文献速递关节外科

哪些患者能从髋或膝关节置换术中获益?术前患者报告结局阈值预测有意义的改善

Who Benefits From Hip Arthroplasty or Knee Arthroplasty? Preoperative Patient-reported Outcome Thresholds Predict Meaningful Improvement.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2024-02-21

研究纳入德国九家医院4182例髋关节置换术(HA)和3645例膝关节置换术(KA)患者,用锚定法基于变化差异确定三种患者报告结局指标(PROMs)的最小临床重要差异(MCID),并以约登指数最大化确定术前PROM阈值。结果显示,达到MCID者与未达到者主要在术前PROM评分上不同;术前EQ-5D-5L高于0.7(HA)或0.6(KA)、HOOS-PS低于42或KOOS-PS低于39、疼痛量表低于3.5或6.5者术后无有意义的获益。

要点

  • HA的MCID:EQ-5D-5L为0.2分,疼痛量表为-0.9分,HOOS-PS为-10分(总分100分)。
  • KA的MCID:EQ-5D-5L为0.2分,疼痛量表为-0.7分,KOOS-PS为-5分(总分100分)。
  • 术前EQ-5D-5L阈值HA为0.7、KA为0.6时区分是否达到MCID的约登指数最高。

核心结论

  • 达到MCID的患者与未达到者在术前PROM评分上存在差异。
  • 术前EQ-5D-5L高于0.7(HA)或0.6(KA)、HOOS-PS低于42或KOOS-PS低于39、疼痛量表低于3.5或6.5者术后无有意义的获益。
  • 阈值可支持临床决策,但患者偏好和医学专业知识必须补充决策。

研究设计与样本

  • 2019年10月1日至2020年12月31日,德国九家参与医院中4182例HA和3645例KA患者同意加入PROMoting Quality研究。
  • 从1843例HA和1546例KA的选定组中,采用锚定法基于变化差异确定MCID。
  • 采用使约登指数最大化的术前PROM评分确定区分达到MCID与否的阈值。

主要发现

  • EQ-5D-5L的MCID在HA为0.2分、KA为0.2分(最高1分,分值越高健康相关生活质量越好)。
  • 疼痛量表的MCID在HA为-0.9分、KA为-0.7分(总分10分,分值越低疼痛越轻)。
  • HOOS-PS的MCID为-10分,KOOS-PS的MCID为-5分(总分100分,分值越低功能越好)。
  • 达到MCID者与未达到者在所有评估的PROM基线和HA、KA中均存在差异;在教育程度和合并症等方面也有差异,但跨PROM和关节置换类型不一致。
  • 未达到阈值的患者仍可能达到MCID,尤其是功能性和疼痛量表。

关键数值与推荐

  • HA术前阈值:EQ-5D-5L为0.7(约登指数0.55),HOOS-PS为42(约登指数0.27),疼痛量表为3.5(约登指数0.47)。
  • KA术前阈值:EQ-5D-5L为0.6(约登指数0.57),KOOS-PS为39(约登指数0.25),疼痛量表为6.5(约登指数0.40)。
  • EQ-5D-5L的约登指数高于其他PROM,表明其阈值区分达到与未达到有意义改善者的能力更好。

临床怎么用

  • 阈值可支持临床决策;当阈值提示术后不太可能达到有意义的改善时,可优先考虑其他治疗方案(作者建议)。
  • 尽管阈值可作为支持,但患者偏好和医学专业知识必须补充决策(作者建议)。
  • 术前PROM评分阈值通过客观指标支持临床医生决策,可提高手术推荐质量。

