文献速递创伤骨科手外科与足踝外科

疑似舟骨骨折患者常规MRI检查存在过度诊断风险

Routine MRI Among Patients With a Suspected Scaphoid Fracture Risks Overdiagnosis.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2023-09-14

该回顾性诊断研究纳入256例临床疑似舟骨骨折且X线阴性的患者,分析其MRI信号改变类型。结果显示仅6%的图像显示明确或可能的舟骨骨折,而29%显示非特异性信号改变,其中舟骨腰部信号改变者中69%为 distracting 且可能误导的发现,提示常规MRI存在过度诊断及过度治疗风险。

要点

  • 疑似舟骨骨折患者中,MRI显示明确或可能舟骨骨折的比例仅为6%。
  • 29%的MRI图像显示非特异性信号改变,其中腰部信号改变者69%为 distracting 发现。
  • 常规MRI对疑似舟骨骨折存在过度诊断风险,支持更选择性使用MRI及患者参与决策。

核心结论

  • distracting 且可能误导的MRI信号改变高发、明确代表舟骨骨折的信号改变低发,以及疑似舟骨骨折患者真实骨折验前概率低,表明常规MRI存在显著的过度诊断和潜在过度治疗风险。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性研究,在一家与一级创伤中心关联的骨科创伤门诊进行,评估2012年1月1日至2019年9月1日期间310例16岁及以上临床疑似舟骨骨折患者的MRI,最终分析256例MR图像。
  • 排除标准包括:MRI前X线已报告可见舟骨骨折(4例)、MRI前无可用X线(2例)、伤后超过3周行MRI(28例)、受伤日期未知(9例)、重复或双侧MRI扫描(11例)。
  • 患者中女性占60%(153例),中位年龄34岁(IQR 21至50岁),MRI在伤后中位8天(IQR 2至12天)进行。

主要发现

  • 6%(16/256)的MR图像被分类为明确(2%[4/256])或可能(5%[12/256])舟骨骨折。
  • 29%(74/256)的MR图像被分类为显示非特异性信号改变,位于腰部(14%[35/256])和其他区域(15%[39/256])。
  • 在51例舟骨腰部信号改变的患者中,69%(35例)被分类为具有 distracting 且可能误导的MRI发现。

关键数值与推荐

  • 明确舟骨骨折定义为:线状、局灶性、双皮质信号异常,伴邻近水肿,且相对于舟骨长轴呈相对横向走行,横向线性信号在多个平面的多个切层上可见。
  • 可能舟骨骨折定义为:在矢状面或冠状面多个切层上可见横向线性信号,伴或不伴邻近水肿。
  • 信号改变模式的可靠性为kappa 0.62。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,基于初步证据支持两种替代策略值得额外关注:根据临床预测规则对风险较高者更选择性地使用MRI,以及让患者参与关于如何处理未来症状性骨不连这一显著小风险的决策。
  • 本研究中心的做法是,对于有疑似舟骨骨折症状和体征且X线阴性的患者进行MRI扫描。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: In the setting of a suspected scaphoid fracture, MRI may result in overdiagnosis and potential overtreatment. This is in part because of the low prevalence of true fractures among suspected fractures, but also because of potentially misleading variations in signal that may be more common than fracture-related signal changes. To better understand the risk of overdiagnosis, we first need insight into the relative prevalence of useful and potentially distracting signal changes among patients with a suspected scaphoid fracture. QUESTION/PURPOSE: What is the proportion of signal changes representing definite and possible scaphoid fractures relative to other types of signal changes on MRI among patients with a suspected scaphoid fracture? METHODS: In a retrospective study in an orthopaedic trauma clinic associated with a Level I trauma center, we evaluated MR images of patients 16 years and older with a clinically suspected scaphoid fracture. At our institution, patients with symptoms and signs of a possible scaphoid fracture and negative radiographs undergo MRI scanning. Between January 1, 2012, and September 1, 2019, a total of 310 patients 16 years or older had an MRI to evaluate a suspected scaphoid fracture. Exclusion criteria included a scaphoid fracture that was visible on radiographs before MRI as reported by the radiologist (four patients), no available radiographs before MRI (two), MRI more than 3 weeks after injury (28), unknown date of injury (nine), and repeat or bilateral MRI scans (11), leaving 256 MR images for analysis. Sixty percent (153) of patients were women, and the median age was 34 years (IQR 21 to 50 years). The images were taken a median of 8 days (IQR 2 to 12 days) after injury. MR images were screened for the presence of scaphoid signal changes. We identified the following patterns of signal change with a reliability of kappa 0.62: definite scaphoid fracture, possible scaphoid fracture, signal in the waist area other than possible or definite fractures, and other signal changes. A definite scaphoid fracture was defined as a linear, focal, and bicortical signal abnormality, with adjacent edema and a relatively transverse orientation relative to the scaphoid long axis. The transverse linear signal was visible on more than one cut in multiple planes. A possible scaphoid fracture had a transverse linear signal on more than one cut on sagittal or coronal planes, with or without adjacent edema. RESULTS: Six percent (16 of 256) of MR images were categorized as revealing definite (2% [four of 256]) or possible (5% [12 of 256]) scaphoid fractures, whereas 29% (74 of 256) were categorized as revealing nonspecific signal changes at the waist (14% [35 of 256]) and other areas (15% [39 of 256]). Of the 51 patients with scaphoid waist signal changes, 69% (35) were categorized as having distracting and potentially misleading MRI findings. CONCLUSION: The high prevalence of signal changes that are distracting and potentially misleading, the low prevalence of signal changes that clearly represent a scaphoid fracture, and the low pretest odds of a true fracture among patients with a suspected scaphoid fracture illustrate that routine MRI of suspected scaphoid fractures carries a notable risk of overdiagnosis and potential overtreatment. Two alternative strategies are supported by preliminary evidence and merit additional attention: more-selective use of MRI in people deemed at higher risk according to a clinical prediction rule and strategies for involving the patient in decisions regarding how to manage the notably small risk of future symptomatic nonunion. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, diagnostic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Bulstra AEJ, van Boxel MF, Crijns TJ, et al. Routine MRI Among Patients With a Suspected Scaphoid Fracture Risks Overdiagnosis. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2023. PMID: 37707789. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002851

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。