骨关节炎髋膝关节置换术患者态度是否存在种族和民族差异?一项系统综述
本文系统检索PubMed、Cochrane和Embase(末次检索2023年8月),纳入21项研究(14项定量、7项定性,共8472例患者),评估黑人和西班牙裔患者对骨关节炎髋膝关节置换术的态度差异及社会经济因素混杂控制情况。结果显示,自认为黑人和西班牙裔的患者对髋膝关节置换术的偏好低于自认为白人的患者;14项定量研究中有13项考虑并处理了潜在的社会经济混杂变量。
要点
- 自认为黑人和西班牙裔的患者对髋膝关节置换术的偏好总体低于自认为白人的患者。
- 黑人患者更倾向于将骨关节炎视为衰老的自然且不可逆部分,并偏好家庭疗法。
- 14项定量研究中13项考虑并处理了潜在的社会经济混杂变量。
核心结论
- 自认为黑人和西班牙裔患者对 discretionary 关节置换术偏好较低,这一现象独立于社会经济因素,并与对衰老的接纳、偏好自主应对(家庭疗法)、更多考虑费用、康复担忧和潜在伤害有关。
- 作者认为,不应假定 discretionary 手术使用较低就代表照护较差,也不应将其视为歧视的替代标志。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索PubMed、Cochrane和Embase(末次检索2023年8月),纳入21项研究,其中14项定量研究、7项定性研究,共8472例患者。
- 采用混合方法评价工具(Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool)进行质量评价;因无随机试验,未进行Meta分析。
主要发现
- 自认为黑人和西班牙裔的患者对髋膝关节置换术的偏好总体低于自认为白人的患者。
- 黑人患者更可能将骨关节炎视为衰老的自然且不可逆部分,并偏好家庭疗法;黑人和西班牙裔患者均重视宗教支持且相对更关注费用。
- 黑人和西班牙裔患者对获益的感知较低、对手术更不熟悉、对手术和康复的恐惧程度更高、对医疗照护的信任更有限。
- 黑人和西班牙裔的社会网络倾向于讨论这些担忧,而白人的社会网络更可能讨论手术的获益。
- 14项定量研究中13项在分析中考虑并处理了潜在的社会经济混杂变量。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入21项研究:14项定量研究和7项定性研究,共8472例患者。
- 14项定量研究中13项考虑并处理了潜在的社会经济混杂变量。
- 质量评价显示纳入研究偏倚风险低:5项定量研究缺乏关于无应答偏倚的细节,1项定性研究缺乏其队列种族和民族构成的细节。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,骨科医生应寻找方法,在公平获得专科照护和 discretionary 手术之间取得平衡,同时避免削弱有效的适应策略。
- 作者认为,不应假定 discretionary 手术使用较低就代表照护较差,也不应将其视为歧视的替代标志。
局限性
- 5项定量研究缺乏关于无应答偏倚的细节。
- 1项定性研究缺乏其队列种族和民族构成的细节。
- 因无随机试验,未进行Meta分析。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: It is not clear why people who identify as Black or Hispanic are less likely to undergo discretionary musculoskeletal surgery such as arthroplasty for osteoarthritis of the hip or knee. Inequities and mistrust are important factors to consider. The role of socioeconomic factors and variation in values, attitudes, and beliefs regarding discretionary procedures are less well understood. A systematic review of the evidence regarding mindsets toward knee and hip arthroplasty among Black and Hispanic people could inform attempts to limit disparities in care. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: In a systematic review of qualitative and quantitative evidence, we asked: (1) What factors are associated with racial and ethnic variations in attitudes toward discretionary hip and knee arthroplasty for osteoarthritis? (2) Do studies that investigate racial and ethnic variations in mindsets toward discretionary orthopaedic care control for potential confounding by socioeconomic factors? METHODS: A systematic search of PubMed, Cochrane, and Embase (last searched August 2023) for studies that addressed racial and ethnic variations in mindsets toward discretionary musculoskeletal care use was conducted. We excluded studies that were not published in English, lacked full-text availability, and those that documented patient approaches without comparing them to the willingness to undergo a discretionary procedure. Twenty-one studies were included-14 quantitative and seven qualitative-including 8472 patients. The Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool was used for quality assessment of included studies. The studies included demonstrated low risk of bias: five quantitative studies lacked detail regarding nonresponse bias and one qualitative study lacked details regarding the racial and ethnic composition of its cohort. To answer our first research question, we categorized themes associated with racial differences in mindsets toward discretionary care and recorded the presence of associations in quantitative studies. To answer our second question, we identified whether quantitative studies address potential confounding with socioeconomic factors. There were no randomized trials, so no meta-analysis was performed. RESULTS: In general, self-identified Black and Hispanic patients had a lower preference for hip and knee arthroplasty than self-identified White patients. Black patients were more likely to regard osteoarthritis as a natural and irremediable part of aging and prefer home remedies. Both Black and Hispanic patients valued support from religion and were relatively cost-conscious. Black and Hispanic patients had lower perception of benefit, were less familiar with the procedure, had higher levels of fear regarding surgery and recovery, and had more-limited trust in care. Generally, Black and Hispanic social networks tended to address these concerns, whereas White social networks were more likely to discuss the benefits of surgery. Thirteen of 14 quantitative studies considered and accounted for potential confounding socioeconomic variables in their analyses. CONCLUSION: The observation that lower preference for discretionary arthroplasty among Black and Hispanic patients is independent from socioeconomic factors and is related to accommodation of aging, preference for agency (home remedies), greater consideration of costs, recovery concerns, and potential harms directs orthopaedic surgeons to find ways to balance equitable access to specialty care and discretionary surgery while avoiding undermining effective accommodation strategies. It is important not to assume that lower use of discretionary surgery represents poorer care or is a surrogate marker for discrimination. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Adu Y, Hurley J, Ring D, et al. Are There Racial and Ethnic Variations in Patient Attitudes Toward Hip and Knee Arthroplasty for Osteoarthritis? A Systematic Review. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2024. PMID: 38393955. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000003021
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。