关节置换研究中性别与社会性别术语使用的系统综述:仍有改进空间
该系统综述评估了5本领先骨科期刊2022年1月1日后发表的100篇关节置换原创临床研究,其中98篇测量了性别或社会性别构念;15篇使用社会性别术语,45篇使用性别术语,38篇混用两者且无一能区分使用;所有文章均将性别呈现为二分类变量,仅2篇明确定义了性别或社会性别,31篇用于统计调整但仅6篇报告分层结果。
要点
- 98/100篇关节置换研究测量了性别或社会性别构念,但术语使用混乱。
- 38篇混用社会性别与性别术语的文章中,无一能区分使用两者。
- 所有文章均将性别呈现为二分类变量,仅2篇明确定义性别或社会性别。
核心结论
- 关节置换文章很少描述性别或社会性别是如何测量的,并且经常互换使用这些术语。
- 这些文章很少提供超过两个选项来捕捉性别和社会性别的变异。
- 未来研究应更精确地处理这些变量,以提高结果质量并确保发现以患者为中心且具有包容性。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,审查5本发表关节置换研究的领先骨科期刊,识别2022年1月1日后发表的关于关节置换主题的前20篇原创临床研究文章,共100篇。
- 记录是否使用社会性别或性别术语、使用是否可区分,以及是否基于社会性别或性别进行分层或调整。
主要发现
- 100篇文章中有98篇测量了社会性别或性别的构念。
- 在98篇中,15篇使用社会性别术语,45篇使用性别术语,38篇混合使用社会性别和性别术语。
- 在38篇混合使用术语的文章中,没有一篇可区分地使用术语。
- 所有文章均将社会性别和性别呈现为二分类变量,2篇尝试明确定义社会性别或性别是如何定义的。
- 在98篇文章中,31篇将这些变量用于统计调整,但仅6篇报告了分层结果。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There is increasing appreciation of the distinction between gender and sex as well as the importance of accurately reporting these constructs. Given recent attention regarding transgender and gender nonconforming (TGNC) and intersex identities, it is more necessary than ever to understand how to describe these identities in research. This study sought to investigate the use of gender- and sex-based terminology in arthroplasty research. METHODS: The 5 leading orthopaedic journals publishing arthroplasty research were reviewed to identify the first twenty primary clinical research articles on an arthroplasty topic published after January 1, 2022. Use of gender- or sex-based terminology, whether use was discriminate, and whether stratification or adjustment based on gender or sex was performed, were recorded. RESULTS: There were 98 of 100 articles that measured a construct of gender or sex. Of these, 15 articles used gender-based terminology, 45 used sex-based terminology, and 38 used a combination of gender- and sex-based terminology. Of the 38 articles using a combination of terminology, none did so discriminately. All articles presented gender and sex as binary variables, and 2 attempted to explicitly define how gender or sex were defined. Of the 98 articles, 31 used these variables for statistical adjustments, though only 6 reported stratified results. CONCLUSIONS: Arthroplasty articles infrequently describe how gender or sex was measured, and frequently use this terminology interchangeably. Additionally, these articles rarely offer more than 2 options for capturing variation in sex and gender. Future research should be more precise in the treatment of these variables to improve the quality of results and ensure findings are patient-centered and inclusive.
引用
- Bellamy JL, Goodrich ER, Sabatini FM, et al. Systematic Review of Gender and Sex Terminology Use in Arthroplasty Research: There Is Room for Improvement. J Arthroplasty. 2024. PMID: 38734326. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2024.05.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。