文献速递关节外科

关节置换外科医生的翻修率与术后患者报告结局评分相关吗?来自澳大利亚骨科协会国家关节置换登记中心的研究

Do the Revision Rates of Arthroplasty Surgeons Correlate With Postoperative Patient-reported Outcome Measure Scores? A Study From the Australian Orthopaedic Association National Joint Replacement Registry.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2023-06-20

研究利用澳大利亚骨科协会国家关节置换登记中心2018年8月至2020年12月的数据,分析235名全髋关节置换术(THA)医生和276名全膝关节置换术(TKA)医生的2年累积翻修率与术后6个月牛津髋/膝关节评分及EQ-VAS评分的相关性。结果显示,医生2年累积翻修率与术后PROMs仅呈极弱相关,无临床相关性。结论认为PROMs和翻修率可能分别反映关节置换术后功能的不同方面。

要点

  • THA医生2年累积翻修率与术后牛津髋关节评分呈极弱相关(ρ=-0.09;p<0.001),与EQ-VAS接近零相关(ρ=-0.02;p=0.25)。
  • TKA医生2年累积翻修率与术后牛津膝关节评分(ρ=-0.04;p=0.004)和EQ-VAS(ρ=0.03;p=0.006)均呈极弱相关。
  • 所有医生术后牛津评分相似,翻修率与PROMs无临床相关,PROMs和翻修率可能分析的是功能的不同方面。

核心结论

  • 医生2年累积翻修率与THA或TKA术后PROMs无临床相关,所有医生术后牛津评分相似。
  • PROMs、翻修率或两者可能是不准确或不完善的关节置换成功指标。

研究设计与样本

  • 利用澳大利亚骨科协会国家关节置换登记中心PROMs项目的数据,纳入2018年8月至2020年12月期间因骨关节炎行择期初次THA和TKA、有术后6个月PROMs、手术医生明确且医生至少完成50例初次THA或TKA的病例。
  • 最终分析纳入235名合格医生完成的8000例THA(其中4256例有术后牛津髋关节评分,4242例有术后EQ-VAS评分)和276名合格医生完成的13019例TKA(其中6730例有术后牛津膝关节评分,6728例有术后EQ-VAS评分)。
  • 采用Spearman相关分析医生2年累积翻修率与术后6个月EQ-VAS及牛津髋/膝关节评分的相关性,并使用多变量Tobit回归和累积链接模型(probit链接)调整年龄、性别、ASA评分、BMI分类、术前PROMs及THA手术入路,缺失数据采用多重插补。

主要发现

  • THA中,术后牛津髋关节评分与医生2年累积翻修率呈极弱相关(Spearman ρ=-0.09;p<0.001),与术后EQ-VAS接近零相关(ρ=-0.02;p=0.25)。
  • TKA中,术后牛津膝关节评分与医生2年累积翻修率呈极弱相关(ρ=-0.04;p=0.004),术后EQ-VAS与医生2年累积翻修率呈极弱相关(ρ=0.03;p=0.006)。
  • 所有处理缺失数据的模型均得到相同结果。

