负重稳定型Weber B踝骨折非手术治疗中合并不稳定与稳定重力应力试验:2年结局研究
该前瞻性非劣效性研究纳入149例负重X线稳定的Weber B踝骨折患者,重力应力X线分为稳定SER2组(n=88)与部分不稳定SER4a组(n=61),均采用功能性支具并允许负重,随访2年。主要结局MOXFQ组间差异为1.0分(95%CI -1.4至3.4,p=0.397),支持非劣效性,其他结局无组间差异。
要点
- 负重稳定型Weber B骨折中,重力应力不稳定(SER4a)与稳定(SER2)者2年患者报告结局非劣效。
- 两组MOXFQ评分差异1.0分(95%CI -1.4至3.4,p=0.397),未超非劣效界值7.5分。
- 作者认为应力不稳定的识别似乎冗余,对手术决策的适用性存疑。
核心结论
- 在负重X线稳定、采用可拆卸支具并允许负重的Weber B/SER踝骨折中,合并不稳定重力应力试验(SER4a)与稳定重力应力试验(SER2)相比,2年随访时患者报告结局与影像学结局均未更差。
- 作者认为应力不稳定的识别似乎冗余,这对将应力不稳定用于手术决策的适用性提出疑问。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性非劣效性研究,纳入149例Weber B踝骨折且负重X线稳定的患者。
- 重力应力X线分为稳定SER2组(n=88)与部分不稳定SER4a组(n=61),均采用功能性支具并允许负重,随访2年。
- 主要结局为MOXFQ(0-100分,分数越低症状越少),非劣效界值预先设定为7.5分。
主要发现
- 2年时149例中144例(96.6%)有主要结局数据。
- MOXFQ评分组间差异为1.0分(95%CI -1.4至3.4,p=0.397),方向有利于SER2组,符合非劣效性。
- 其他任何结局均未发现明显的组间差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 非劣效界值预先设定为7.5分(MOXFQ评分)。
- MOXFQ评分组间差异1.0分(95%CI -1.4至3.4,p=0.397),有利于SER2组。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Replacing gravity stress tests with weight-bearing radiographs to evaluate the stability of Weber B (also called Lauge-Hansen supination-external rotation [SER]) ankle fractures results in a lower surgery rate, thus avoiding associated risks and complications. Still, nonoperative treatment of weight-bearing stable fractures is controversial because of the scarcity of strong evidence. We investigated the influence of a concomitant unstable gravity stress test compared with a stable gravity stress test on outcomes after nonoperative treatment of weight-bearing stable fractures. METHODS: We performed a prospective, noninferiority study on 149 patients with Weber B ankle fractures and stable weight-bearing radiographs. Gravity stress radiographs classified fractures as stable (SER2 [n = 88]) or partially unstable (SER4a [n = 61]). All were treated with a functional orthosis and weight-bearing was allowed; patients were followed for 2 years. The primary outcome was the Manchester-Oxford Foot and Ankle Questionnaire (MOXFQ), with a range from 0 to 100, in which lower scores indicate fewer symptoms. A noninferiority margin was prospectively defined as 7.5 points. The secondary outcomes included the Olerud-Molander Ankle Score, assessment of ankle congruence, and treatment-related adverse events. RESULTS: The primary outcome data were available for 144 (96.6%) of 149 participants at 2 years. The between-group difference in the MOXFQ score was 1.0 point (95% confidence interval, -1.4 to 3.4 points; p = 0.397) in favor of the SER2 group, consistent with noninferiority. We found no appreciable between-group differences for any other outcome. CONCLUSIONS: In Weber B/SER ankle fractures that are stable on weight-bearing radiographs, are treated with removable orthoses, and are allowed to bear weight, a concomitant unstable gravity stress test (SER4a) was not associated with worse patient-reported or radiographic outcomes compared with a stable gravity stress test (SER2) at the 2-year follow-up. Thus, the identification of stress instability seems redundant, which questions the applicability of stress instability for surgical decision-making. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Diagnostic Level II . See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
引用
- Gregersen MG, Robinson HS, Molund M, et al. Concomitant Unstable and Stable Gravity Stress Tests on Weight-Bearing Stable Weber B Ankle Fractures Treated Nonoperatively: A 2-Year Outcome Study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2023. PMID: 37498982. doi:10.2106/JBJS.23.00195
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。