全球髋部骨折审计的标准化可促进学习、提升质量并指导循证实践
该研究比较了覆盖20个国家的17个髋部骨折登记处与脆性骨折网络(FFN)2022年修订的最小通用数据集(MCD)的兼容性。结果显示,最新建立的登记处对MCD的依从性最高,第一代、第二代和第三代登记处分别收集了60%、75%和85%的MCD字段。研究结论认为现有登记处与MCD之间具有中等但正在改善的兼容性。
要点
- 第三代登记处对MCD字段的依从性最高(85%),第一代和第二代分别为60%和75%。
- 所有17个登记处均收集的5个核心字段包括年龄、性别、手术日期/时间、手术类型和急性入院期间死亡。
- 仅11/17(65%)登记处收集的三个核心字段为伤前活动能力/日常生活活动、入院时认知和骨保护药物处方。
核心结论
- 现有登记处与FFN MCD之间具有中等但正在改善的兼容性,2022年MCD的引入与最新建立项目的依从性水平提高相关。
- 提高伤前功能、认知、骨保护和随访时长等数据收集的一致性可促进更大的互操作性,并可能改善国际协作基准比较、研究和质量改进。
研究设计与样本
- 研究比较了覆盖20个国家的17个髋部骨折登记处与FFN MCD的20个核心字段和12个可选字段的兼容性。
主要发现
- 最新建立的登记处对MCD的依从性最高。
- 第一代登记处(斯堪的纳维亚)收集了60%的MCD字段数据,第二代登记处(英国、其他欧洲国家、澳大利亚和新西兰)收集了75%,第三代登记处收集了85%。
- 所有17个登记处均收集的5个核心字段为:年龄、性别、手术日期/手术时间、手术类型和急性入院期间死亡。
- 大多数(16/17;94%)登记处收集的2个字段为:就诊日期/时间和美国麻醉医师协会分级。
- 多数(15/17;88%)登记处收集的5个字段为:骨折类型、侧别和病理性质、麻醉方式和出院去向。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: National hip fracture registries audit similar aspects of care but there is variation in the actual data collected; these differences restrict international comparison, benchmarking, and research. The Fragility Fracture Network (FFN) published a revised minimum common dataset (MCD) in 2022 to improve consistency and interoperability. Our aim was to assess compatibility of existing registries with the MCD. METHODS: We compared 17 hip fracture registries covering 20 countries (Argentina; Australia and New Zealand; China; Denmark; England, Wales, and Northern Ireland; Germany; Holland; Ireland; Japan; Mexico; Norway; Pakistan; the Philippines; Scotland; South Korea; Spain; and Sweden), setting each of these against the 20 core and 12 optional fields of the MCD. RESULTS: The highest MCD adherence was demonstrated by the most recently established registries. The first-generation registries in Scandinavia collect data for 60% of MCD fields, second-generation registries (UK, other European, and Australia and New Zealand) collect for 75%, and third-generation registries collect data for 85% of MCD fields. Five of the 20 core fields were collected by all 17 registries (age; sex; surgery date/time of operation; surgery type; and death during acute admission). Two fields were collected by most (16/17; 94%) registries (date/time of presentation and American Society of Anesthesiologists grade), and five more by the majority (15/17; 88%) registries (type, side, and pathological nature of fracture; anaesthetic modality; and discharge destination). Three core fields were each collected by only 11/17 (65%) registries: prefracture mobility/activities of daily living; cognition on admission; and bone protection medication prescription. CONCLUSION: There is moderate but improving compatibility between existing registries and the FFN MCD, and its introduction in 2022 was associated with an improved level of adherence among the most recently established programmes. Greater interoperability could be facilitated by improving consistency of data collection relating to prefracture function, cognition, bone protection, and follow-up duration, and this could improve international collaborative benchmarking, research, and quality improvement.
引用
- Johansen A, Hall AJ, Ojeda-Thies C, et al. Standardization of global hip fracture audit could facilitate learning, improve quality, and guide evidence-based practice. Bone Joint J. 2023. PMID: 37652448. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.105B9.BJJ-2023-0281
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。