骨科专科培训项目主任的性别差异
该回顾性队列研究分析了2022至2023学年600名骨科专科培训项目主任,其中女性40名(6.7%)。女性在运动医学、肩肘和成人重建等亚专科中代表性不足,亚专科薪酬中位数与女性项目主任比例呈负相关(r=-0.70,p=0.036),ACGME认证项目女性比例更高(11.0% vs 3.9%,p<0.001)。作者认为需要更多研究来了解影响女性在骨科领导职位中代表性的障碍。
要点
- 600名骨科专科培训项目主任中女性占6.7%(40名)。
- 女性项目主任比例随学术等级升高而增加:助理教授PPR=0.67,副教授PPR=0.77,正教授PPR=0.80。
- 亚专科薪酬中位数与女性项目主任比例呈负相关(r=-0.70,p=0.036)。
核心结论
- 女性在骨科专科培训项目主任中代表性不足,尤其是在运动医学、肩肘和成人重建等亚专科。
- 需要更多研究来了解影响女性在骨科领导职位中代表性的障碍。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入2022至2023学年骨科专科培训项目主任600名,从互联网资源收集学术、培训和人口学特征。
- 计算男性和女性的参与-患病率比值(PPR),PPR<0.8表示代表性不足,PPR>1.2表示代表性过高。
- 采用双变量分析评估性别多样性与地理区域及ACGME认证状态的相关性,采用Pearson相关系数分析亚专科薪酬中位数与性别多样性的关系。
主要发现
- 600名专科培训项目主任中女性40名(6.7%)。
- 助理教授占24.5%(女性8.8% vs 男性91.2%,p<0.001),副教授占26.2%(女性9.6% vs 男性90.4%,p<0.001),正教授占36.8%(女性4.5% vs 男性95.5%,p<0.001),无职称占12.5%(女性2.7% vs 男性97.3%,p<0.001)。
- 女性项目主任比例随学术等级升高而增加:助理教授PPR=0.67,副教授PPR=0.77,正教授PPR=0.80。
- 女性项目主任比例最高的亚专科为骨与软组织肿瘤(19.0%)、小儿骨科(14.6%)和手外科(12.6%);PPR最低的亚专科为骨科运动医学(PPR=0.35)、肩肘(PPR=0.45)和成人重建(PPR=0.52)。
- 女性项目主任在骨与软组织肿瘤(PPR=1.17)、手外科(PPR=1.02)、足踝(PPR=0.84)和骨科创伤(PPR=0.80)中代表性公平。
关键数值与推荐
- PPR<0.8定义为代表性不足,PPR>1.2定义为代表性过高。
- 女性在助理教授(PPR=0.67)、副教授(PPR=0.77)和正教授(PPR=0.80)水平的PPR均<0.8。
- 骨与软组织肿瘤(PPR=1.17)、手外科(PPR=1.02)、足踝(PPR=0.84)和骨科创伤(PPR=0.80)的PPR在0.8至1.2之间。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,提高专科培训项目主任的性别多样性可能有助于增加骨科亚专科对女性的招聘。
- 作者认为,公平考虑来自各种背景的骨科医生担任领导职位可以增加劳动力多样性,从而可能提高骨科社区的活力。
局限性
- 需要更多研究来了解影响女性在骨科领导职位中代表性的障碍。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Women are underrepresented in the orthopaedic surgery workforce in the U.S. The purpose of this study was to elucidate the representation of women among fellowship program directors (PDs) in orthopaedic surgery. METHODS: This was a retrospective cohort study of fellowship PDs in orthopaedic surgery during the 2022 to 2023 academic year. Academic, training, and demographic characteristics were collected from internet-based resources. Participation-to-prevalence ratios (PPRs) were calculated for both men and women. A PPR of <0.8 indicated underrepresentation and a PPR of >1.2 indicated overrepresentation. Bivariate analyses were utilized to assess the correlation between sex diversity and geographic region and between sex diversity and Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME)-accreditation status. The relationship between the median annual salary and the sex diversity of each orthopaedic subspecialty was analyzed with use of the Pearson correlation coefficient. RESULTS: This study included 600 fellowship PDs, 40 (6.7%) of whom were women. In total, 24.5% of the fellowship PDs were assistant professors (8.8% women versus 91.2% men, p < 0.001); 26.2% were associate professors (9.6% women versus 90.4% men, p < 0.001); 36.8% were full professors (4.5% women versus 95.5% men, p < 0.001); and 12.5% were unranked (2.7% women versus 97.3% men, p < 0.001). The representation of women increased with academic rank, as reflected in their prevalence at the assistant (PPR = 0.67), associate (PPR = 0.77), and full professor (PPR = 0.80) levels. Among the orthopaedic subspecialties, musculoskeletal oncology (19.0%), pediatric orthopaedics (14.6%), and hand surgery (12.6%) had the highest proportions of women fellowship PDs. PPRs were lowest for orthopaedic sports medicine (PPR = 0.35), shoulder and elbow (PPR = 0.45), and adult reconstruction (PPR = 0.52). Women PDs had equitable representation in musculoskeletal oncology (PPR = 1.17), hand surgery (PPR = 1.02), foot and ankle (PPR = 0.84), and orthopaedic trauma (PPR = 0.80). Median subspecialty compensation was negatively correlated with the prevalence of women among fellowship PDs (r = -0.70, p = 0.036). Geographic region was not associated with sex diversity (p = 0.434), but programs with ACGME accreditation had significantly more women fellowship PDs than those without (11.0% versus 3.9%, p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Women are underrepresented among orthopaedic fellowship PDs, especially in certain subspecialties (orthopaedic sports medicine, shoulder and elbow, and adult reconstruction). More research is needed to understand the barriers that impact the representation of women among leadership positions in orthopaedic surgery. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Greater sex diversity among fellowship PDs may help to increase the recruitment of women into orthopaedic subspecialties. The equitable consideration of orthopaedic surgeons from all backgrounds for leadership positions can increase workforce diversity, which may improve the vitality of the orthopaedic community.
引用
- Silvestre J, Tippabhatla A, Chopra A, et al. Sex Disparities Among Fellowship Program Directors in Orthopaedic Surgery. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2023. PMID: 38323988. doi:10.2106/JBJS.23.00278
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。