局限性

  • 未来研究可能评估这些阈值在实践中的效用。
  • 未来研究可能检验不同阈值如何组合为多维决策工具。
  • 未来研究可能基于实践中使用的其他PROM推导术前阈值。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Hip arthroplasty (HA) and knee arthroplasty (KA) are high-volume procedures. However, there is a debate about the quality of indication; that is, whether surgery is truly indicated in all patients. Patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) may be used to determine preoperative thresholds to differentiate patients who will likely benefit from surgery from those who will not. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) What were the minimum clinically important differences (MCIDs) for three commonly used PROMs in a large population of patients undergoing HA or KA treated in a general orthopaedic practice? (2) Do patients who reach the MCID differ in important ways from those who do not? (3) What preoperative PROM score thresholds best distinguish patients who achieve a meaningful improvement 12 months postsurgery from those who do not? (4) Do patients with preoperative PROM scores below thresholds still experience gains after surgery? METHODS: Between October 1, 2019, and December 31, 2020, 4182 patients undergoing HA and 3645 patients undergoing KA agreed to be part of the PROMoting Quality study and were hence included by study nurses in one of nine participating German hospitals. From a selected group of 1843 patients with HA and 1546 with KA, we derived MCIDs using the anchor-based change difference method to determine meaningful improvements. Second, we estimated which preoperative PROM score thresholds best distinguish patients who achieve an MCID from those who do not, using the preoperative PROM scores that maximized the Youden index. PROMs were Hip Disability and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score-Physical Function short form (HOOS-PS) (scored 0 to 100 points; lower indicates better health), Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score-Physical Function short form (KOOS-PS) (scored 0 to 100 points; lower indicates better health), EuroQol 5-Dimension 5-level (EQ-5D-5L) (scored -0.661 to 1 points; higher indicates better health), and a 10-point VAS for pain (perceived pain in the joint under consideration for surgery within the past 7 days) (scored 0 to 10 points; lower indicates better health). The performance of derived thresholds is reported using the Youden index, sensitivity, specificity, F1 score, geometric mean as a measure of central tendency, and area under the receiver operating characteristic curve. RESULTS: MCIDs for the EQ-5D-5L were 0.2 for HA and 0.2 for KA, with a maximum of 1 point, where higher values represented better health-related quality of life. For the pain scale, they were -0.9 for HA and -0.7 for KA, of 10 points (maximum), where lower scores represent lower pain. For the HOOS-PS, the MCID was -10, and for the KOOS-PS it was -5 of 100 points, where lower scores represent better functioning. Patients who reached the MCID differed from patients who did not reach the MCID with respect to baseline PROM scores across the evaluated PROMs and for both HA and KA. Patients who reached an MCID versus those who did not also differed regarding other aspects including education and comorbidities, but this was not consistent across PROMs and arthroplasty type. Preoperative PROM score thresholds for HA were 0.7 for EQ-5D-5L (Youden index: 0.55), 42 for HOOS-PS (Youden index: 0.27), and 3.5 for the pain scale (Youden index: 0.47). For KA, the thresholds were 0.6 for EQ-5D-5L (Youden index: 0.57), 39 for KOOS-PS (Youden index: 0.25), and 6.5 for the pain scale (Youden index: 0.40). A higher Youden index for EQ-5D-5L than for the other PROMs indicates that the thresholds for EQ-5D-5L were better for distinguishing patients who reached a meaningful improvement from those who did not. Patients who did not reach the thresholds could still achieve MCIDs, especially for functionality and the pain scale. CONCLUSION: We found that patients who experienced meaningful improvements (MCIDs) mainly differed from those who did not regarding their preoperative PROM scores. We further identified that patients undergoing HA or KA with a score above 0.7 or 0.6, respectively, on the EQ-5D-5L, below 42 or 39 on the HOOS-PS or KOOS-PS, or below 3.5 or 6.5 on a 10-point joint-specific pain scale presurgery had no meaningful benefit from surgery. The thresholds can support clinical decision-making. For example, when thresholds indicate that a meaningful improvement is not likely to be achieved after surgery, other treatment options may be prioritized. Although the thresholds can be used as support, patient preferences and medical expertise must supplement the decision. Future studies might evaluate the utility of using these thresholds in practice, examine how different thresholds can be combined as a multidimensional decision tool, and derive presurgery thresholds based on additional PROMs used in practice. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Preoperative PROM score thresholds in this study will support clinicians in decision-making through objective measures that can improve the quality of the recommendation for surgery.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Langenberger B, Steinbeck V, Busse R, et al. Who Benefits From Hip Arthroplasty or Knee Arthroplasty? Preoperative Patient-reported Outcome Thresholds Predict Meaningful Improvement. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2024. PMID: 38393816. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002994

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。