美国足踝骨科协会年会全现场参会模式产生巨大碳排放
该研究量化了2019年美国足踝骨科协会(AOFAS)芝加哥年会全现场参会的温室气体排放,并比较2020年全虚拟年会及四枢纽、七枢纽现场替代模式的碳排放。结果显示全现场年会排放约1565吨二氧化碳当量,全虚拟年会约34吨,较现场下降97.8%;四枢纽和七枢纽模式分别预测减少往返航空旅行排放54%和71%。
要点
- 2019年AOFAS全现场年会总排放约1565吨CO2e,人均中位数0.61吨。
- 2020年全虚拟年会总排放约34吨CO2e,较现场年会下降97.8%。
- 四枢纽和七枢纽现场模式预测减少往返航空排放54%和71%。
核心结论
- 2019年AOFAS年会碳足迹巨大,许多参会者超过《巴黎协定》人均年碳预算2.5吨。
- 虚拟举办大幅降低年会碳足迹,枢纽式现场会议模型识别了可减少会议参会碳足迹的潜在现场替代方案。
研究设计与样本
- 基于2019年AOFAS年会1271名注册参会者的邮编和国家信息,使用Myclimate计算器估算往返航空旅行CO2e,并用美国环保署排放因子估算会场、汽车旅行和酒店住宿排放。
- 按Faber框架估算2020年全虚拟年会(假设参会人数与2019年相同)的网络数据传输、个人电脑和显示器及服务器相关排放。
- 利用2019年注册名单建模四枢纽和七枢纽现场会议替代方案,枢纽地点依据注册者地理分布选择并将注册者分配至最近枢纽,再用Myclimate估算往返航空旅行CO2e。
主要发现
- 2019年全现场年会总估算排放为1565吨CO2e(人均中位数0.61吨,范围0.02至7.7吨)。
- 2020年全虚拟年会总估算排放为34吨CO2e(人均中位数0.03吨),较现场年会下降97.8%。
- 四枢纽(芝加哥、圣地亚哥、伦敦、东京)现场会议模型预测往返航空旅行CO2e减少54%。
- 七枢纽(芝加哥、华盛顿特区、达拉斯、洛杉矶、圣地亚哥、伦敦、东京)会议模型预测往返航空旅行CO2e减少71%。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,专业学会必须考虑通过创新方法(或许如作者的多枢纽方案)来脱碳医疗 sector,在不阻碍学术进步的情况下减少碳密集型年会的碳排放。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Professional society conferences are integral to the medical profession. However, airline travel is a major contributor to greenhouse gas production, and the environmental impact of in-person attendance at an orthopaedic conference has yet to be described. With growing concern about the climate crisis, we sought to quantify the carbon footprint of in-person attendance to help potential attendees more consciously consider in-person attendance, inform strategies to minimize greenhouse gas emissions during travel to annual meetings, and increase awareness about and momentum for efforts in orthopaedic surgery to reduce the carbon footprint of society conferences. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) What was the magnitude of greenhouse gas production resulting from all-in-person 2019 American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) annual meeting attendance in Chicago, IL, USA? (2) What was the magnitude of greenhouse gas production resulting from the all-virtual 2020 AOFAS annual meeting, and how does it compare with the 2019 AOFAS annual meeting carbon footprint? (3) To what extent could an alternative in-person meeting model with four or seven hubs decrease greenhouse gas production resulting from round-trip air travel compared with the 2019 AOFAS annual meeting? METHODS: A list of the postal codes and countries of all 1271 registered participants attending the four-day 2019 AOFAS annual meeting in Chicago, IL, USA, was obtained from AOFAS headquarters. The 2019 conference was chosen because it was the last pre-COVID meeting and thus attendance was more likely to resemble that at prepandemic in-person conferences than more recent meetings because of pandemic travel restrictions. We estimated carbon dioxide-equivalent (CO 2 e) production from round-trip air travel using a publicly available internet-based calculator (Myclimate: https://co2.myclimate.org/en/flight_calculators/new ). Emissions produced by the conference venue, car travel, and hotel stays were estimated using published Environmental Protection Agency emission factors. To estimate emissions produced by the all-virtual 2020 AOFAS annual meeting (assuming an equal number of attendees as in 2019), we used the framework published by Faber and summed estimated network data transfer emissions, personal computer and monitor emissions, and server-related emissions. Using the 2019 registrant list, we modeled four-hub and seven-hub in-person meeting alternatives to determine potential decreased round-trip air travel greenhouse gas production. Meeting hub locations were selected by visualizing the geographic distribution of the 2019 registrants and selecting reasonable meeting locations that would minimize air travel for the greatest number of attendees. Registrants were assigned to the nearest hub location. Myclimate was again used to estimate CO 2 e production for round-trip air travel for the hub meeting models. RESULTS: The total estimated emissions of the all-in-person 2019 AOFAS annual meeting (when accounting for travel, conference space, and hotel stays) was 1565 tons CO 2 e (median 0.61 tons per attendee, range 0.02 to 7.7 tons). The total estimated emissions of the all-virtual 2020 meeting (when accounting for network data transfer emissions, personal computer and monitor emissions, and server-related emissions) was 34 tons CO 2 e (median 0.03 tons per attendee). This corresponds to a 97.8% decrease in CO 2 e emissions compared with the in-person conference. The model of a four-hub in-person meeting alternative with meetings in Chicago, Santiago, London, and Tokyo predicted an estimated 54% decrease in CO 2 e emissions from round-trip air travel. The seven-hub meeting model with meetings in Chicago; Washington, DC; Dallas; Los Angeles; Santiago; London; and Tokyo was predicted to diminish the CO 2 e emissions of round-trip air travel by an estimated 71%. CONCLUSION: The 2019 AOFAS annual meeting had an enormous carbon footprint and resulted in many individuals exceeding their annual allotted carbon budget (2.5 tons) according to the Paris Agreement. Hosting the meeting virtually greatly reduced the annual meeting carbon footprint, and our hub-based meeting models identified potential in-person alternatives for reducing the carbon footprint of conference attendance. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Professional societies must consider our responsibility to decarbonizing the healthcare sector by considering innovative approaches-perhaps such as our multihub proposals-to decarbonize carbon-intensive annual meetings without stalling academic progress.
引用
- Parker EB, Bluman A, Pruneski J, et al. American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society Annual Meeting All-in-person Attendance Results in Immense Carbon Expenditure. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2023. PMID: 37493467. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002764
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。