全髋关节置换术与教育加运动对比:对266例髋骨关节炎患者的倾向性匹配分析
该倾向性匹配研究纳入778例髋骨关节炎患者(教育加运动组303例,全髋关节置换术组475例),按1:1匹配后得到266例(每组133例)。12个月随访时,全髋关节置换术在疼痛、功能和生活质量方面的改善显著优于教育加运动,但17%至30%的教育加运动患者仍达到有临床意义改善的手术阈值。
要点
- 匹配后266例患者中,全髋关节置换术组在12个月时的疼痛、功能和生活质量改善均显著优于教育加运动组。
- 17%至30%的教育加运动患者达到有临床意义改善的手术阈值,而全髋关节置换术患者为84%至90%。
- 作者认为教育加运动可能使部分患者推迟全髋关节置换术,但需验证性试验确认。
核心结论
- 全髋关节置换术在疼痛、功能和生活质量方面提供更大的改善。
- 相当比例的教育加运动患者获得有临床意义的改善,提示教育加运动可能使部分患者推迟全髋关节置换术,但需验证性试验确认。
研究设计与样本
- 倾向性匹配研究,纳入778例髋骨关节炎患者(教育加运动组303例,全髋关节置换术组475例),基于治疗前特征计算倾向评分并按1:1比例匹配。
- 匹配样本共266例(教育加运动组133例,全髋关节置换术组133例),除阿片类药物使用外,所有治疗前特征均平衡。
- 采用线性混合模型估计从治疗前到3个月和12个月随访时疼痛、功能和生活质量变化值的组间平均差异。
主要发现
- 12个月随访时,全髋关节置换术组疼痛改善显著大于教育加运动组(平均差异35.4;95%置信区间31.4至39.4)。
- 12个月随访时,全髋关节置换术组功能改善显著大于教育加运动组(平均差异30.5;95%置信区间26.3至34.7)。
- 12个月随访时,全髋关节置换术组生活质量改善显著大于教育加运动组(平均差异33.6;95%置信区间28.8至38.4)。
- 17%至30%的教育加运动患者达到有临床意义改善的手术阈值,而全髋关节置换术患者为84%至90%。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为教育加运动可能使部分患者推迟全髋关节置换术,但需验证性试验确认。
局限性
- 匹配样本在除阿片类药物使用外的所有治疗前特征上平衡,即阿片类药物使用未达平衡。
- 作者指出需验证性试验确认教育加运动可能推迟全髋关节置换术的观察结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Total hip arthroplasty (THA) for osteoarthritis (OA) is a major health system cost. Education and exercise (Edu + Ex) programs may reduce the number of THAs needed, but supporting data are limited. This study aimed to estimate the treatment effect of THA versus Edu + Ex on pain, function, and quality of life outcomes 3 and 12 months after treatment initiation for hip OA. METHODS: Patients who had hip OA who underwent THA or an Edu + Ex program were included in this propensity-matched study. In 778 patients (Edu + Ex, n = 303; THA, n = 475), propensity scores were based on pretreatment characteristics, and patients were matched on a 1:1 ratio. Between-group treatment effects (pain, function, and quality of life) were estimated as the mean difference (MD) in change from pretreatment to 3-month and 12-month follow-up using linear mixed models. RESULTS: The matched sample consisted of 266 patients (Edu + Ex, n = 133; THA, n = 133) who were balanced on all pretreatment characteristics except opioid use. At 12-month follow-up, THA resulted in significantly greater improvements in pain (MD 35.4; 95% confidence interval [CI] 31.4 to 39.4), function (MD 30.5; 95% CI 26.3 to 34.7), and quality of life (MD 33.6; 95% CI 28.8 to 38.4). Between 17% and 30% of patients receiving Edu + Ex experienced a surgical threshold for clinically meaningful improvement in outcomes, compared to 84% and 90% of THA patients. CONCLUSIONS: A THA provides greater improvements in pain, function, and quality of life. A notable proportion of Edu + Ex patients had clinically meaningful improvements, suggesting Edu + Ex may result in THA deferral in some patients, but confirmatory trials are needed.
引用
- Young JJ, Zywiel MG, Skou ST, et al. Total Hip Arthroplasty Versus Education and Exercise: A Propensity-Matched Analysis of 266 Patients Who Have Hip Osteoarthritis. J Arthroplasty. 2024. PMID: 38697319. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2024.04.072
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。