开放获取出版与全膝关节置换术文献中社交媒体关注度增加相关,但与引用次数增加无关
该研究纳入2016至2022年全膝关节置换术文献9606篇(开放获取4669篇,占48.61%),比较开放获取与非开放获取文章的社交媒体关注度和引用率。开放获取文章的平均Altmetric关注评分和Mendeley读者数更高,但引用次数无显著差异;在排名前10的关节置换期刊中,开放获取与Altmetric关注评分及引用次数均无独立预测关系,仅与Mendeley读者数相关。
要点
- 开放获取文章平均Altmetric关注评分为13.45,非开放获取为8.42(P=0.012)。
- 开放获取文章平均Mendeley读者数为43.91,非开放获取为36.72(P<0.001)。
- 开放获取并非引用次数的独立预测因素(13.98 vs 13.63,P=0.914)。
核心结论
- 全膝关节置换术文献中,开放获取出版与社交媒体关注度增加相关,但与总体引用次数无关。
- 在排名前10的关节置换期刊中,这一关联未观察到。
- 作者可能利用这些结果权衡读者群、引用和在线参与度与开放获取出版成本的相对重要性。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入2016年至2022年全膝关节置换术文献共9606篇,其中开放获取文章4669篇(48.61%)。
- 文章分为开放获取组和非开放获取组,使用负二项回归分析Altmetric关注评分和Mendeley读者数,并调整自发表以来的天数。
主要发现
- 开放获取文章平均Altmetric关注评分为13.45,非开放获取为8.42(P=0.012)。
- 开放获取文章平均Mendeley读者数为43.91,非开放获取为36.72(P<0.001)。
- 开放获取与非开放获取文章的引用次数无显著差异(13.98 vs 13.63,P=0.914)。
- 排名前10的关节置换期刊亚组分析中,开放获取不是Altmetric关注评分的独立预测因素(13.51 vs 9.53,P=0.084),也不是引用次数的独立预测因素(19.51 vs 18.74,P=0.495)。
- 排名前10的关节置换期刊亚组分析中,开放获取是Mendeley读者数的独立预测因素(49.05 vs 40.25,P<0.003)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Open access (OA) publication is growing in total joint arthroplasty literature. While OA manuscripts are free to view, these publications require a fee from authors. This study aimed to compare social media attention and citation rates between OA and non-OA publications in the total knee arthroplasty (TKA) literature. METHODS: There were 9,606 publications included, with 4,669 (48.61%) as OA articles. The TKA articles were identified from 2016 to 2022. Articles were grouped as OA or non-OA and Altmetric Attention Score (AAS), a weighted count of social media attention, and the Mendeley readership were analyzed using negative binomial regressions while adjusting for days since publication. RESULTS: The OA articles had greater mean AAS (13.45 versus 8.42, P = .012) and Mendeley readership (43.91 versus 36.72, P < .001). OA was not an independent predictor of number of citations when compared to non-OA articles (13.98 versus 13.63, P = .914). Subgroup analysis of studies in the top 10 arthroplasty journals showed OA was not an independent predictor of AAS (13.51 versus 9.53, P = .084) or number of citations (19.51 versus 18.74, P = .495) but was an independent predictor of Mendeley readership (49.05 versus 40.25, P < .003). CONCLUSION: The OA publications in the TKA literature were associated with increased social media attention, but not overall citations. This association was not observed among the top 10 journals. Authors may use these results to weigh the relative importance of readership, citations, and online engagement to the cost of OA publication.
引用
- Cueto R, Harris AB, Root K, et al. Open Access Publication in Total Knee Arthroplasty Is Associated With Increased Social Media Attention, but Is Not Associated With Increased Citations. J Arthroplasty. 2023. PMID: 37286049. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2023.05.085
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。