关键数值与推荐

  • THA医生2年累积翻修率与术后牛津髋关节评分:Spearman ρ=-0.09(p<0.001)。
  • THA医生2年累积翻修率与术后EQ-VAS:Spearman ρ=-0.02(p=0.25)。
  • TKA医生2年累积翻修率与术后牛津膝关节评分:Spearman ρ=-0.04(p=0.004)。
  • TKA医生2年累积翻修率与术后EQ-VAS:Spearman ρ=0.03(p=0.006)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 缺失数据可能限制本研究发现,尽管在不同缺失数据情景下结果一致。
  • 未来研究应识别与功能结局相关的变量。
  • 鉴于牛津评分记录的功能水平较粗略,需要能够识别临床有意义功能差异的结局指标。
  • 在国家关节置换登记中使用牛津评分可能受到合理质疑。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) are a pragmatic and efficient means to evaluate the functional quality of arthroplasty beyond revision rates, which are used by most joint replacement registries to judge success. The relationship between these two measures of quality-revision rates and PROMs-is unknown, and not every procedure with a poor functional result is revised. It is logical-although still untested-that higher cumulative revision rates correlate inversely with PROMs for individual surgeons; more revisions are associated with lower PROM scores. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: We used data from a large national joint replacement registry to ask: (1) Does a surgeon's early THA cumulative percent revision (CPR) rate and (2) early TKA CPR rate correlate with the postoperative PROMs of patients undergoing primary THA and TKA, respectively, who have not undergone revision? METHODS: Elective primary THA and TKA procedures in patients with a primary diagnosis of osteoarthritis that were performed between August 2018 and December 2020 and registered in the Australian Orthopaedic Association National Joint Replacement Registry PROMs program were eligible. THAs and TKAs were eligible for inclusion in the primary analysis if 6-month postoperative PROMs were available, the operating surgeon was clearly identified, and the surgeon had performed at least 50 primary THAs or TKAs. Based on the inclusion criteria, 17,668 THAs were performed at eligible sites. We excluded 8878 procedures that were not matched to the PROMs program, leaving 8790 procedures. A further 790 were excluded because they were performed by unknown or ineligible surgeons or were revised, leaving 8000 procedures performed by 235 eligible surgeons, including 4256 (53%; 3744 cases of missing data) patients who had postoperative Oxford Hip Scores and 4242 (53%; 3758 cases of missing data) patients who had a postoperative EQ-VAS score recorded. Complete covariate data were available for 3939 procedures for the Oxford Hip Score and for 3941 procedures for the EQ-VAS. A total of 26,624 TKAs were performed at eligible sites. We excluded 12,685 procedures that were not matched to the PROMs program, leaving 13,939 procedures. A further 920 were excluded because they were performed by unknown or ineligible surgeons, or because they were revisions, leaving 13,019 procedures performed by 276 eligible surgeons, including 6730 (52%; 6289 cases of missing data) patients who had had postoperative Oxford Knee Scores and 6728 (52%; 6291 cases of missing data) patients who had a postoperative EQ-VAS score recorded. Complete covariate data were available for 6228 procedures for the Oxford Knee Score and for 6241 procedures for the EQ-VAS. The Spearman correlation between the operating surgeon's 2-year CPR and 6-month postoperative EQ-VAS Health and Oxford Hip or Oxford Knee Score was evaluated for THA and TKA procedures where a revision had not been performed. Associations between postoperative Oxford and EQ-VAS scores and a surgeon's 2-year CPR were estimated based on multivariate Tobit regressions and a cumulative link model with a probit link, adjusting for patient age, gender, ASA score, BMI category, preoperative PROMs, as well as surgical approach for THA. Missing data were accounted for using multiple imputation, with models assuming they were missing at random and a worst-case scenario. RESULTS: Of the eligible THA procedures, postoperative Oxford Hip Score and surgeon 2-year CPR were correlated so weakly as to be clinically irrelevant (Spearman correlation ρ = -0.09; p < 0.001), and the correlation with postoperative EQ-VAS was close to zero (ρ = -0.02; p = 0.25). Of the eligible TKA procedures, postoperative Oxford Knee Score and EQ-VAS and surgeon 2-year CPR were correlated so weakly as to be clinically irrelevant (ρ = -0.04; p = 0.004 and ρ = 0.03; p = 0.006, respectively). All models accounting for missing data found the same result. CONCLUSION: A surgeon's 2-year CPR did not exhibit a clinically relevant correlation with PROMs after THA or TKA, and all surgeons had similar postoperative Oxford scores. PROMs, revision rates, or both may be inaccurate or imperfect indicators of successful arthroplasty. Missing data may limit the findings of this study, although the results were consistent under a variety of different missing data scenarios. Innumerable factors contribute to arthroplasty results, including patient-related variables, differences in implant design, and the technical quality of the procedure. PROMs and revision rates may be analyzing two different facets of function after arthroplasty. Although surgeon variables are associated with revision rates, patient factors may exert a stronger influence on functional outcomes. Future research should identify variables that correlate with functional outcome. Additionally, given the gross level of function that Oxford scores record, outcome measures that can identify clinically meaningful functional differences are required. The use of Oxford scores in national arthroplasty registries may rightfully be questioned. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hoskins W, Bingham R, Corfield S, et al. Do the Revision Rates of Arthroplasty Surgeons Correlate With Postoperative Patient-reported Outcome Measure Scores? A Study From the Australian Orthopaedic Association National Joint Replacement Registry. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2023. PMID: 37339166. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002737

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。