国际关节置换术感知风险测量倡议:一项多国调查研究结果
该倡议向8个国家的外科医生发送了针对各自支付与惩罚模型调整的调查问卷,评估其对全髋或全膝关节置换术患者医疗及社会经济风险的感知。本文主要报告加拿大、爱尔兰和英国的结果,发现各国对糖尿病患者感知风险存在较大差异,但对年龄、体质指数、性别及社会经济状况的风险感知在各医疗体系中出奇一致。作者建议建立更好的风险调整模型以帮助逆转关节置换术可及性差异。
要点
- 调查覆盖8个国家,本文主要报告加拿大、爱尔兰和英国结果。
- 各国对糖尿病患者的感知风险存在较大差异,糖化血红蛋白切点不一。
- 对年龄、体质指数、性别及社会经济状况的风险感知在各医疗体系中出奇一致。
核心结论
- 外科医生会依据最佳可得证据尝试优化具有可逆风险患者的健康状况。
- 证据质量参差不齐,尤其对于不可逆的社会风险因素,因对成本和结局的担忧而有限,这些担忧可能受经验驱动的风险感知影响。
- 结果表明风险感知确实在许多医疗提供环境中对可及性产生此类影响。
- 作者建议建立更好的医疗和社会经济风险因素风险调整模型,并可能就报销调整和报告进行分层或排除,以帮助逆转关节置换术可及性差异。
研究设计与样本
- 该倡议向8个不同国家的外科医生发送调查问卷,每份问卷针对各自独特的支付、报酬和惩罚模型进行调整。
- 调查问题涉及外科医生对具有全髋或全膝关节置换术指征患者的医疗和社会经济因素的风险感知。
- 本文主要报告加拿大、爱尔兰和英国的结果。
主要发现
- 医疗体系从全民或国家资助(加拿大)到几乎完全私立(印度)不等。
- 部分医疗体系采用捆绑支付并对需再入院或再手术的术后并发症保留费用,包括部分公开结局数据(美国和英国),而其他体系则没有(加拿大)。
- 各国对糖尿病患者的感知风险存在一些重大差异,其糖化血红蛋白切点不一,有的甚至未使用。
- 总体而言,对年龄、体质指数、年龄、性别、社会经济和社会状况的风险感知在各医疗体系中保持出奇一致。
- 所设定的任何限制主要由外科医生决策驱动,而非外部要求。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 证据质量参差不齐。
- 尤其对于不可逆的社会风险因素,证据因对成本和结局的担忧而有限,这些担忧可能受经验驱动的风险感知影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There is an inherent moral imperative to avoid complications from arthroplasty. Doing so at ideal cost is also associated with surgeon reputation, and, increasingly in health care delivery systems that measure and competitively score outcomes, reimbursement to the surgeons and their hospitals. As a result, patients who are perceived to be in higher risk comorbidity groups, such as the obese and diabetics, as well as those challenged by socioeconomic factors may face barriers to access elective arthroplasty. METHODS: In this initiative, surveys were sent to surgeons in 8 different countries, each adapted for their own unique payment, remuneration, and punitive models. The questions in the surveys pertained to surgeons' perception of risk regarding medical and socioeconomic factors in patients indicated for total hip or knee arthroplasty. This paper primarily reports on the results from Canada, Ireland, and the United Kingdom. RESULTS: The health care systems varied between a universal/state funded health care system (Canada) to those that were almost exclusively private (India). Some health care systems have "bundled" payment with retention of fees for postoperative complications requiring readmission/reoperation and including some with public publication of outcome data (United States and the United Kingdom), whereas others had none (Canada). There were some major discrepancies across different countries regarding the perceived risk of diabetic patients, who have variable Hemoglobin A1c cut-offs, if any used. However, overall the perception of risk for age, body mass index, age, sex, socioeconomic, and social situations remained surprisingly consistent throughout the health care systems. Any limitations set were primarily driven by surgeon decision making and not external demands. CONCLUSION: Surgeons will understandably try and optimize the health status of patients who have reversible risks as shown by best available evidence. The evidence is of variable quality, and, especially for irreversible social risk factors, limited due to concerns over cost and quality outcomes that can be influenced by experience-driven perceptions of risk. The results show that perceptions of risk do have such influence on access across many health care delivery environments. The authors recommend better risk-adjustment models for medical and socioeconomic risk factors with possible stratification/exclusions regarding reimbursement adjustments and reporting to help reverse disparities of access to arthroplasty.
引用
- Atrey A, Yates AJ, O'Connor MI, et al. The International Initiative to Measure Perceived Risk in Arthroplasty: The Results From a Multinational Survey. J Arthroplasty. 2023. PMID: 37595767. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2023.08.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。