女性骨科医生考虑关节置换专科培训的动机与障碍
通过匿名问卷调查164名女性骨科医生和学员,其中72人选择关节置换专科、92人选择其他亚专科,分析选择或不选择关节置换的原因。选择关节置换者最看重对手术的喜爱,最大担忧为工作与生活平衡、受孕或健康妊娠能力及转诊医生的性别偏见;曾考虑关节置换但最终选择其他专科者中,30.4%曾「少许」考虑、8.7%曾「强烈」考虑关节置换,主要阻碍为「男孩俱乐部」文化、手术体力要求及缺乏导师。
要点
- 选择关节置换者最重要的动机是喜爱手术操作本身。
- 关节置换组最大担忧为工作与生活平衡、妊娠能力及转诊医生性别偏见。
- 曾考虑关节置换但选其他专科者中30.4%「少许」考虑、8.7%「强烈」考虑。
核心结论
- 选择职业路径的决定是多因素的,作者希望识别可改变因素以提高女性在关节置换领域的代表性。
- 作者认为增加导师指导、实施改善工作与生活平衡的实际方案、支持健康妊娠及减轻手术体力要求可能有助于解决当前差异。
研究设计与样本
- 通过REDCap发放匿名问卷,经邮件列表、社交媒体群组及住院医师项目招募女性骨科医生和学员。
- 纳入已决定特定亚专科或已完成专科培训的医生,共获得164名医生回应,其中关节置换72人、其他亚专科92人。
- 采用卡方检验和Fisher精确检验进行统计分析。
主要发现
- 选择关节置换者最重要的因素是对手术的喜爱。
- 关节置换组对该领域最大的担忧为工作与生活平衡、受孕和/或健康妊娠的能力以及转诊医生的性别偏见。
- 最终选择其他亚专科者中,30.4%曾「少许」考虑关节置换,8.7%曾「强烈」考虑关节置换。
- 曾考虑关节置换但最终选择其他专科者的最重要阻碍为对「男孩俱乐部」文化的担忧、对手术体力要求的担忧及缺乏导师。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Arthroplasty is one of the least gender-diverse orthopaedic subspecialties. While previous studies have looked at factors influencing fellowship choices for women, few studies have attempted to understand the decision for or against arthroplasty specifically. Working to better understand fellowship choice is a critical step in the process of increasing women recruitment. METHODS: An anonymous survey was distributed using REDCap to women orthopaedic surgeons and trainees through listservs, social media groups, and residency programs. Surgeons who had decided on a specific subspecialty or already completed fellowship were included. Responses were obtained from 164 surgeons (72 arthroplasty surgeons, 92 other subspecialties). Chi-squared and Fisher's Exact tests were then performed. RESULTS: The most important factor for those who chose arthroplasty was enjoyment of the surgeries. The biggest concerns from those in the arthroplasty group about the field were work-life balance, ability to become pregnant and/or have a healthy pregnancy, and sex bias from referring physicians. Of those who ultimately chose another subspecialty, 30.4% considered arthroplasty "a little" and 8.7% considered it "strongly." The most important dissuaders for the group that considered arthroplasty were concerns about "boy's club" culture, concerns about the physicality of the surgeries, and a lack of mentors. CONCLUSION: While the decision to choose a career path is multifactorial, our hope is that through the identification of modifiable factors we can increase women representation in arthroplasty. Increasing mentorship, implementing practical solutions to improve work-life balance, supporting healthy pregnancies, and mitigating the physical demands of surgery could help address current disparities.
引用
- Lancaster AJ, Stevenson KL, Noel PH, et al. Motivations and Barriers for Women Orthopaedic Surgeons Considering Arthroplasty Fellowship. J Arthroplasty. 2023. PMID: 37572723. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2023.08.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。