精准还是陷阱?评估骨水泥型全髋关节置换术的ICD-10编码准确性:一项多中心研究
本研究回顾性分析了4个地理分布不同的学术医学中心在2015年10月至2020年10月期间实施的所有骨水泥型初次全髋关节置换术(THA),旨在确定ICD-10-PCS识别骨水泥固定的准确性。共识别552例骨水泥型THA,其中452例(81.9%)被正确编码为骨水泥型;在4个中心中3个中心的480例中,403例(84%)被正确报告至美国关节置换登记处(AJRR),317例(66%)既被正确编码又被正确报告。结论指出多个机构数据集存在差异,可能导致依赖ICD-10-PCS编码的登记处报告不准确,使用ICD-10操作数据评估行政索赔数据库的具体细节时应谨慎。
要点
- 共552例骨水泥型THA中452例(81.9%)ICD-10-PCS编码正确。
- 各中心正确编码比例:A中心187/260(72%),B中心158/185(85%),C中心35/35(100%),D中心72/72(100%)。
- 3个中心480例中403例(84%)正确报告至AJRR,317例(66%)既正确编码又正确报告。
核心结论
- 研究发现多个机构数据集存在差异,可能导致依赖ICD-10-PCS编码的AJRR和其他登记处报告不准确。
- 使用ICD-10操作数据评估行政索赔数据库的具体细节时应谨慎,因为这些不准确对数据有效性和解释构成固有挑战。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性综述4个地理分布不同的学术医学中心2015年10月至2020年10月期间实施的所有骨水泥型初次THA。
- 通过术后X线片和病历审查确定ICD-10-PCS编码相对于手术记录的准确性,并与美国关节置换登记处(AJRR)发布的机构级编码进行交叉核对。
主要发现
- 共识别552例骨水泥型THA,其中452例(81.9%)被ICD-10-PCS正确编码为骨水泥型。
- 正确编码比例:A中心187/260(72%),B中心158/185(85%),C中心35/35(100%),D中心72/72(100%)。
- 4个中心中3个中心的480例骨水泥型THA中,403例(84%)被正确报告为骨水泥型至AJRR:A中心185/260(71%),B中心185/185(100%),C中心33/35(94%)。
- 上述480例中,317例(66%)既被ICD-10-PCS正确编码又被正确报告为骨水泥型至AJRR。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems, 10th Revision, Procedure Coding System (ICD-10-PCS) was adopted in the U.S. in 2015. Proponents of the ICD-10-PCS have stated that its granularity allows for a more accurate representation of the types of procedures performed by including laterality, joint designation, and more detailed procedural data. However, other researchers have expressed concern that the increased number of codes adds further complexity that leads to inaccurate and inconsistent coding, rendering registry and research data based on ICD-10-PCS codes invalid and inaccurate. We aimed to determine the accuracy of the ICD-10-PCS for identifying cemented fixation in primary total hip arthroplasty (THA). METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed all cemented primary THAs performed at 4 geographically diverse, academic medical centers between October 2015 and October 2020. Cemented fixation was identified from the ICD-10-PCS coding for each procedure. The accuracy of an ICD-10-PCS code relative to the surgical record was determined by postoperative radiograph and chart review, and cross-referencing with institution-level coding published by the American Joint Replacement Registry (AJRR) was also performed. RESULTS: A total of 552 cemented THA cases were identified within the study period, of which 452 (81.9%) were correctly coded as cemented with the ICD-10-PCS. The proportion of cases that were correctly coded was 187 of 260 (72%) at Institution A, 158 of 185 (85%) at Institution B, 35 of 35 (100%) at Institution C, and 72 of 72 (100%) at Institution D. Of the 480 identified cemented THA cases at 3 of the 4 institutions, 403 (84%) were correctly reported as cemented to the AJRR (Institution A, 185 of 260 cases [71%]; Institution B, 185 of 185 [100%]; and Institution C, 33 of 35 [94%]). Lastly, of these 480 identified cemented THA cases, 317 (66%) were both correctly coded with the ICD-10-PCS and correctly reported as cemented to the AJRR. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings revealed existing discrepancies within multiple institutional data sets, which may lead to inaccurate reporting by the AJRR and other registries that rely on ICD-10-PCS coding. Caution should be exercised when utilizing ICD-10 procedural data to evaluate specific details from administrative claims databases as these inaccuracies present inherent challenges to data validity and interpretation.
引用
- Singh V, Jolissaint JE, Kohler JG, et al. Precision or Pitfall? Evaluating the Accuracy of ICD-10 Coding for Cemented Total Hip Arthroplasty: A Multicenter Study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2023. PMID: 37973050. doi:10.2106/JBJS.23.00325
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。