基于MRI的椎体骨质量评分:与年龄的关系及可重复性
这项回顾性研究纳入136例20-69岁患者,在3个月内接受两次T1加权腰椎MRI,评估椎体骨质量(VBQ)评分与年龄的相关性及重复扫描的可重复性。控制MRI弛豫/回波时间后,VBQ(L1-4)评分与年龄正相关,序列MRI间可重复性优良(CV=0.169),VBQ(L1)与VBQ(L1-4)公式间一致性优良(ICC>0.9)。
要点
- 控制MRI弛豫/回波时间后,VBQ(L1-4)评分与年龄正相关。
- 序列MRI间VBQ(L1-4)评分可重复性优良,CV为0.169。
- VBQ(L1)与VBQ(L1-4)两公式间一致性优良,ICC>0.9。
核心结论
- 包括MRI技术因素和年龄在内的外在因素可影响VBQ(L1-4)评分,使用该工具估算骨密度(BMD)时必须考虑。
- VBQ(L1-4)评分与年龄正相关。
- 控制技术因素时,VBQ(L1-4)评分在序列MRI间的可重复性优良,支持使用VBQ评分估算BMD。
- VBQ(L1)评分是VBQ(L1-4)评分的可靠替代。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究纳入136例年龄20-69岁患者,在2011年1月至2021年12月间接受两次间隔3个月内的T1加权腰椎MRI。
- VBQ(L1-4)评分计算为L1-L4信号强度(SI)与L3脑脊液(CSF)SI的商。
- VBQ(L1)评分计算为L1 SI与L1 CSF SI的商。
- 采用回归分析确定VBQ(L1-4)评分与年龄的相关性,采用变异系数(CV)确定序列MRI扫描间VBQ(L1-4)评分的可重复性。
主要发现
- 共纳入136例患者(平均±标准差年龄44.9±12.5岁;女性占53.7%)。
- 影响VBQ评分的外在因素包括患者年龄、MRI弛豫时间和特定MRI机器。
- 控制MRI弛豫/回波时间后,VBQ(L1-4)评分与年龄正相关,序列MRI间可重复性优良,CV为0.169。
- VBQ(L1)与VBQ(L1-4)两公式所得VBQ评分一致性优良(ICC>0.9)。
关键数值与推荐
- VBQ(L1-4)评分在序列MRI间的变异系数(CV)为0.169。
- VBQ(L1)与VBQ(L1-4)两公式所得VBQ评分的组内相关系数(ICC)>0.9。
临床怎么用
- 使用VBQ评分估算骨密度(BMD)时须考虑MRI技术因素和年龄等外在因素。
- 控制技术因素时,VBQ(L1-4)评分在序列MRI间可重复性优良,支持使用VBQ评分估算BMD。
- VBQ(L1)评分可作为VBQ(L1-4)评分的可靠替代。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
UNLABELLED: Vertebral bone quality (VBQ) score is an opportunistic measure of bone mineral density using routine preoperative MRI in spine surgery. VBQ score positively correlates with age and is reproducible across serial scans. However, extrinsic factors, including MRI machine and protocol, affect the VBQ score and must be standardized. PURPOSE: The purposes of this study were to determine whether VBQ score increased with age and whether VBQ remained consistent across serial MRI studies obtained within 3 months. METHODS: This retrospective study evaluated 136 patients, age 20-69, who received two T1-weighted lumbar MRI within 3 months of each other between January 2011 and December 2021. VBQ(L1-4) score was calculated as the quotient of L1-L4 signal intensity (SI) and L3 cerebral spinal fluid (CSF) SI. VBQ(L1) score was calculated as the quotient of L1 SI and L1 CSF SI. Regression analysis was performed to determine correlation of VBQ(L1-4) score with age. Coefficient of variation (CV) was used to determine reproducibility between VBQ(L1-4) scores from serial MRI scans. RESULTS: One hundred thirty-six patients (mean ± SD age 44.9 ± 12.5 years; 53.7% female) were included in this study. Extrinsic factors affecting the VBQ score included patient age, MRI relaxation time, and specific MRI machine. When controlling for MRI relaxation/echo time, the VBQ(L1-4) score was positively correlated with age and had excellent reproducibility in serial MRI with CV of 0.169. There was excellent agreement (ICC > 0.9) of VBQ scores derived from the two formulas, VBQ(L1) and VBQ(L1-4). CONCLUSION: Extrinsic factors, including MRI technical factors and age, can impact the VBQ(L1-4) score and must be considered when using this tool to estimate bone mineral density (BMD). VBQ(L1-4) score was positively correlated with age. Reproducibility of the VBQ(L1-4) score across serial MRI is excellent especially when controlling for technical factors, supporting use of the VBQ score in estimating BMD. The VBQ(L1) score was a reliable alternative to the VBQ(L1-4) score.
引用
- Liu D, Kadri A, Hernando D, et al. MRI-based vertebral bone quality score: relationship with age and reproducibility. Osteoporos Int. 2023. PMID: 37640844. doi:10.1007/s00198-023-06893-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。