种方式的心理负荷无差异;手术导航和患者特异性器械的塑形符合度均略优于自由hand,手术导航的定性匹配评分略高于患者特异性器械;手术时间无差异。作者认为这些差异的临床意义需进一步研究。

要点

  • 手术导航和患者特异性器械的塑形符合度(均方根偏差)略优于自由hand。
  • 手术导航的定性匹配评分略高于患者特异性器械,但作者认为无临床重要差异。
  • 三种方式的心理负荷和手术时间无差异。

核心结论

  • 基于肿瘤切除后标准化关节周围骨缺损重建的手术模拟,手术导航在定性匹配上可能略优于患者特异性器械,但两者塑形移植物与标准化肿瘤切除后骨缺损的符合度均略优于自由hand技术。
  • 确定这些差异是否具有临床意义需要进一步研究。

研究设计与样本

  • 临床前合成骨研究,7名外科医生按相同顺序(自由hand、患者特异性器械、手术导航)使用三种方式为标准化骨缺损塑形合成骨以模拟肿瘤切除后重建。
  • 使用NASA心理任务负荷指数问卷和手术时间进行记录;采用锥形束CT图像测量塑形移植物与计算机生成理想骨模型之间的符合度(均方根指标,单位mm)。
  • 另由6名资深外科医生在不知晓方式的情况下,使用10点Likert量表对移植物植入标准化肿瘤缺损的匹配质量进行评分。

主要发现

  • 自由hand、患者特异性器械和手术导航三种技术的NASA总任务负荷评分无差异。
  • 符合度均方根值(均值±标准差):手术导航2±0 mm与患者特异性器械2±1 mm无差异;两者均较自由hand(3±1 mm)有小幅改善。自由hand与手术导航的平均差为1 mm(95%CI 0.5至1.1;p=0.01);自由hand与患者特异性器械的平均差为1 mm(95%CI -0.1至0.9;p=0.02);患者特异性器械与手术导航的平均差为0 mm(95%CI -0.5至0.2;p=0.82)。
  • 塑形移植物匹配质量评分(中位数[四分位距]):手术导航7[6至8]与患者特异性器械6[5至7.8]之间无临床重要差异;两者均高于自由hand的3[2至4]。自由hand与手术导航的中位数差为4(p<0.001);自由hand与患者特异性器械的中位数差为3(p<0.001);患者特异性器械与手术导航的中位数差为1(p=0.03)。
  • 手术时间(均值±标准差):自由hand为16±10分钟,患者特异性器械为14±9分钟,手术导航为24±8分钟;三种塑形方式的手术时间无差异(自由hand与患者特异性器械:平均差2分钟[95%CI 0至7];p=0.92;自由hand与手术导航:平均差8分钟[95%CI 0至20];p=0.23;患者特异性器械与手术导航:平均差10分钟[95%CI 1至19];p=0.12)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 符合度采用均方根指标(mm)测量,多组比较采用方差分析(ANOVA),p<0.05为显著。
  • 匹配质量采用10点Likert量表评分。

临床怎么用

  • 本文所介绍的手术导航系统为实验室研究开发产品,尚未准备广泛部署于临床实践,但目前已在研究手术室环境中用于患者照护。
  • 该新技术存在学习曲线、资本成本和潜在风险。
  • 所报告的初步结果基于临床前合成骨肿瘤研究,不如实际手术场景真实。

