文献速递关节外科

在9个骨科注册中心验证骨科数据评估小组(ODEP)评级:有ODEP评级的全髋植入物表现优于无评级者

Validating Orthopaedic Data Evaluation Panel (ODEP) Ratings Across 9 Orthopaedic Registries: Total Hip Implants with an ODEP Rating Perform Better Than Those without an ODEP Rating.
PubMed 文献 · J Bone Joint Surg Am · 2024-05-31

研究在9个骨科注册中心匹配全髋和全膝植入物的ODEP评级与累积翻修风险(CRR),采用随机效应模型Meta分析汇总CRR并用ODEP基准分类。结果显示有ODEP评级的全髋植入物在各随访时间点CRR均低于无评级者,但A*与A评级间总体无差异;全膝植入物因匹配率低未进一步分析。

要点

  • 有ODEP评级的全髋植入物在3、5、10年CRR均低于无评级者,但全髋柄5年差异不显著。
  • A*与A评级全髋植入物CRR总体无差异,仅A*A*杯柄组合3年CRR显著更低。
  • 39%的A*杯和42%的A*柄按汇总CRR仍为A*,但24%的A杯和31%的A柄也会被评为A*。

核心结论

  • 在所有随访时间点,有ODEP评级的全髋植入物CRR均低于无ODEP评级的全髋植入物。
  • 鉴于全髋植入物表现存在国家间差异,注册中心应首先用本国翻修数据验证ODEP评级以更好指导本国植入物选择。
  • 数据来源透明化和使用多个注册中心的翻修数据将强化ODEP基准。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究将注册中心报告的全髋和全膝植入物特定3年、5年和10年CRR按植入物名称与ODEP评级匹配。
  • 采用随机效应模型Meta分析汇总CRR,并使用ODEP基准标准对汇总CRR进行分类。

主要发现

  • 共有313个全髋杯(54%)、356个全髋柄(58%)、218个全髋杯柄组合(34%)和68个全膝植入物(13%)具有唯一品牌名称并被匹配到ODEP评级。
  • 由于匹配比例低,全膝植入物未进一步分析。
  • 有ODEP评级的全髋植入物在所有随访时间点CRR均低于无ODEP评级的全髋植入物,但全髋柄5年差异不显著。
  • A*与A评级全髋植入物之间CRR总体无差异,例外是全髋杯柄组合中A*A*评级组合在3年时间点CRR显著更低。
  • 39%的A*评级杯和42%的A*评级柄基于汇总注册中心3年CRR会获得A*评级,但24%的A评级杯和31%的A评级柄也会获得A*评级,更长随访显示类似结果。

关键数值与推荐

  • ODEP评级A*代表较A更高的评级。
  • 全髋杯匹配ODEP评级313个(54%),全髋柄356个(58%),全髋杯柄组合218个(34%),全膝植入物68个(13%)。
  • 39%的A*评级杯和42%的A*评级柄基于汇总注册中心3年CRR获得A*评级;24%的A评级杯和31%的A评级柄也获得A*评级。

临床怎么用

  • 注册中心应首先使用本国翻修数据验证ODEP评级,以更好指导本国的植入物选择。
  • 数据来源透明化和使用多个注册中心的翻修数据可强化ODEP基准。

局限性

  • 全膝植入物仅有13%匹配到ODEP评级,因匹配比例低未进一步分析。
  • 全髋柄5年CRR差异不显著。
  • A*与A评级全髋植入物CRR总体无差异,仅全髋杯柄组合3年时间点A*A*评级CRR显著更低。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Orthopaedic Data Evaluation Panel (ODEP) ratings of total hip (TH) and total knee (TK) implants are informative for assessing implant performance. However, the validity of ODEP ratings across multiple registries is unknown. Therefore, we aimed to assess, across multiple registries, whether TH and TK implants with a higher ODEP rating (i.e., an A* rating) have lower cumulative revision risks (CRRs) than those with a lower ODEP rating (i.e., an A rating) and the extent to which A* and A-rated implants would be A*-rated on the basis of the pooled registries' CRR. METHODS: Implant-specific CRRs at 3, 5, and 10 years that were reported by registries were matched to ODEP ratings on the basis of the implant name. A meta-analysis with random-effects models was utilized for pooling the CRRs. ODEP benchmark criteria were utilized to classify these pooled CRRs. RESULTS: A total of 313 TH cups (54%), 356 TH stems (58%), 218 TH cup-stem combinations (34%), and 68 TK implants (13%) with unique brand names reported by registries were matched to an ODEP rating. Given the low percentage that matched, TK implants were not further analyzed. ODEP-matched TH implants had lower CRRs than TH implants without an ODEP rating at all follow-up time points, although the difference for TH stems was not significant at 5 years. No overall differences in CRRs were found between A* and A-rated TH implants, with the exception of TH cup-stem combinations, which demonstrated a significantly lower CRR for A*A*-rated cup-stem combinations at the 3-year time point. Thirty-nine percent of A*-rated cups and 42% of A*-rated stems would receive an A* rating on the basis of the pooled registries' CRR at 3 years; however, 24% of A-rated cups and 31% of A-rated stems would also receive an A* rating, with similar findings demonstrated at longer follow-up. CONCLUSIONS: At all follow-up time points, ODEP-matched TH implants had lower CRRs than TH implants without an ODEP rating. Given that the performance of TH implants varied across countries, registries should first validate ODEP ratings with use of country-specific revision data to better guide implant selection in their country. Data source transparency and the use of revision data from multiple registries would strengthen the ODEP benchmarks. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic Level III . See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

来源:J Bone Joint Surg Am,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hoogervorst LA, van Tilburg MM, Lübbeke A, et al. Validating Orthopaedic Data Evaluation Panel (ODEP) Ratings Across 9 Orthopaedic Registries: Total Hip Implants with an ODEP Rating Perform Better Than Those without an ODEP Rating. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2024. PMID: 38820172. doi:10.2106/JBJS.23.00793

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。