北爱尔兰等待髋膝关节置换术患者的痛苦真相
该队列研究纳入北爱尔兰单一NHS信托基金991例等待全髋或全膝关节置换术患者,比较等待≤3个月(497例)与≥3年(494例)者的健康相关生活质量和关节特异性功能,并与匹配正常人群比较。等待者EQ-5D-5L评分显著低于匹配对照(p<0.001),40%等待≤3个月和38%等待≥3年者出现「比死亡更差」的负分。等待≥3年者强阿片类药物和抗抑郁药处方及非计划就诊显著更多。
要点
- 等待关节置换患者EQ-5D-5L评分显著低于匹配正常人群(p<0.001),所有维度均有显著差异。
- 40%等待≤3个月和38%等待≥3年者EQ-5D-5L出现负分,提示状态「比死亡更差」。
- 等待≥3年者强阿片类药物处方28.4% vs 15.2%(p<0.001),抗抑郁药处方15.2% vs 9.9%(p=0.034)。
核心结论
- 北爱尔兰等待关节置换患者严重残疾,健康相关生活质量和功能评分是研究中最低的。
- 等待≤3个月与≥3年者之间EQ-5D-5L和关节特异性评分无恶化,可能反映这些评分的下限效应。
- 长时间等待与强阿片类药物依赖增加、抑郁和非计划就诊增加相关。
研究设计与样本
- 队列研究,纳入北爱尔兰单一NHS信托基金等待关节置换术的991例患者,其中497例等待≤3个月,494例等待≥3年。
- 采用邮寄问卷调查EQ-5D-5L、EQ-VAS和牛津髋/膝关节评分评估健康相关生活质量和关节特异性功能。
- 通过电子记录确定加入等待名单后的处方以及非工作时间全科医生/急诊就诊情况。
- 总体712/991(71.8%)应答:等待≤3个月组全髋置换164例、全膝置换199例;等待≥3年组全髋置换88例、全膝置换261例。
主要发现
- 等待≤3个月组EQ-5D-5L中位评分0.155(IQR -0.118至0.375),等待≥3年组0.189(IQR -0.130至0.377),匹配对照中位评分0.837(IQR 0.728至1.000)。
- 与匹配对照相比,两个等待队列EQ-5D-5L评分均显著更低(p<0.001),且每个维度均有显著差异。
- EQ-5D-5L负分(提示状态「比死亡更差」)在等待≤3个月组占40%,等待≥3年组占38%。
- 等待≥3年组相比等待≤3个月组:强阿片类药物处方28.4% vs 15.2%(p<0.001),抗抑郁药处方15.2% vs 9.9%(p=0.034)。
- 等待≥3年组相比等待≤3个月组:至少一次急诊就诊11.7% vs 0%(p<0.001),至少一次非工作时间全科医生就诊25.5% vs 2.5%(p<0.001)。
局限性
- 等待≤3个月与≥3年者之间EQ-5D-5L和关节特异性评分无恶化,原文认为可能反映这些评分的下限效应。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: The aim of this study was to report health-related quality of life (HRQoL) and joint-specific function in patients waiting for total hip or knee arthroplasty surgery (THA or TKA) in Northern Ireland, compared to published literature and a matched normal population. Secondary aims were to report emergency department (ED) and out-of-hours general practitioner (OOH GP) visits, new prescriptions of strong opioids, and new prescriptions of antidepressants while waiting. METHODS: This was a cohort study of 991 patients on the waiting list for arthroplasty in a single Northern Ireland NHS trust: 497 on the waiting list for ≤ three months; and 494 waiting ≥ three years. Postal surveys included the EuroQol five-dimension five-level questionnaire (EQ-5D-5L), visual analogue scores (EQ-VAS), and Oxford Hip and Knee scores to assess HRQoL and joint-specific function. Electronic records determined prescriptions since addition to the waiting list and patient attendances at OOH GP/EDs. RESULTS: Overall, 712/991 (71.8%) responded at ≤ three months for THA (n = 164) and TKA (n = 199), and ≥ three years for THA (n = 88) and TKA (n = 261). The median EQ-5D-5L score in those waiting ≤ three months was 0.155 (interquartile range (IQR) -0.118 to 0.375) and 0.189 (IQR -0.130 to 0.377) for ≥ three years. Matched controls had a median EQ-5D-5L 0.837 (IQR 0.728 to 1.000). Compared to matched controls, EQ-5D-5L scores were significantly lower in both waiting cohorts (p < 0.001) with significant differences found in every domain. Negative scores, indicating a state "worse than death", were present in 40% at ≤ three months and 38% at ≥ three years. Patients waiting ≥ three years had significantly more opioid (28.4% vs 15.2%; p < 0.001) and antidepressant prescriptions (15.2% vs 9.9%; p = 0.034) and significantly more joint-related attendances at unscheduled care (11.7% vs 0% with ≥ one ED attendance (p < 0.001) and (25.5% vs 2.5% ≥ one OOH GP attendance (p < 0.001)). CONCLUSION: Patients on waiting lists in Northern Ireland are severely disabled with the worst HRQoL and functional scores studied. The lack of deterioration in EQ-5D-5L and joint-specific scores between patients waiting ≤ three months and ≥ three years likely reflects floor effects of these scores. Prolonged waits were associated with increased dependence on strong opiates, depression, and attendances at unscheduled care.
引用
- Karayiannis PN, Warnock M, Cassidy R, et al. The painful truth of waiting for hip and knee arthroplasty in Northern Ireland. Bone Joint J. 2023. PMID: 37399093. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.105B7.BJJ-2023-0078.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。