比较颈椎间盘置换与颈椎前路椎间盘切除融合术的试验统计脆弱性:一项Meta分析
该Meta分析纳入25项比较颈椎间盘置换(CDA)与颈椎前路椎间盘切除融合术(ACDF)的随机对照试验,采用脆弱指数评估统计稳健性。二分类结局中位脆弱指数为7,连续结局中位连续脆弱指数为14,结论认为这些试验具有中等程度的统计稳健性,不因统计脆弱性而受损。
要点
- 二分类结局中位脆弱指数为7(IQR 3-10),中位脆弱商为0.043。
- 连续结局中位连续脆弱指数为14(IQR 9-22),中位连续脆弱商为0.145。
- 平均而言,改变100例中4.3例二分类结局或14.5例连续结局即可逆转试验显著性。
核心结论
- 比较ACDF与CDA的随机对照试验具有中等程度的统计稳健性,不因统计脆弱性而受损。
研究设计与样本
- Meta分析,评估比较CDA与ACDF治疗症状性退变性颈椎病变的随机对照试验的稳健性。
- 共纳入25项研究、78个结局事件。
- 连续结局包括颈部功能障碍指数、整体疼痛、颈部疼痛、神经根性臂痛和改良日本骨科协会评分;二分类结局包括任何相邻节段疾病、上位相邻节段疾病和下位相邻节段疾病。
主要发现
- 13个二分类事件的中位脆弱指数为7(IQR 3-10),中位脆弱商为0.043(IQR 0.035-0.066)。
- 65个连续事件的中位连续脆弱指数为14(IQR 9-22),中位连续脆弱商为0.145(IQR 0.074-0.188)。
- 平均而言,二分类结局改变100例患者中4.3例、连续结局改变100例中14.5例即可逆转试验显著性。
- 13个报告失访数据的二分类事件中,8个(61.5%)失访≥7例;65个报告失访数据的连续事件中,22个(33.8%)失访≥14例。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY DESIGN: Meta-analysis. OBJECTIVE: To assess the robustness of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that compared cervical disc arthroplasty (CDA) and anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) for the treatment of symptomatic degenerative cervical pathology by using fragility indices. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: RCTs comparing these surgical approaches have shown that CDA may be equivalent or even superior to ACDF due to better preservation of normal spinal kinematics. MATERIALS AND METHODS: RCTs reporting clinical outcomes after CDA versus ACDF for degenerative cervical disc disease were evaluated. Data for outcome measures were classified as continuous or dichotomous. Continuous outcomes included: Neck Disability Index, overall pain, neck pain, radicular arm pain, and modified Japanese Orthopedic Association scores. Dichotomous outcomes included: any adjacent segment disease (ASD), superior-level ASD, and inferior-level ASD. The fragility index (FI) and continuous FI (CFI) were determined for dichotomous and continuous outcomes, respectively. The corresponding fragility quotient (FQ) and continuous FQ were calculated by dividing FI/CFI by sample size. RESULTS: Twenty-five studies (78 outcome events) were included. Thirteen dichotomous events had a median FI of 7 [interquartile range (IQR): 3-10], and the median FQ was 0.043 (IQR: 0.035-0.066). Sixty-five continuous events had a median CFI of 14 (IQR: 9-22) and a median continuous FQ of 0.145 (IQR: 0.074-0.188). This indicates that, on average, altering the outcome of 4.3 patients out of 100 for the dichotomous outcomes and 14.5 out of 100 for continuous outcomes would reverse trial significance. Of the 13 dichotomous events that included a loss to follow-up data, 8 (61.5%) represented ≥7 patients lost. Of the 65 continuous events reporting the loss to follow-up data, 22 (33.8%) represented ≥14 patients lost. CONCLUSION: RCTs comparing ACDF and CDA have fair to moderate statistical robustness and do not suffer from statistical fragility.
引用
- Ortiz-Babilonia CD, Gupta A, Cartagena-Reyes MA, et al. The Statistical Fragility of Trials Comparing Cervical Disc Arthroplasty and Anterior Cervical Discectomy and Fusion: A Meta Analysis. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2023. PMID: 37368958. doi:10.1097/BRS.0000000000004756
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。