短暂性、游走性或局限性骨质疏松症及骨髓水肿综合征的术语:一项范围综述
本研究通过全面检索电子数据库和参考文献,纳入561篇关于髋部短暂性骨质疏松症(TOH)、局限性或区域游走性骨质疏松症(RMO)及骨髓水肿综合征(BMES)的文献(其中423篇为病例报告,涉及2921例患者),旨在梳理诊断术语的多样性和使用频率。结果显示TOH是最常用术语(257篇,45.8%),RMO用于34篇(6.1%),BMES用于57篇(10.2%),其余使用短暂性、游走性、区域性与骨质疏松或骨髓水肿的各种组合;76.3%的文献术语与骨质疏松相关,18.2%与骨髓水肿相关,但术语与实际发现并不对应。作者结论认为这些密切相关实体的术语混乱且不统一,缺乏正式定义阻碍了准确诊断、疾病机制研究和有效治疗。
要点
- TOH是最常用术语(257篇,45.8%),RMO用于34篇(6.1%),BMES用于57篇(10.2%)。
- 76.3%的文献术语与骨质疏松相关,18.2%与骨髓水肿相关,但术语与实际发现不对应。
- 骨质疏松通常经X线片肉眼判读确定,很少通过骨密度测定;许多文献使用骨质疏松相关术语却无证据表明检出骨质疏松。
核心结论
- 这些密切相关实体的术语混乱且不统一,缺乏正式定义阻碍了准确诊断、疾病机制研究和有效治疗。
研究设计与样本
- 范围综述,全面检索电子数据库和参考文献列表,纳入报告TOH、RMO、BMES或相关变异型患者的出版物,按标题、摘要或正文措辞对术语进行分类。
- 共纳入561篇出版物,其中423篇为病例报告,涉及2921例患者。
主要发现
- TOH是最常用术语,出现于257篇(45.8%)。
- RMO用于34篇(6.1%),BMES用于57篇(10.2%),其余使用短暂性、游走性和区域性与骨质疏松或骨髓水肿的各种组合。
- 局限性骨质疏松未被使用;识别出三种与妊娠相关的不同术语。
- 76.3%的出版物术语与骨质疏松相关,18.2%与骨髓水肿相关,但术语与实际发现不对应。
- 骨髓水肿与骨质疏松出现频率相当;骨质疏松通常经X线片肉眼判读确定,很少通过骨密度测定;许多出版物使用骨质疏松相关术语却无证据表明检出骨质疏松。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
There is no formally defined terminology for the related entities transient osteoporosis of the hip (TOH), localized or regional migratory osteoporosis (RMO) and bone marrow edema syndrome (BMES). This study aimed to map the diversity and frequency of diagnostic terms and vocabulary utilized in the literature. A comprehensive search of electronic databases and reference lists was conducted. Publications that reported on patients with TOH, RMO, BMES, or related variants were eligible for inclusion. The terminologies were categorized based on the wording of the titles, abstracts, or texts. We included 561 publications, of which 423 were case reports, involving 2921 patients. Overall, TOH was the most commonly used term, occurring in 257 (45.8%). RMO was used in 34 (6.1%) and BMES in 57 (10.2%). The remaining used various combinations of transient, migratory, and regional in conjunction with either osteoporosis or bone marrow edema. Localized osteoporosis was not used. We identified three different terms related to pregnancy. In 76.3% of the publications, the terminology was related to osteoporosis and in 18.2% to bone marrow edema, although terminology did not correspond to actual findings. Bone marrow edema occurred as often as osteoporosis, and osteoporosis was generally ascertained by visual inspection of radiographs, seldom by bone densitometry. Many publications used osteoporosis-related terms without evidence that osteoporosis had been detected. The terminology of these closely related entities is confusing and unstandardized. The lack of formal definitions impedes accurate diagnosis, research on disease mechanisms, and effective treatment.
引用
- Grøvle L, Haugen AJ, Johansen M, et al. The terminologies of transient, migratory, or localized osteoporosis, and bone marrow edema syndrome: a scoping review. Osteoporos Int. 2023. PMID: 37814095. doi:10.1007/s00198-023-06929-x
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。