社会剥夺和低传统健康素养是否与骨科手术中PROMIS CAT完成率较高相关?
在单中心城市四级学术医疗中心骨科亚专科门诊进行横断面纸质问卷调查研究,共分析287例患者。调整年龄后ADL评分与PROMIS CAT完成情况无关,但健康素养较低者更可能完全不完成问卷(OR 0.85 [95%CI 0.75-0.97];p=0.02);且11%完全完成PROMIS CAT的患者并未完全理解内容。
要点
- 调整年龄后社会剥夺指数(ADI)与PROMIS CAT完成情况无关。
- 健康素养较低者完全不完成PROMIS CAT的比值比为0.85(95%CI 0.75-0.97;p=0.02)。
- 11%(26/229)完全完成PROMIS CAT的患者并未完全理解问卷内容。
核心结论
- 在城市社会经济多样化的骨科患者群体中,健康素养与PROMIS CAT问卷完成情况相关。
- 健康素养较低增加完全不完成任何部分PROMIS CAT问卷的可能性。
- 患者可在未完全理解问题的情况下完成PROMIS CAT,提示完成并不保证理解或评分有效性,在低健康素养患者中更甚。
研究设计与样本
- 2022年6月至2022年8月,在单一城市四级学术医疗中心足踝、创伤和手/上肢骨科亚专科门诊进行横断面纸质问卷调查。
- 纳入18岁及以上英语患者,因门诊时间限制采用便利抽样,从946例合格患者中接触36%(339/946),15%(52/339)拒绝,最终分析85%(287/339)。
- 中位(范围)年龄49岁(35至64);58%(167/287)为非西班牙裔黑人或非裔美国人,26%(75/287)为非西班牙裔白人。
主要发现
- PROMIS CAT自报完成情况:80%(229/287)完全完成,13%(37/287)部分完成,7%(21/287)完全未完成。
- 调整年龄后ADI评分与PROMIS CAT完成情况无关:部分完成OR 1.00(95%CI 0.98-1.01;p=0.72),完全未完成OR 1.01(95%CI 0.99-1.03;p=0.45)。
- 健康素养较低者完全不完成任何部分问卷的OR 0.85(95%CI 0.75-0.97;p=0.02)。
- 74%(26/35)未完全理解PROMIS CAT所有问题的患者仍完全完成问卷,即11%(26/229)完全完成PROMIS CAT的患者未完全理解内容。
- 在有健康素养数据的完全完成PROMIS CAT患者中,健康素养不足/边缘者较健康素养充足者更可能未完全理解所有问题:21%(14/67)vs 8%(12/160),OR 3.26(95%CI 1.42-7.49;p=0.005)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,在骨科人群中临床实施PROMIS CAT将受益于进一步研究健康素养,以提高问卷完成率并确保患者理解所回答问题的内容,从而增加结局测量的内部有效性。
局限性
- 对PROMIS CAT理解问题的回答可能受社会期望偏倚限制,可能高估真正理解问卷内容的人数。
- 因门诊时间限制采用便利抽样(946例合格患者中接触36% [339/946])。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System® (PROMIS®) may be used to assess an individual patient's perspective of their physical, mental, and social health through either standard or computer adaptive testing (CAT) patient questionnaires. These questionnaires are used across disciplines; however, they have seen considerable application in orthopaedic surgery. Patient characteristics associated with PROMIS CAT completion have not been examined within the context of social determinants of health, such as social deprivation or health literacy, nor has patient understanding of the content of PROMIS CAT been assessed. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) What patient demographics, including social deprivation, are associated with completion of PROMIS CAT questionnaires? (2) Is health literacy level associated with completion of PROMIS CAT questionnaires? (3) Do patients with lower health literacy have a higher odds of completing PROMIS CAT without fully understanding the content? METHODS: Between June 2022 and August 2022, a cross-sectional study was performed via a paper survey administered to patients at a single, urban, quaternary academic medical center in orthopaedic subspecialty clinics of foot and ankle, trauma, and hand/upper extremity surgeons. We considered all English-speaking patients aged 18 or older, including those with limited reading and/or writing abilities, as eligible provided they received an iPad in clinic to complete the PROMIS CAT questionnaire as part of their routine standard clinical care or they completed the questionnaire via a patient portal before the visit. In all, 946 patients were considered eligible during the study period and a convenience sample of 36% (339 of 946) of patients was approached for inclusion due to clinic time constraints. Fifteen percent (52 of 339) declined to participate, leaving 85% (287 of 339) of patients for analysis here. Median (range) age of study participants was 49 years (35 to 64). Fifty-eight percent (167 of 287) of study participants self-identified as non-Hispanic Black or African American and 26% (75 of 287) as non-Hispanic White. Even proportions were observed across education levels (high school graduate or less, 29% [82 of 287]; some college, 25% [73 of 287]; college graduate, 25% [71 of 287]; advanced degree, 20% [58 of 287]). Eighteen percent (52 of 287) of