超形合度设计对比后稳定型与后交叉韧带保留型胫骨垫片——证据告诉我们什么?系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析纳入19项研究,比较超形合度(UC)与后交叉韧带保留型(CR)或后稳定型(PS)胫骨垫片的运动学和临床结局。UC与CR在膝关节屈曲度和WOMAC评分上无差异;PS在前後稳定性(P<.001)和股骨后滚(P<.001)上优于UC,但膝关节屈曲度、内外侧稳定性及各项临床评分无差异。作者指出缺乏高质量研究,需要更统一且随访超过5年的长期研究来论证UC使用的增加。
要点
- UC与CR在膝关节屈曲度(n=3,P=.33)和WOMAC评分(n=2,P=.58)上无差异。
- PS较UC有更好的前后稳定性(n=4,P<.001)和更多股骨后滚(n=2,P<.001)。
- PS与UC在膝关节屈曲度、内外侧稳定性及WOMAC、KSS等临床评分上无差异。
核心结论
- 现有数据表明,在约术后2年结束的小样本短期研究中,CR或PS与UC垫片之间无临床差异。
- 更重要的是,缺乏比较所有垫片的高质量研究,需要更统一且随访超过5年的长期研究来论证UC使用的增加。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,检索5个在线数据库2000年1月至2022年7月的文献。
- 共纳入19项研究,其中5项比较UC与CR,14项比较UC与PS。
- 仅1项随机对照试验(RCT)被评为「高质量」。
主要发现
- CR研究汇总分析显示膝关节屈曲度无差异(n=3,P=.33),WOMAC评分无差异(n=2,P=.58)。
- PS研究Meta分析显示PS的前后稳定性更优(n=4,P<.001),股骨后滚更多(n=2,P<.001)。
- PS与UC在膝关节屈曲度(n=9,P=.55)和内外侧稳定性(n=2,P=.50)上无差异。
- PS与UC在WOMAC(n=5,P=.26)、Knee Society Score(n=3,P=.58)、Knee Society Knee Score(n=4,P=.76)和Knee Society Function Score(n=5,P=.51)上无差异。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 仅1项随机对照试验(RCT)被评为「高质量」。
- 纳入研究为小样本短期研究,结束于术后约2年。
- 缺乏比较所有垫片的高质量研究。
- 需要更统一且随访超过5年的长期研究来论证UC使用的增加。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Posterior-stabilized (PS) and cruciate-retaining (CR) have been the most common tibial designs used in total knee arthroplasty. Ultra-congruent (UC) inserts are becoming popular because they preserve bone without relying on the posterior cruciate ligament balance and integrity. Despite increasing use, there is no consensus on how UC inserts perform versus PS and CR designs. METHODS: A comprehensive literature search of 5 online databases was performed for articles from January 2000 to July 2022 comparing the kinematic and clinical outcomes of PS or CR tibial inserts to UC inserts. There were nineteen studies included. There were 5 studies comparing UC to CR and 14 comparing UC to PS. Only one randomized controlled trial (RCT) was rated "good quality". RESULTS: For CR studies, pooled analyses showed no difference in knee flexion (n = 3, P = .33) or Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC) scores (n = 2, P = .58). For PS studies, meta-analyses showed better anteroposterior stability (n = 4, P < .001) and more femoral rollback (n = 2, P < .001) for PS but no difference in knee flexion (n = 9, P = .55) or medio-lateral stability (n = 2, P = .50). There was no difference with WOMAC (n = 5, P = .26), Knee Society Score (n = 3, P = .58), Knee Society Knee Score (n = 4, P = .76), or Knee Society Function Score (n = 5, P = .51). CONCLUSION: Available data demonstrates there are no clinical differences between CR or PS and UC inserts in small short-term studies ending around 2 years after surgery. More importantly, high-quality research comparing all inserts is lacking, demonstrating a need for more uniform and longer-term studies beyond 5 years after surgery to justify increased UC usage.
引用
- Wenzel AN, Hasan SA, Chaudhry YP, et al. Ultracongruent Designs Compared to Posterior-Stabilized and Cruciate-Retaining Tibial Inserts - What Does the Evidence Tell Us? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Arthroplasty. 2023. PMID: 37276953. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2023.05.064
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。