全膝关节置换术随机对照试验的患者选择:评估纳入标准的系统综述
该系统综述检索多个数据库,分析全膝关节置换术随机对照试验是否以骨关节炎严重程度(影像学分级或患者报告结局测量阈值)作为纳入标准。在不少于100例患者的试验中,仅18项(<8%)使用了特定影像学评分或患者报告结局测量阈值;在少于100例患者的试验中,48项(<15%)使用了特定纳入标准。结论认为绝大多数试验未基于疾病严重程度纳入患者,可能导致队列异质性并影响试验有效性。
要点
- 在不少于100例患者的随机对照试验中,仅18项(<8%,共2952例随机患者)使用特定影像学评分或患者报告结局测量阈值作为纳入标准。
- 18项研究中有11项使用特定影像学评分(如Kellgren-Lawrence或Ahlbäck分类),3项使用术前患者报告结局测量阈值。
- 在少于100例患者的试验中,48项(<15%)使用了特定纳入标准。
核心结论
- 绝大多数随机对照试验(>85%)未以患者报告结局测量评分阈值或影像学分类所衡量的疾病严重程度作为纳入标准。
- 缺乏一致的纳入标准可能导致队列异质性,可能削弱全膝关节置换术随机对照试验的有效性。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索PubMed、Embase、Scopus、Web of Science和Cochrane数据库,使用全膝关节置换术、患者报告结局测量和影像学评分相关术语组合。
- 共1227项研究由2名筛选者独立审查。
- 分析全膝关节置换术随机对照试验中不少于100例患者的236项和少于100例患者的325项,评估具体纳入标准和招募过程。
主要发现
- 在不少于100例患者的随机对照试验中,18项(<8%,共2952例随机患者)使用了特定影像学评分或患者报告结局测量阈值作为纳入标准。
- 18项研究中有11项使用特定影像学评分,如Kellgren-Lawrence或Ahlbäck分类。
- 3项研究使用术前患者报告结局测量阈值:Knee Society Knee Score <60、Knee Society Function Score <60、Oxford Knee Score <20和Hospital for Special Surgery Score <60。
- 在少于100例患者的试验中,48项(<15%)使用了特定纳入标准。
关键数值与推荐
- 在不少于100例患者的随机对照试验中,仅18项(<8%,共2952例随机患者)使用特定影像学评分或患者报告结局测量阈值。
- 18项研究中有11项使用特定影像学评分(如Kellgren-Lawrence或Ahlbäck分类),3项使用术前患者报告结局测量阈值。
- 在少于100例患者的试验中,48项(<15%)使用了特定纳入标准。
- 证据等级:预后Level I。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Patients undergo total knee arthroplasty (TKA) at widely disparate stages of osteoarthritis, raising the possibility of high heterogeneity among patients enrolled in TKA research studies. Obscuration of treatment effectiveness and other problems that may stem from cohort heterogeneity can be controlled in clinical studies by rigorously defining target patients. The purpose of this review was to determine the extent to which randomized controlled trials (RCTs) on TKA use osteoarthritis severity, as defined by radiographic grade or patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs), in their inclusion criteria, and to investigate potential impact on outcome. METHODS: A search of PubMed, Embase, Scopus, Web of Science, and Cochrane databases used a combination of terms involving TKA, PROMs, and radiographic scoring. A total of 1,227 studies were independently reviewed by 2 screeners for the above terms. RCTs with ≥100 patients (236) and with <100 patients (325) undergoing TKA were analyzed with regard to the specific inclusion criteria and recruitment process. RESULTS: Among the identified RCTs with ≥100 patients, 18 (<8%, with a total of 2,952 randomized patients) used specific radiographic scoring or PROM thresholds in their inclusion criteria. Eleven of the 18 studies used specific radiographic scoring, such as the Kellgren-Lawrence or Ahlbäck classifications. Three studies used preoperative PROM thresholds: Knee Society Knee Score of <60, Knee Society Function Score of <60, Oxford Knee Score of <20, and Hospital for Special Surgery Score of <60. Among studies with <100 patients, 48 (<15%) used specific inclusion criteria. CONCLUSIONS: The vast majority of RCTs (>85%) did not enroll patients based on disease severity, as measured by PROM score thresholds or radiographic classifications, in their inclusion criteria. The lack of consistent inclusion criteria likely results in heterogeneous cohorts, potentially undermining the validity of RCTs on TKA. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Prognostic Level I . See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
引用
- Beiene ZA, Tanghe KK, Neitzke CC, et al. Patient Selection in Randomized Controlled Trials of Total Knee Arthroplasty: A Systematic Review Assessing Inclusion Criteria. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2024. PMID: 38252710. doi:10.2106/JBJS.23.00629
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。