双侧全膝关节置换术的财务可行性:同期与分期手术间收入与贡献毛利的配对队列分析
该研究回顾性分析2012至2021年接受同期双侧全膝关节置换术(simBTKA)与分期双侧全膝关节置换术(staBTKA)的患者,按基线特征1:1倾向匹配后每组205例。结果显示simBTKA总费用与直接费用均显著低于staBTKA两次手术总费用,但收入亦显著更低,两组贡献毛利(CM)相当,术后并发症相似。
要点
- simBTKA总费用(P<.001)与直接费用(P<.001)显著低于staBTKA两次手术总费用。
- simBTKA收入显著更低(P<.001),两组贡献毛利相当(P=.477)。
- 90天再入院(P=1.000)、90天翻修(P=1.000)及末次随访全因翻修(P=.083)两组相似。
核心结论
- 在倾向匹配队列中,simBTKA较staBTKA费用更低,但收入亦更低,两者贡献毛利相似。
- 鉴于术后并发症率相似,两种术式的成本效益相当。
- 未来研究需识别哪些患者在临床与患者报告结局方面更适合simBTKA而非staBTKA。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2012至2021年接受simBTKA(同日完成双侧手术)与staBTKA(一年内不同日期完成两次手术)的全部患者。
- 共评估2,357例患者(simBTKA 595例,staBTKA 1,762例),按基线特征1:1倾向匹配后410例纳入最终匹配分析(每组205例)。
- 比较两组手术结局及住院期间收入、成本与贡献毛利。
主要发现
- simBTKA总费用(P<.001)与直接费用(P<.001)显著低于staBTKA两次手术的总费用。
- simBTKA收入显著更低(P<.001),导致两组贡献毛利相当(P=.477)。
- 术后90天再入院(P=1.000)、90天翻修(P=1.000)及末次随访全因翻修(P=.083)两组相似。
局限性
- 原文结论指出未来研究需识别哪些患者在临床与患者报告结局方面更适合simBTKA而非staBTKA。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Financial analyses of simultaneous bilateral total knee arthroplasty versus staged bilateral total knee arthroplasty (simBTKA and staBTKA, respectively) have shown improved cost-effectiveness of simBTKA, though revenue and contribution margin (CM) for these procedures have not been investigated. Our analyses compared surgical outcomes, revenues, and CMs between simBTKA and staBTKA. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed all patients who underwent simBTKA (both procedures done on the same day) and staBTKA (procedures done on a different day within one year) between 2012 and 2021. Patients were 1:1 propensity matched based on baseline characteristics. Surgical outcomes, as well as revenue, cost, and CM of the inpatient episode were compared between groups. Of the 2,357 patients evaluated (n = 595 simBTKA, n = 1,762 staBTKA), 410 were included in final matched analyses (205 per group). RESULTS: Total (P < .001) and direct (P < .001) costs were significantly lower for simBTKA procedures compared to overall costs of both staBTKA procedures. Significantly lower revenue for simBTKA procedures (P < .001), resulted in comparable CM between groups (P = .477). Postoperative complications including 90-day readmission (P = 1.000), 90-day revision (P = 1.000) and all-cause revision at latest follow-up (P = .083) were similar between groups. CONCLUSIONS: In our propensity-matched cohort, lower costs for simBTKA compared to staBTKA were matched by lower revenues, with a resulting similar CM between procedures. Given that postoperative complication rates were similar, both procedures had comparable cost-effectiveness. Future research is needed to identify patients for whom simBTKA may represent a better surgical intervention compared to staBTKA with respect to clinical and patient reported outcomes.
引用
- Ashkenazi I, Rajahraman V, Lawrence KW, et al. The Financial Feasibility of Bilateral Total Knee Arthroplasty: A Matched Cohort Analyses of Revenue and Contribution Margin Between Simultaneous and Staged Procedures. J Arthroplasty. 2024. PMID: 38242509. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2024.01.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。