6本主要骨科期刊作者署名中的性别趋势
该文献计量学研究提取了2011年至2021年间6本骨科期刊的文章信息,使用Genderize.io根据作者名字判定性别。结果显示,女性中间作者占比增加5个百分点,第一作者增加4个百分点,最后作者增加1个百分点;女性中间作者比例最高的期刊为《小儿骨科学杂志》(28%),最低为《关节置换术杂志》(16%)。在除2本期刊外的所有期刊中,产出最高的5位女性最后作者平均每篇论文被引次数显著少于男性同行。
要点
- 2011年至2021年间,6本骨科期刊中女性中间作者占比增加5个百分点。
- 女性第一作者占比增加4个百分点,女性最后作者占比增加1个百分点。
- 在除2本期刊外的所有期刊中,产出最高的5位女性最后作者平均每篇被引显著少于男性。
核心结论
- 骨科手术及其文献体系中存在性别差距。
- 女性中间作者总体及每本期刊中的增加显示了该领域女性未来增长的势头。
研究设计与样本
- 研究提取2011年至2021年间6本骨科期刊的文章文献计量信息,数据来源为Web of Science。
- 收集的数据包括作者顺序、作者姓名、所属机构及通讯作者地址。
- 使用经验证的软件Genderize.io根据作者名字判定性别。
- 对每本期刊使用方差分析进行统计分析,并进行线性回归确定趋势,控制年份。
主要发现
- 在所有纳入的骨科期刊中,女性中间作者占比增加5个百分点,女性第一作者占比增加4个百分点,女性最后作者占比增加1个百分点。
- 研究期间,女性中间作者比例最高为《小儿骨科学杂志》的28%,最低为《关节置换术杂志》的16%。
- 在除2本期刊外的所有期刊中,产出最高的5位女性最后作者平均每篇论文被引次数显著少于男性同行。
局限性
- 本研究结论提出需进一步探究骨科手术整体的研究产出和机会可获得性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Historically, orthopaedic surgery has had low female representation, with <6% of practicing surgeons identifying as female. Although prior literature has illustrated gender disparities in first and last authorship as well as changes in gender representation over time, less attention has been paid to middle authorship. We hypothesized that trends in female authorship would reflect increasing female participation in orthopaedic surgery and orthopaedic subspecialties coinciding with an overall increase in female authorship. METHODS: Bibliometric information from articles published between 2011 and 2021 in 6 orthopaedic journals was extracted with use of the Web of Science. Collected data included author order, author names, affiliation, and corresponding author address. A gender was assigned with the use of Genderize.io, which is validated software, on the basis of author first name. Statistical analysis was performed with use of an analysis of variance for each journal, and linear regression was performed to determine trends, controlling for year. RESULTS: Among all included orthopaedic journals, female middle authorship increased by 5 percentage points, female first authorship increased by 4 percentage points, and female last authorship increased by 1 percentage point. Over the study period, the highest rate of female middle authorship (28%) was seen in the Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics, whereas the lowest rate (16%) was seen in The Journal of Arthroplasty . We found that the 5 highest-producing female last authors were, on average, cited significantly less per publication than their male counterparts in all but 2 journals. CONCLUSIONS: Gender gaps exist within orthopaedic surgery as well as within its body of literature. Although this study highlights areas of growth, it also promotes further inquiry into research productivity and the availability of opportunity within orthopaedic surgery as a whole. The increase in female middle authorship overall and in each journal demonstrates momentum for future growth for women in the field of orthopaedic surgery.
引用
- Grant C, Stauffer TP, Seyler TM, et al. Gender Trends in Authorship in 6 Major Orthopaedic Journals. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2024. PMID: 38194590. doi:10.2106/JBJS.23.00995
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。