多数骨肉瘤患者寻求情感支持及他人治疗经历信息:一项主题分析
该研究采用扎根理论方法分析2012年1月1日至2022年5月1日期间五个骨肉瘤在线讨论论坛的570条帖子,识别出情感联系与信息支持(诊断、治疗、康复)四类主题,其中情感方面与连接他人最为普遍(78%的帖子),其次为治疗信息支持(49%的帖子)。作者认为大多数帖子包含经验信息和情感支持而非直接医疗建议,未来研究应评估在线肉瘤论坛中共享信息的准确性。
要点
- 情感支持与连接他人是骨肉瘤论坛最常见主题,占78%的帖子。
- 治疗信息支持次之,占49%的帖子;诊断与康复信息支持各占15%。
- 作者建议医生提供情感支持并推荐可靠的在线论坛资源。
核心结论
- 分析帖子发现两个最常见主题涉及寻求情感支持以及关于各种治疗方式他人经历的信息。
- 尽管评估的大多数帖子包含经验信息和情感支持而非直接医疗建议,未来研究应评估在线肉瘤论坛中共享信息的准确性。
研究设计与样本
- 通过搜索词「sarcoma discussion forum」识别在线讨论论坛,排除封闭群组、链接缺失或无效的网站以及非公开论坛(如Facebook群组),最终评审五个讨论板。
- 收集2012年1月1日至2022年5月1日期间发布的帖子,直至达到数据饱和(即额外收集帖子不会揭示新主题)。
- 筛选讨论线程以识别与最常见骨肉瘤(软骨肉瘤、尤文肉瘤和骨肉瘤)相关的帖子。
- 采用扎根理论分析帖子,进行三轮文本审阅(开放编码、轴心编码、选择性编码),共分析来自139个线程的570条帖子,生成25个轴心编码和4个选择性编码。
- 照护者帖子与患者帖子分开并单独分类进行亚组分析。
主要发现
- 四个选择性编码包括情感方面或连接他人、信息支持:诊断、信息支持:治疗和信息支持:康复。
- 情感方面与连接他人是最普遍的主题,占570条帖子中的445条(78%)。
- 信息支持:治疗占570条帖子中的282条(49%)。
- 信息支持:诊断和信息支持:康复各占帖子的15%。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,照护肉瘤患者的医生不仅应处理与医疗护理相关的患者关切,还应直接提供情感支持,并通过提供包括在线讨论论坛在内的同伴支持渠道资源来协助患者。
- 作者指出,由于帖子匿名无法确定使用在线网站的患者比例,但这些发现提示肉瘤患者在医生诊室之外存在共同的经验主题。
- 作者认为,医疗服务提供者应了解可靠的论坛以作为资源提供给患者。
- 作者认为,肌肉骨骼肿瘤学会可考虑背书一个或多个此类论坛并提供医生监督以监测错误信息。
局限性
- 由于纳入帖子的匿名性,无法确定使用在线网站的患者比例。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Online discussion forums allow individuals who otherwise may be strangers to create a community where they can seek and share information. Patients with bone sarcomas and their support networks use discussion forums dedicated to cancer support. There is a paucity of published reports regarding the care experience of patients with bone sarcomas because studies on online discussion groups have primarily focused on some of the more common cancers, including breast and prostate cancer. Understanding commonly discussed themes among patients with bone sarcomas would allow treating physicians to have a better understanding of patient concerns when providing patient education and counseling. QUESTION/PURPOSE: We performed this study to review posts from bone sarcoma internet discussion boards to establish common themes related to the care experience of patients with sarcomas. METHODS: Online discussion forums were identified using the search term "sarcoma discussion forum." After identifying 12 websites, we excluded closed forum groups, websites with missing or invalid links to forums, and nonpublic forums, such as groups on Facebook. These websites include profiles and photos that are personal, and sufficient author anonymity could not be achieved for this study. Posts written between January 1, 2012, and May 1, 2022, posted on five discussion boards were reviewed and collected until we reached a point of data saturation in which we agreed that the collection of additional posts would not reveal new themes. Discussion threads were filtered to identify posts pertaining to the most common bone sarcomas: chondrosarcoma, Ewing sarcoma, and osteosarcoma. Grounded theory-the methodology of repeated analyses of qualitative data to identify recurring themes or concepts-was used to analyze posts. Caregiver posts were delineated from patient posts and categorized separately for subgroup analysis. Grounded theory, although a qualitative method, endeavors to integrate the strengths inherent in quantitative methods with qualitative approaches. Grounded theory categorizes words, language, and the meanings these imply and seeks to organize and reduce the data gathered into themes or essences, which, in turn, can be fed into descriptions, models, or theories. Our analysis used three reviews of text to assign and group codes based on repeating ideas or concepts. The first review (open coding) aims to assign codes based on the verbatim text included by the author to capture the specific thoughts and ideas of the post. The second review (axial coding) aims to consolidate the ideas of posts by applying broader concepts to each post. The third and final review (selective coding) aims to further consolidate the themes of each post by trying to embody the main message contained in a post. A total of 570 posts from 139 threads were collected and analyzed using grounded theory. Twenty-five axial codes and four selective codes were created. We defined data saturation by the absence of a new open code in the analysis of a block of 50 posts to ensure that signals of saturation were not accepted too early in the analysis. RESULTS: The four selective codes included emotional aspects or connecting with others, information support: diagnosis, information support: treatment, and information support: recovery. Of these four codes, emotional aspects and connecting with others was the most prevalent theme (78% [445 of 570] of posts) followed by information support: treatment (49% [282 of 570] of posts). Information support: diagnosis and information support: recovery were each captured in 15% of posts. CONCLUSION: Analysis of posts reveals that the two most common themes involve seeking out emotional support and information about the experiences of others with various treatment modalities. Although most of the posts we assessed contained experiential information and emotional support rather than directed medical advice, future studies should assess the accuracy of information shared among online sarcoma forums. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Physicians caring for patients with sarcomas should not only address patient concerns related to medical care, but also provide emotional support directly and assist patients by providing resources to peer support outlets, including online discussion forums. Although we cannot ascertain the proportion of patients who use online sites given the anonymity of posts included, these findings suggest common experiential themes across patients with sarcomas outside their doctors' offices. It is important that providers be aware of reputable forums to provide as resources for their patients. The Musculoskeletal Tumor Society may further benefit from endorsing one or more of these forums and providing physician oversight to monitor misinformation.
引用
- Paulson AE, Stein A, Kendal JK, et al. Most Patients With Bone Sarcomas Seek Emotional Support and Information About Other Patients' Experiences: A Thematic Analysis. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2023. PMID: 37432118. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002761
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。