ASES与UCLA量表在肩袖修复术后具有反应性:一项系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析纳入252项研究(32072例患者),比较肩袖修复术后多种患者报告结局量表的反应性,发现UCLA(效应量2.51)和ASES(效应量2.00)反应性最高,ASES较VAS、Constant、SST和SANE更敏感,UCLA较ASES、VAS、Constant和SST更敏感,作者建议广泛采用ASES和UCLA量表。
要点
- 共识别67种PROM工具,最常用为ASES(73%)、VAS(65%)和Constant(47%)。
- 效应量最高的3种PROM为UCLA(2.51)、WORC(2.42)和ASES(2.00)。
- ASES较VAS(RE 1.70)、Constant(RE 2.76)、SST(RE 1.67)和SANE(RE 2.14)反应性更高。
核心结论
- ASES和UCLA量表是肩袖修复术后反应性最高的患者报告结局量表。
- 作者建议在临床和研究中广泛采用ASES和UCLA量表以实现标准化,但UCLA量表需要现场进行关节活动度和力量测试,这是实际限制和长期随访的障碍。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,证据等级4级,按照PRISMA及PRISMA-Searching扩展指南在PubMed/MEDLINE、Embase和Web of Science进行检索。
- 共纳入252项研究,32072例患者,平均年龄59.6岁,平均体重指数28.7,平均随访时间27.8个月。
主要发现
- 252项研究中,131项(52%)报告了关节活动度,123项(49%)报告了影像学表现。
- 共识别67种PROM工具,最常用为ASES(n=183;73%)、VAS(n=163;65%)和Constant(n=118;47%)。
- 效应量最高的3种PROM为UCLA(2.51)、WORC(2.42)和ASES(2.00)。
- ASES较VAS反应性更高(RE 1.70),较Constant更高(RE 2.76),较SST更高(RE 1.67),较SANE更高(RE 2.14)。
- UCLA较ASES反应性更高(RE 1.03),较VAS更高(RE 3.66),较Constant更高(RE 1.72),较SST更高(RE 1.66)。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议在临床和研究中广泛采用ASES和UCLA量表以实现标准化,并指出UCLA量表需要现场进行关节活动度和力量测试,是长期随访的实际限制和障碍。
局限性
- UCLA量表需要现场进行关节活动度和力量测试,这是实际限制和长期随访的障碍。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Multiple patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) have been used to assess shoulder function, but it is unknown which are the most effective. PURPOSE/HYPOTHESIS: The purpose of this study was to report the multiple PROMs used after rotator cuff repair (RCR) and to compare the responsiveness between them. It was hypothesized that the Western Ontario Rotator Cuff PROM would be the most responsive and commonly used in patients undergoing RCR. STUDY DESIGN: Meta-analysis; Level of evidence, 4. METHODS: A systematic review was conducted in accordance with PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) and PRISMA-Searching extension guidelines via PubMed/MEDLINE, Embase (Elsevier), and Web of Science (Clarivate). Patient and study characteristics were extracted. From the studies that met inclusion criteria for responsiveness analysis (≥2 PROMs reported, 1-year minimum follow-up, and pre- and postoperative PROM means and standard deviations reported), the authors compared the responsiveness between PROM instruments using effect size and relative efficiency (RE) if a PROM could be compared with another in ≥10 articles. RESULTS: A total of 252 studies met inclusion criteria (32,072 patients; mean age, 59.6 years; mean body mass index, 28.7; mean follow-up time, 27.8 months). Range of motion was reported in 131 (52%) studies and imaging findings were reported in 123 (49%) studies. There were 67 PROM instruments identified; the most commonly used were the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeon (ASES) (n = 183; 73%), Visual Analog Scale (VAS) (n = 163; 65%), and Constant (n = 118; 47%) scores. The 3 PROMs with the highest effect sizes were the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) (2.51), Western Ontario Rotator Cuff (2.42), and ASES (2.00) scores. Overall, UCLA and ASES scores were the most responsive PROMs. The ASES PROM was more responsive than the VAS (RE, 1.70), Constant (RE, 2.76), Simple Shoulder Test (RE, 1.67), and Single Assessment Numeric Evaluation (RE, 2.14) scores. The UCLA PROM was more responsive than the ASES (RE, 1.03), VAS (RE, 3.66), Constant (RE, 1.72), and Simple Shoulder Test (RE, 1.66) scores. CONCLUSION: ASES and UCLA scores were the most responsive PROMs after RCR. The authors recommend widespread adoption of ASES and UCLA scores for clinical and research standardization; however, the UCLA PROM requires in-person range of motion and strength testing, which is a practical limitation and barrier to long-term follow-up.
引用
- Abed V, Kapp S, Nichols M, et al. ASES and UCLA Are Responsive Patient-Reported Outcome Measures After Rotator Cuff Repair: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2024. PMID: 38391128. doi:10.1177/03635465231213870
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。