前交叉韧带损伤与完整膝关节在传统侧位X线片上的胫骨后倾角:均值与离群值
这项横断面研究(证据等级3)在1000例前交叉韧带损伤膝(A组)和1000例前交叉韧带完整膝(B组)的传统侧位X线片上测量胫骨后倾角,发现A组均值10.04°±3°显著高于B组9.02°±2.9°(P<.001),且A组胫骨后倾角≥12°的离群值比例显著更高,传统侧位X线片测量可重复性好。
要点
- 前交叉韧带损伤膝胫骨后倾角均值10.04°±3°,完整膝9.02°±2.9°,组间差异显著(P<.001)。
- 前交叉韧带损伤膝胫骨后倾角≥12°者占32.2%,完整膝占19.8%(P<.001),且随阈值升高比例递增。
- 传统侧位X线片测量胫骨后倾角的组内与组间信度良好至优秀。
核心结论
- 传统侧位X线片上胫骨后倾角中位数在完整膝为9°、在前交叉韧带损伤膝为10°。
- 该均值差异虽有统计学意义,但在临床实践中可能可忽略。
- 前交叉韧带损伤组中超过12°的离群值显著更多,且随胫骨后倾角增大比例递增,可作为截骨矫正的潜在阈值。
- 传统侧位X线片在迄今最大队列中显示出高可重复性,证明其作为胫骨后倾角常规测量的可行性。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,证据等级3。
- 前交叉韧带损伤膝1000例(A组)与前交叉韧带完整膝1000例(B组),由3名经验丰富的检查者采用Dejour和Bonnin技术在传统侧位X线片上测量内侧胫骨后倾角。
- 排除图像质量差、骨关节炎、既往截骨术或非数字X线片的患者。
- 采用组内相关系数计算组内与组间信度。
主要发现
- A组胫骨后倾角均值10.04°±3°(范围2°-22°)vs B组9.02°±2.9°(范围1°-18°),A组较高(P<.001)。
- A组胫骨后倾角≥12°者32.2% vs B组19.8%(P<.001);≥13°者20.9% vs 11.1%(P<.001);≥14°者13.5% vs 5.7%(P<.001);≥15°者8% vs 2.7%(P<.001);≥16°者3.7% vs 1.4%(P=.0005)。
- B组胫骨后倾角≤8°者42.7% vs A组32.1%(P<.001);≤7°者30.9% vs 20%(P<.001);≤6°者19.8% vs 12.4%(P<.001);≤5°者12% vs 6.6%(P=.0003);≤4°者5.3% vs 2.8%(P=.0045)。
- 组内相关系数显示整个测量过程信度良好至优秀。
关键数值与推荐
- 传统侧位X线片测量胫骨后倾角的中位数:完整膝9°,前交叉韧带损伤膝10°。
- 前交叉韧带损伤膝胫骨后倾角≥12°的比例为32.2%,完整膝为19.8%(P<.001)。
- 胫骨后倾角超过12°可作为截骨矫正的潜在阈值。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: An increased tibial slope (TS) has been identified as a risk factor for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury and graft failure after ACL reconstruction. However, different imaging modalities are used to determine the TS, resulting in divergent values. Consequently, no reference values and no consensus on thresholds can be reached, which in turn is mandatory for indicating correction osteotomies when facing outlier TS. PURPOSE: To determine the mean values of the TS and the incidence of their outliers in large cohorts of patients with ACL-injured and noninjured knees and to determine the feasibility of measuring TS on conventional lateral radiographs (CLRs). STUDY DESIGN: Cross-sectional study; Level of evidence 3. METHODS: TS of ACL-injured knees (n = 1000, group A) and ACL-intact knees (n = 1000, group B) was measured by 3 experienced examiners. Medial TS was measured on CLRs using the technique of Dejour and Bonnin. Patients with radiographs with poor image quality, osteoarthritis, previous osteotomies, or nondigital radiographs were excluded. The intra- and interrater reliability was calculated using the intraclass correlation coefficient. RESULTS: The mean TS was significantly higher in group A than in group B (10.04°± 3° [range, 2°-22°] vs 9.02°± 2.9° [range, 1°-18°], respectively; P < .001). Significantly more participants in group A had TS larger than 12° (≥12°, 32.2% vs 19.8%, P < .001; ≥13°, 20.9% vs 11.1%, P < .001; ≥14°, 13.5% vs 5.7%, P < .001; ≥15°, 8% vs 2.7%, P < .001; ≥16°, 3.7% vs 1.4%, P = .0005), respectively. In contrast, significantly more participatns in group B had TS 8° or less (≤8°, 32.1% vs 42.7%, P < .001; ≤7°, 20% vs 30.9%, P < .001; ≤6°, 12.4% vs 19.8%, P < .001; ≤5°, 6.6% vs 12%, P = .0003; ≤4°, 2.8% vs 5.3%, P = .0045). The intraclass correlation coefficient revealed a good to excellent reliability throughout measurements. CONCLUSION: Median values for the TS were 9° for uninjured and 10° for ACL-injured knees on CLRs. Notwithstanding its statistical significance, this finding might be negligible in clinical practice. However, a significantly larger number of outliers were found in the ACL-injured group exceeding a TS of 12° and demonstrating an incremental proportion with increasing TS, serving as a potential threshold for correction osteotomy. Furthermore, CLRs in the largest cohort to date exhibited high reproducibility, proving the feasibility of CLRs as a routine measurement for TS.
引用
- Weiler A, Berndt R, Wagner M, et al. Tibial Slope on Conventional Lateral Radiographs in Anterior Cruciate Ligament-Injured and Intact Knees: Mean Value and Outliers. Am J Sports Med. 2023. PMID: 37306059. doi:10.1177/03635465231178292
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。