挪威与丹麦膝关节韧带登记联合的天花板效应限制前交叉韧带重建结局预测
基于挪威与丹麦膝关节韧带登记(NKLR与DKRR)联合数据对62,955例患者进行机器学习分析,预测前交叉韧带重建翻修手术概率。三种非参数模型区分度中等(一致性0.67),与仅用NKLR的既往模型相似,未显示更优准确性。
要点
- 联合NKLR与DKRR共62,955例患者,5%接受翻修手术,平均随访7.6±4.5年。
- 随机生存森林、梯度提升和超级学习器表现最佳,一致性0.67(95%CI 0.64-0.70)。
- 尽管分析近63,000例患者,联合模型未优于仅用NKLR的既往模型,提示天花板效应。
核心结论
- 基于NKLR与DKRR联合数据的机器学习分析可中等准确度预测翻修前交叉韧带重建风险,但所得算法较不友好且与仅基于NKLR的既往模型相比未显示更优准确性。
- 这种天花板效应提示简单向现有国家膝关节韧带登记添加更多患者不太可能改善预测能力,并可能促使未来改变以增加变量纳入。
研究设计与样本
- 队列研究,证据等级3。
- 对NKLR与DKRR联合数据进行机器学习分析,主要结局为1年、2年和5年内翻修前交叉韧带重建的概率。
- 数据随机分为训练集(75%)和测试集(25%),检验4种机器学习模型:Cox lasso、随机生存森林、梯度提升和超级学习器。
- 数据集包含62,955例患者,其中5%接受了翻修手术,平均随访7.6±4.5年。
主要发现
- 3种非参数模型(随机生存森林、梯度提升和超级学习器)表现最佳,显示中等一致性(0.67,95%CI 0.64-0.70),并在1年和2年时校准良好。
- 模型表现与既往发表的模型相似(仅NKLR模型:一致性0.67-0.69;校准良好)。
局限性
- 所得算法较不友好。
- 与既往基于仅NKLR患者的模型相比未显示更优准确性,尽管分析了近63,000例患者。
- 天花板效应提示简单向现有国家膝关节韧带登记添加更多患者不太可能改善预测能力。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Clinical tools based on machine learning analysis now exist for outcome prediction after primary anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR). Relying partly on data volume, the general principle is that more data may lead to improved model accuracy. PURPOSE/HYPOTHESIS: The purpose was to apply machine learning to a combined data set from the Norwegian and Danish knee ligament registers (NKLR and DKRR, respectively), with the aim of producing an algorithm that can predict revision surgery with improved accuracy relative to a previously published model developed using only the NKLR. The hypothesis was that the additional patient data would result in an algorithm that is more accurate. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: Machine learning analysis was performed on combined data from the NKLR and DKRR. The primary outcome was the probability of revision ACLR within 1, 2, and 5 years. Data were split randomly into training sets (75%) and test sets (25%). There were 4 machine learning models examined: Cox lasso, random survival forest, gradient boosting, and super learner. Concordance and calibration were calculated for all 4 models. RESULTS: The data set included 62,955 patients in which 5% underwent a revision surgical procedure with a mean follow-up of 7.6 ± 4.5 years. The 3 nonparametric models (random survival forest, gradient boosting, and super learner) performed best, demonstrating moderate concordance (0.67 [95% CI, 0.64-0.70]), and were well calibrated at 1 and 2 years. Model performance was similar to that of the previously published model (NKLR-only model: concordance, 0.67-0.69; well calibrated). CONCLUSION: Machine learning analysis of the combined NKLR and DKRR enabled prediction of the revision ACLR risk with moderate accuracy. However, the resulting algorithms were less user-friendly and did not demonstrate superior accuracy in comparison with the previously developed model based on patients from the NKLR alone, despite the analysis of nearly 63,000 patients. This ceiling effect suggests that simply adding more patients to current national knee ligament registers is unlikely to improve predictive capability and may prompt future changes to increase variable inclusion.
引用
- Martin RK, Wastvedt S, Pareek A, et al. Ceiling Effect of the Combined Norwegian and Danish Knee Ligament Registers Limits Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Outcome Prediction. Am J Sports Med. 2023. PMID: 37289071. doi:10.1177/03635465231177905
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。