文献速递手外科与足踝外科

基于症状和体征诊断轻中度腕管特发性正中神经病变与基于电诊断研究和超声的诊断不一致

Diagnosis of Mild-to-moderate Idiopathic Median Neuropathy at the Carpal Tunnel Based on Signs and Symptoms is Discordant From Diagnosis Based on Electrodiagnostic Studies and Ultrasound.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2023-07-04

本研究利用横断面数据注册库,对110例符合条件的患者通过潜在类别分析估计轻中度腕管特发性正中神经病变的患病率。基于症状和体征估计的患病率为73%(95%CI 62%至81%),而基于电诊断研究和超声测量的估计患病率为51%(95%CI 37%至65%),两者相差22%且置信区间重叠,提示存在相当的不确定性和过度诊断或诊断不足的潜在可能。

要点

  • 基于症状和体征估计的轻中度腕管特发性正中神经病变患病率为73%(95%CI 62%至81%)。
  • 基于电诊断研究和超声测量估计的患病率为51%(95%CI 37%至65%)。
  • 两种方法估计的患病率相差22%,且置信区间重叠,提示诊断存在相当的不确定性。

核心结论

  • 基于症状和体征与基于电诊断研究和超声标准估计的轻中度腕管特发性正中神经病变患病率存在22%的显著不一致,且概率估计的置信区间重叠,提示存在相当的不确定性和相应的过度诊断或诊断不足的显著潜在可能。
  • 当症状和体征提示轻中度正中神经病变且考虑手术时,患者和临床医生可考虑额外检查如电诊断研究或超声,以提高实际可从手术获益的正中神经病变的概率。
  • 作者认为,更准确可靠的轻中度腕管特发性正中神经病变诊断策略或工具可能有益,这可能是未来研究的重点。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究使用现有横断面数据注册库的数据,注册库纳入2014年1月至2019年1月期间所有接受包含正中神经的电诊断研究的新成人英语使用者,或尚未手术的腕管综合征诊断患者。
  • 最终注册库包含185名参与者,排除75例明显重度腕管特发性正中神经病变者(定义为神经传导速度不可记录、大鱼际萎缩或两点辨别觉大于5毫米),110例符合条件患者中3例种族或民族信息缺失但在最终分析中予以考虑。
  • 研究采用潜在类别分析,使用轻中度腕管特发性正中神经病变的四个特征性体征和症状以及电诊断研究和超声测量,在两个潜在类别分析中估计轻中度腕管特发性正中神经病变的患病率。
  • 证据等级为III级,诊断性研究。

主要发现

  • 基于症状和体征估计的轻中度腕管特发性正中神经病变患病率为73%(95%CI 62%至81%)。
  • 基于电诊断研究和超声测量估计的轻中度腕管特发性正中神经病变患病率为51%(95%CI 37%至65%)。
  • 两种方法估计的患病率相差22%,且概率估计的置信区间重叠。

关键数值与推荐

  • 轻中度腕管特发性正中神经病变基于症状和体征的估计患病率为73%(95%CI 62%至81%)。
  • 轻中度腕管特发性正中神经病变基于电诊断研究和超声测量的估计患病率为51%(95%CI 37%至65%)。
  • 排除明显重度腕管特发性正中神经病变的标准为神经传导速度不可记录、大鱼际萎缩或两点辨别觉大于5毫米。

临床怎么用

  • 当症状和体征提示轻中度正中神经病变且考虑手术时,患者和临床医生可考虑额外检查如电诊断研究或超声,以提高实际可从手术获益的正中神经病变的概率。

局限性

  • 原文报告有少量未记录数量的人拒绝参与。
  • 110例符合条件患者中3例种族或民族信息缺失。
  • 基于症状和体征与基于电诊断研究和超声标准的患病率估计相差22%且置信区间重叠,提示存在相当的不确定性和相应的过度诊断或诊断不足的显著潜在可能。
  • 作者认为更准确可靠的轻中度腕管特发性正中神经病变诊断策略或工具可能有益,这可能是未来研究的重点。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Although idiopathic median neuropathy at the carpal tunnel (IMNCT) is objective and verifiable, distinction of normal and abnormal nerves is imprecise and probabilistic. The associated symptoms and signs (carpal tunnel syndrome [CTS]) vary, particularly for nonsevere (mild and moderate) median neuropathy. Discordance between diagnosis of mild or moderate median neuropathy at the carpal tunnel using symptoms and signs and diagnosis based on objective tests is a measure of the potential for overdiagnosis and overtreatment. QUESTION/PURPOSE: What is the difference in the estimated prevalence of mild-to-moderate IMNCT using nonsevere signs and symptoms compared with the estimated prevalence using electrodiagnostic studies (EDS) and ultrasound (US)? METHODS: We used data from an existing cross-sectional data registry. To create this registry, between January 2014 and January 2019, we considered all new adult English-speaking people who had an EDS that included the median nerve or people with a diagnosis of CTS who did not have surgery yet. A small and unrecorded number of people declined participation. The cross-sectional area of the median nerve at the distal wrist crease using US in people who already had EDS was measured. People with a diagnosis of CTS underwent both EDS and US. The six signs and symptoms of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome 6 (CTS-6, a validated tool to estimate the probability of IMNCT using ratings of symptoms and signs of CTS) were recorded. This resulted in a registry of 185 participants; we excluded 75 people for obvious, severe IMNCT (defined as nonrecordable nerve conduction velocity, thenar atrophy, or greater than 5 mm 2-point discrimination). Three of the 110 qualifying patients had missing information on ethnicity or race, but we accounted for this in our final analysis. Without a reference standard, as is the case with IMNCT, latent class analysis (LCA) can be used to establish the probability that an individual has specific pathophysiologic findings. LCA is a statistical method that identifies sets of characteristics that tend to group together. This technique has been used, for example, in diagnosing true scaphoid fractures among suspected fractures based on a combination of demographic, injury, examination, and radiologic variables. The prevalence of mild-to-moderate IMNCT was estimated in two LCAs using four signs and symptoms characteristic of mild-to-moderate IMNCT, as well as EDS and US measures of median neuropathy. RESULTS: The estimated prevalence of mild-to-moderate IMNCT based on signs and symptoms was 73% (95% CI 62% to 81%), while the estimated prevalence using EDS and US measurements was 51% (95% CI 37% to 65%). CONCLUSION: The notable discordance of 22% between the estimated prevalence of mild-to-moderate IMNCT using signs and symptoms and prevalence based on EDS and US criteria, and the overlapping CIs of the probability estimations, indicate considerable uncertainty and a corresponding notable potential for underdiagnosis or overdiagnosis. When signs and symptoms suggest mild-to-moderate median neuropathy and surgery is being considered, patients and clinicians might consider additional testing, such as EDS or US, to increase the probability of actual median neuropathy that can benefit from surgery. We might benefit from a more accurate and reliable diagnostic strategy or tool for mild-to-moderate IMNCT; this might be the focus of a future study. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, diagnostic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Teunis T, Domico A, Ring D, et al. Diagnosis of Mild-to-moderate Idiopathic Median Neuropathy at the Carpal Tunnel Based on Signs and Symptoms is Discordant From Diagnosis Based on Electrodiagnostic Studies and Ultrasound. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2023. PMID: 37404022. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002751

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。