上关节囊重建与中斜方肌腱转移治疗孤立性不可修复冈上肌腱撕裂:静态重建与动态重建的比较
队列研究纳入60例孤立性不可修复冈上肌腱撕裂患者,34例行上关节囊重建(S组),26例行关节镜辅助中斜方肌腱转移(M组)。两组临床评分均改善,M组末次随访主动前屈(148.2°±24.1° vs 165.9°±8.7°,P=.003)和外展(131°±37.3° vs 152.5°±17.9°,P=.035)显著更高。S组肩峰磨损率(58.8% vs 15.4%,P<.001)和移植物再撕裂率(47.1% vs 7.7%,P<.001)显著更高,但两组临床评分无显著差异。
要点
- 两组术后临床评分均显著改善,M组末次随访主动前屈和外展显著高于S组(P=.003和P=.035)。
- S组肩峰磨损率58.8% vs M组15.4%(P<.001),移植物再撕裂率47.1% vs 7.7%(P<.001)。
- 两组术后Constant、ASES和UCLA评分及Hamada分级(P=.143)无显著差异。
核心结论
- 上关节囊重建与中斜方肌腱转移均改善孤立性不可修复冈上肌腱撕裂的术后整体临床结局,中斜方肌腱转移在主动前屈和外展活动度方面优于上关节囊重建。
- 上关节囊重建组移植物失败和肩峰下骨侵蚀发生率更高,但短期随访两组临床评分无差异。
- 作者提出未来应开展进一步结构良好的长期比较试验。
研究设计与样本
- 队列研究,证据等级3。
- 共60例孤立性不可修复冈上肌腱撕裂患者,按手术方式分为两组:S组行上关节囊重建(n=34),M组行中斜方肌腱转移(n=26)。
- 临床结局包括疼痛视觉模拟评分、肩关节主动活动度、美国肩肘外科医师评分和加州大学洛杉矶分校肩关节评分;影像学结局包括肩肱间距、肩袖撕裂关节病进展(Hamada分级)、肩峰下骨侵蚀和移植物失败。
- S组平均随访39.3±5.2个月(范围26-59个月),M组平均随访37.6±9.8个月(范围27-54个月)。
主要发现
- 两组临床结局均显著改善。
- 末次随访M组主动前屈148.2°±24.1° vs S组165.9°±8.7°(P=.003),M组主动外展131°±37.3° vs S组152.5°±17.9°(P=.035),M组显著更高。
- 两组术后Constant、美国肩肘外科医师评分和加州大学洛杉矶分校肩关节评分无显著差异。
- 末次随访两组Hamada分级无差异(P=.143)。
- S组肩峰磨损率58.8% vs M组15.4%(P<.001),S组移植物再撕裂率47.1% vs M组7.7%(P<.001),S组显著更高。
局限性
- 作者提出未来应开展进一步结构良好的长期比较试验。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Both superior capsular reconstruction (SCR) and middle trapezius tendon (MTT) transfer can be performed in nonarthritic young and active patients with isolated irreparable supraspinatus tendon tears (IISTTs). However, to our knowledge, no comparative clinical studies have been conducted on these procedures. PURPOSE: To evaluate and compare the clinical and radiological outcomes of SCR and arthroscopic-assisted MTT transfer in patients with IISTTs. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: A total of 60 patients with IISTTs were categorized into 2 groups according to the surgical procedure-Group S underwent SCR (n = 34); Group M underwent MTT transfer (n = 26). The clinical outcomes included the visual analog scale score for pain, active shoulder range of motion, American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons score, and University of California, Los Angeles, shoulder score. Radiological outcomes included the assessment of the acromiohumeral distance, progression of cuff tear arthropathy (Hamada grade), subacromial bone erosion, and graft failure. RESULTS: The mean follow-up time was 39.3 ± 5.2 months (range, 26-59 months) and 37.6 ± 9.8 months (range, 27-54 months) in Group S and Group M, respectively. Significant improvements in clinical outcomes were observed in both groups, while the active forward flexion (148.2°± 24.1° vs 165.9°± 8.7°; P = .003) and abduction (131°± 37.3° vs 152.5°± 17.9°; P = .035) were significantly higher in Group M at the final follow-up. No significant differences were found in the postoperative Constant, American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons, and University of California, Los Angeles, shoulder scores between the 2 groups. Radiologically, although no difference was found in the Hamada grade at the final follow-up between the 2 groups (P = .143), the rates of acromial wear (58.8% vs 15.4%; P < .001) and graft retear (47.1% vs 7.7%; P < .001) were significantly higher in Group S than in Group M. CONCLUSION: Both SCR and MTT transfer improved the overall clinical outcomes of IISTTs postoperatively, whereas MTT transfer was superior to SCR in terms of active forward flexion and abduction range of motion. Although higher rates of graft failure and subacromial bone erosion were observed in Group S, no difference was found in the clinical scores between the 2 groups at the short-term follow-up. However, further well-structured, prolonged comparative trials should be conducted in the future.
引用
- Kim JG, Lim C, Kim BT, et al. Superior Capsular Reconstruction Versus Middle Trapezius Tendon Transfer for Isolated Irreparable Supraspinatus Tendon Tears: Static Versus Dynamic Reconstruction. Am J Sports Med. 2024. PMID: 38179610. doi:10.1177/03635465231213340
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。