patients reported an annual income bracket of USD 0 to 13,000, and 17% (48 of 287) reported more than USD 120,000. Forty-six percent (132 of 287) of patients worked full-time, 21% (59 of 287) were retired, and 23% (66 of 287) were unemployed or on disability. The primary outcome of interest was self-reported PROMIS CAT questionnaire completion grouped as: fully completed, partially completed, or no part completed. Overall, self-reported PROMIS CAT questionnaire completion proportions were: 80% (229 of 287) full completion, 13% (37 of 287) partial completion, and 7% (21 of 287) no part completed. We collected the National Area Deprivation Index (ADI) score and the Brief Health Literacy Screening Tool (BRIEF) as part of the study survey to associate with level of completion. Additionally, patient understanding of PROMIS CAT was assessed through Likert-scaled responses to a study survey question that directly asked whether the patient understood all of the questions on the PROMIS CAT questionnaire. Responses to this question may have been limited by social desirability bias, and hence may overestimate how many individuals genuinely understood the questionnaire content. However, the benefit of this approach was it efficiently allowed us to estimate the ceiling effect of patient comprehension of PROMIS CAT and likely had a high degree of specificity for detecting lack of comprehension. RESULTS: ADI score adjusted for age was not associated with PROMIS CAT completion (partial completion OR 1.00 [95% CI 0.98 to 1.01]; p = 0.72, no part completed OR 1.01 [95% CI 0.99 to 1.03]; p = 0.45). Patients with lower health literacy scores, however, were more likely to not complete any part of their assigned questionnaires than patients with higher scores (no part completed OR 0.85 [95% CI 0.75 to 0.97]; p = 0.02). Additionally, 74% (26 of 35) of patients who did not fully understand all of the PROMIS CAT questionnaire questions still fully completed them-hence, 11% (26 of 229) of all patients who fully completed PROMIS CAT did not fully understand the content. Among patients self-reporting full completion of PROMIS CAT with health literacy data (99% [227 of 229]), patients with inadequate/marginal health literacy were more likely than patients with adequate health literacy to not fully understand all of the questions (21% [14 of 67] versus 8% [12 of 160], OR 3.26 [95% CI 1.42 to 7.49]; p = 0.005). CONCLUSION: Within an urban, socioeconomically diverse, orthopaedic patient population, health literacy was associated with PROMIS CAT questionnaire completion. Lower health literacy levels increased the likelihood of not completing any part of the assigned PROMIS CAT questionnaires. Additionally, patients completed PROMIS CAT without fully understanding the questions. This indicates that patient completion does not guarantee comprehension of the questions nor validity of their scores, even more so among patients with low health literacy. This is a substantive concern for fidelity of data gathered from PROMIS CAT. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Clinical implementation of the PROMIS CAT in orthopaedic populations will benefit from further research into health literacy to increase questionnaire completion and to ensure that patients understand the content of the questions they are answering, which will increase the internal validity of the outcome measure.
引用
- Litvak AL, Lin NA, Hynes KK, et al. Are Social Deprivation and Low Traditional Health Literacy Associated With Higher PROMIS CAT Completion in Orthopaedic Surgery? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2023. PMID: 37732819. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002861
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。