使用新的半定量技术在前後位X线片上评估椎体骨折严重程度
研究提出一种基于前后位脊柱X线片的半定量分级方案,将椎体左右半侧分为A至D型、整体分为E至F型,并与Genant分级对应;由一名经验丰富的放射科医师和一名放射科实习生对50名女性的前后位片进行评估,与侧位片比较,医师正确判定1、2、3级骨折的比例分别为84.2%、91.7%、77.2%,实习生分别为68.4%、79.2%、81.8%。
要点
- 前后位X线片半定量分级将半侧椎体分为垂直矩形、正方形、横矩形和梯形,整体椎体分为横带或蝴蝶结型,分别对应Genant 1至3级。
- 与侧位片比较,放射科医师加权Kappa为0.944(含正常椎体)和0.883(不含正常椎体)。
- 放射科实习生加权Kappa为0.891(含正常椎体)和0.830(不含正常椎体)。
核心结论
- 作者提出一种新的半定量分级系统,用于在脊柱前后位X线片上评估椎体骨折严重程度。
研究设计与样本
- 研究提出前后位X线片上半定量分级方案,半侧椎体分为A垂直矩形、B正方形、C横矩形、D梯形,整体椎体分为E横带或F蝴蝶结型。
- A型和B型与正常及Genant半定量1级骨质疏松性椎体骨折比较,C型和D型与2级比较,E型和F型与3级比较。
- 由一名经验丰富的委员会认证放射科医师和一名放射科实习生对50名女性的前后位脊柱X线片进行评估,并与侧位X线片比较。
主要发现
- 半侧椎体的高宽比范围为1.32至1.48。
- 侧位X线片上50名患者共84个椎体存在骨质疏松性椎体骨折,其中1级38个、2级24个、3级22个。
- 前后位X线片上,放射科医师正确判定1级、2级、3级骨折的比例分别为84.2%、91.7%、77.2%。
- 放射科实习生正确判定1级、2级、3级骨折的比例分别为68.4%、79.2%、81.8%。
- 与侧位X线片比较,放射科医师加权Kappa为0.944(含正常椎体)和0.883(不含正常椎体),实习生相应Kappa值分别为0.891和0.830。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
UNLABELLED: We developed a new tool to assess the severity of osteoporotic vertebral fracture using radiographs of the spine. Our technique can be used in patient care by helping to stratify patients with osteoporotic vertebral fractures into appropriate treatment pathways. It can also be used for research purposes. PURPOSE: The aim of our study was to propose a semi-quantitative (SQ) grading scheme for osteoporotic vertebral fracture (OVF) on anteroposterior (AP) radiographs. METHODS: On AP radiographs, the vertebrae are divided into right and left halves, which are graded (A) vertical rectangle, (B) square, (C) traverse rectangle, and (D) trapezoid; whole vertebrae are graded (E) transverse band or (F) bow-tie. Type A and B were compared with normal and Genant SQ grade 1 OVF, Type C and D with grade 2 OVF, and Type E and F with grade 3 OVF. Spine AP radiographs and lateral radiographs of 50 females were assessed by AP radiographs SQ grading. After training, an experienced board-certified radiologist and a radiology trainee assessed the 50 AP radiographs. RESULTS: The height-to-width ratio of the half vertebrae varied 1.32-1.48. On lateral radiographs, 84 vertebrae of the 50 patients had OVFs (38 grade 1, 24 grade 2, and 22 grade 3). On AP radiographs, the radiologist correctly assigned 84.2%, 91.7%, and 77.2% and the trainee correctly assigned 68.4%, 79.2%, and 81.8% of grade 1, 2, and 3 OVFs, respectively. Compared with lateral radiographs, the radiologist had a weighted Kappa of 0.944 including normal vertebrae and 0.883 not including normal vertebrae, while the corresponding Kappa values for the trainee were 0.891 and 0.830, respectively. CONCLUSION: We propose a new semi-quantitative grading system for vertebral fracture severity assessment on AP spine radiographs.
引用
- Yu W, Guan WM, Hayashi D, et al. Vertebral fracture severity assessment on anteroposterior radiographs with a new semi-quantitative technique. Osteoporos Int. 2024. PMID: 38296865. doi:10.1007/s00198-024-07024-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。