老年人上肢骨折后恐惧回避信念与行为:系统综述与元民族志研究
该系统综述旨在理解老年人上肢骨折后恐惧回避信念的相关观点,检索截至2023年4月1日的已发表与未发表文献,纳入8项定性研究(n=150名参与者,其中109例桡骨远端骨折、41例肱骨骨折),采用元民族志方法与GRADE-CERQUAL工具合成数据,识别出三类主题,证据置信度为中等。
要点
- 部分患者初期认为上肢骨折相对轻微,但随时间推移意识到其具有广泛影响及长期恢复视角。
- 骨折后立即提供教育与支持以预防或挑战关于跌倒恐惧和运动恐惧的初始健康信念对康复至关重要。
- 恐惧回避信念可严重影响某些老年人的康复及长期健康与福祉。
核心结论
- 恐惧回避信念可严重影响某些老年人的康复以及其长期健康与福祉。
- 在急性上肢创伤环境中考虑恐惧回避并采取措施减轻其影响,将更好地服务于这些患者持续从损伤中康复。
研究设计与样本
- 系统检索已发表与未发表文献数据库,检索时间从建库至2023年4月1日。
- 纳入报告上肢骨折后恐惧回避信念或行为观点的定性研究。
- 提取数据包括受访者特征、恐惧体验与感知、跌倒恐惧以及恐惧回避信念与行为。
- 采用元民族志方法与GRADE-CERQUAL工具合成数据。
- 共纳入8项研究(n=150名参与者;109例桡骨远端骨折/41例肱骨骨折)。
主要发现
- 识别出三个 overarching 主题:(1)恐惧回避体验的类型,(2)恐惧回避信念与行为的驱动因素,(3)恐惧回避信念与行为的后果。
- 所生成的主题基于中等置信度证据。
- 部分患者最初认为上肢骨折是相对轻微的损伤,但随时间推移意识到其具有广泛后果及长期恢复视角,这通常发生在初期恐惧减轻之后。
临床怎么用
- 骨折后立即提供教育与支持以预防或挑战关于跌倒恐惧和运动恐惧的初始健康信念对康复至关重要。
- 在急性上肢创伤环境中考虑恐惧回避并采取措施减轻其影响,将更好地服务于这些患者持续从损伤中康复。
局限性
- 主题基于中等置信度证据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: This systematic review aimed to understand older people's perspectives of associated fear-avoidant beliefs following upper limb fracture. METHODS: Published and unpublished literature databases were systematically searched from inception to 1st April 2023. Qualitative studies reporting the perspectives of fear-avoidant beliefs or behaviours in people who had sustained an upper limb fracture were eligible. Data extracted included characteristics of people interviewed, experiences and perceptions of fear, fear of falling, and fear-avoidant beliefs and behaviours. Data were synthesised using a meta-ethnography approach and the GRADE-CERQUAL tool. RESULTS: Eight studies were eligible (n = 150 participants; 109 distal radial/41 humeral fracture). Three overarching themes were identified: (1) type of fear-avoidant experiences, (2) drivers of fear-avoidant beliefs and behaviours, and (3) consequences of fear-avoidant beliefs and behaviours. The themes generated were based on moderate confidence evidence. In summary, whilst some patients initially consider upper limb fractures to be relatively minor injuries, over time, the realisation occurs that they have wide-ranging consequences with longer-term perspectives on recovery. This often occurs following an initial period of reduced fear. Providing education and support immediately post-fracture to prevent or challenge initial health beliefs around fear of falls and fear of movement is imperative to recovery. CONCLUSIONS: Fear-avoidant beliefs can impact heavily on certain older people's recovery, as well as their longer-term health and wellbeing. Consideration of fear avoidance and taking steps to mitigate against this in the acute upper limb trauma setting will better serve these patients in their ongoing recovery from injury.
引用
- Smith TO, Brown O, Baxter MA, et al. Fear-avoidant beliefs and behaviours after upper limb fracture in older people: a systematic review and meta-ethnography. Osteoporos Int. 2024. PMID: 38279074. doi:10.1007/s00198-024-07030-7
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。