局限性

  • 所报告的初步结果基于临床前合成骨肿瘤研究,不如实际手术场景真实。
  • 本研究为小队列研究,仅涉及一种标准化合成关节周围骨肿瘤缺损场景。
  • 确定这些差异是否具有临床意义需要进一步研究。
  • 该新技术存在学习曲线、资本成本和潜在风险。
  • 手术导航系统尚未准备广泛部署于临床实践。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Joint-sparing resection of periarticular bone tumors can be challenging because of complex geometry. Successful reconstruction of periarticular bone defects after tumor resection is often performed with structural allografts to allow for joint preservation. However, achieving a size-matched allograft to fill the defect can be challenging because allograft sizes vary, they do not always match a patient's anatomy, and cutting the allograft to perfectly fit the defect is demanding. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Is there a difference in mental workload among the freehand, patient-specific instrumentation, and surgical navigation approaches? (2) Is there a difference in conformance (quantitative measure of deviation from the ideal bone graft), elapsed time during reconstruction, and qualitative assessment of goodness-of-fit of the allograft reconstruction among the approaches? METHODS: Seven surgeons used three modalities in the same order (freehand, patient-specific instrumentation, and surgical navigation) to fashion synthetic bone to reconstruct a standardized bone defect. National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) mental task load index questionnaires and procedure time were captured. Cone-beam CT images of the shaped allografts were used to measure conformance (quantitative measure of deviation from the ideal bone graft) to a computer-generated ideal bone graft model. Six additional (senior) surgeons blinded to modality scored the quality of fit of the allografts into the standardized tumor defect using a 10-point Likert scale. We measured conformance using the root-mean-square metric in mm and used ANOVA for multipaired comparisons (p < 0.05 was significant). RESULTS: There was no difference in mental NASA total task load scores among the freehand, patient-specific instrumentation, and surgical navigation techniques. We found no difference in conformance root-mean-square values (mean ± SD) between surgical navigation (2 ± 0 mm; mean values have been rounded to whole numbers) and patient-specific instrumentation (2 ± 1 mm), but both showed a small improvement compared with the freehand approach (3 ± 1 mm). For freehand versus surgical navigation, the mean difference was 1 mm (95% confidence interval [CI] 0.5 to 1.1; p = 0.01). For freehand versus patient-specific instrumentation, the mean difference was 1 mm (95% CI -0.1 to 0.9; p = 0.02). For patient-specific instrumentation versus surgical navigation, the mean difference was 0 mm (95% CI -0.5 to 0.2; p = 0.82). In evaluating the goodness of fit of the shaped grafts, we found no clinically important difference between surgical navigation (median [IQR] 7 [6 to 8]) and patient-specific instrumentation (median 6 [5 to 7.8]), although both techniques had higher scores than the freehand technique did (median 3 [2 to 4]). For freehand versus surgical navigation, the difference of medians was 4 (p < 0.001). For freehand versus patient-specific instrumentation, the difference of medians was 3 (p < 0.001). For patient-specific instrumentation versus surgical navigation, the difference of medians was 1 (p = 0.03). The mean ± procedural times for freehand was 16 ± 10 minutes, patient-specific instrumentation was 14 ± 9 minutes, and surgical navigation techniques was 24 ± 8 minutes. We found no differences in procedure times across three shaping modalities (freehand versus patient-specific instrumentation: mean difference 2 minutes [95% CI 0 to 7]; p = 0.92; freehand versus surgical navigation: mean difference 8 minutes [95% CI 0 to 20]; p = 0.23; patient-specific instrumentation versus surgical navigation: mean difference 10 minutes [95% CI 1 to 19]; p = 0.12). CONCLUSION: Based on surgical simulation to reconstruct a standardized periarticular bone defect after tumor resection, we found a possible small advantage to surgical navigation over patient-specific instrumentation based on qualitative fit, but both techniques provided slightly better conformance of the shaped graft for fit into the standardized post-tumor resection bone defect than the freehand technique did. To determine whether these differences are clinically meaningful requires further study. The surgical navigation system presented here is a product of laboratory research development, and although not ready to be widely deployed for clinical practice, it is currently being used in a research operating room setting for patient care. This new technology is associated with a learning curve, capital costs, and potential risk. The reported preliminary results are based on a preclinical synthetic bone tumor study, which is not as realistic as actual surgical scenarios. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Surgical navigation systems are an emerging technology in orthopaedic and reconstruction surgery, and understanding their capabilities and limitations is paramount for clinical practice. Given our preliminary findings in a small cohort study with one scenario of standardized synthetic periarticular bone tumor defects, future investigations should include different surgical scenarios using allograft and cadaveric specimens in a more realistic surgical setting.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Chan HHL, Nayak P, Alshaygy I, et al. Does Freehand, Patient-specific Instrumentation or Surgical Navigation Perform Better for Allograft Reconstruction After Tumor Resection? A Preclinical Synthetic Bone Study. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2024. PMID: 38813958. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003116

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。