股骨头骨折的临床评估:哪种分类系统具有最佳的通用性、可靠性和可重复性?
该研究纳入2011年1月至2023年1月在中国一家大型一级创伤中心就诊的231例股骨头骨折患者(231髋),由4名观察者依据Pipkin、Brumback、AO/OTA、Chiron和New分类系统独立分型,1个月后重复分型以评估观察者内信度。结果显示Pipkin和Chiron分类具有接近完全的通用性及足够的观察者间和观察者内可重复性,推荐用于临床和研究;其他分类系统通用性或可重复性不足。
要点
- Pipkin和Chiron分类通用性分别为99%(228/231)和99%(228/231),观察者间κ分别为0.81和0.79。
- Pipkin和Chiron分类观察者内κ分别为0.89和0.87,均接近完美。
- Brumback、AO/OTA和New分类因通用性或可重复性不足,不推荐用于临床和研究。
核心结论
- 基于CT图像,临床医生和临床科学家可以同等信心地使用Pipkin或Chiron分类系统对股骨头骨折进行分型。
- 似乎不太可能出现任何新分类系统能显著优于这两个系统,其他现有系统要么缺乏足够的通用性,要么缺乏足够的可重复性,不推荐普遍使用。
研究设计与样本
- 2011年1月至2023年1月在中国一家大型一级创伤中心进行的诊断性研究,证据等级为Level III。
- 254例股骨头骨折患者中排除9%(23例)因CT图像质量差、骨骺未闭合、病理性骨折或髋臼发育不良,最终分析91%(231例患者,231髋)。
- 女性占19%(45例),受伤时平均年龄40±17岁。
- 所有骨折由4名观察者依据Pipkin、Brumback、AO/OTA、Chiron和New分类独立分型,每名观察者1个月后重复分型以评估观察者内信度。
主要发现
- 通用性:Pipkin 99%(228/231),Brumback 43%(99/231),AO/OTA 94%(216/231),Chiron 99%(228/231),New 100%(231/231)。
- 观察者间一致性:Pipkin几乎完美(κ 0.81 [95% CI 0.78至0.84]),Brumback中等(κ 0.51 [95% CI 0.44至0.59]),AO/OTA一般(κ 0.28 [95% CI 0.18至0.38]),Chiron高度一致(κ 0.79 [95% CI 0.76至0.82]),New高度一致(κ 0.63 [95% CI 0.58至0.68])。
- 观察者内一致性:Pipkin几乎完美(κ 0.89 [95% CI 0.83至0.96]),Brumback高度一致(κ 0.72 [95% CI 0.69至0.75]),AO/OTA中等(κ 0.51 [95% CI 0.43至0.58]),Chiron几乎完美(κ 0.87 [95% CI 0.82至0.91]),New高度一致(κ 0.78 [95% CI 0.59至0.97])。
关键数值与推荐
- 基于通用性及观察者间和观察者内可重复性的综合结果,推荐Pipkin和Chiron分类用于临床和研究。
- Brumback、AO/OTA和New分类因通用性或可重复性不足,不推荐用于临床和研究。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,临床医生和临床科学家可以同等信心地使用Pipkin或Chiron分类系统基于CT图像对股骨头骨折进行分型。
- 作者认为,其他现有分类系统因缺乏足够的通用性或可重复性,不推荐普遍使用。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Femoral head fractures are rare but potentially disabling injuries, and classifying them accurately and consistently can help surgeons make good choices about their treatment. However, there is no consensus as to which classification of these fractures is the most advantageous; parameters that might inform this choice include universality (the proportion of fractures that can be classified), as well as, of course, interobserver and intraobserver reproducibility. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Which classification achieves the best universality (defined as the proportion of fractures that can be classified)? (2) Which classification delivers the highest intraobserver and interobserver reproducibility in the clinical CT assessment of femoral head fractures? (3) Based on the answers to those two questions, which classifications are the most applicable for clinical practice and research? METHODS: Between January 2011 and January 2023, 254 patients with femoral head fractures who had CT scans (CT is routine at our institution for patients who have experienced severe hip trauma) were potentially eligible for inclusion in this study, which was performed at a large Level I trauma center in China. Of those, 9% (23 patients) were excluded because of poor-quality CT images, unclosed physes, pathologic fractures, or acetabular dysplasia, leaving 91% (231 patients with 231 hips) for analysis here. Among those, 19% (45) were female. At the time of injury, the mean age was 40 ± 17 years. All fractures were independently classified by four observers according to the Pipkin, Brumback, AO/Orthopaedic Trauma Association (OTA), Chiron, and New classifications. Each observer repeated his classifications again 1 month later to allow us to ascertain intraobserver reliability. To evaluate the universality of classifications, we characterized the percentage of hips that could be classified using the definitions offered in each classification. The kappa (κ) value was calculated to determine interrater and intrarater agreement. We then compared the classifications based on the combination of universality and interobserver and intraobserver reproducibility to determine which classifications might be recommended for clinical and research use. RESULTS: The universalities of the classifications were 99% (228 of 231, Pipkin), 43% (99 of 231, Brumback), 94% (216 of 231, AO/OTA), 99% (228 of 231, Chiron), and 100% (231 of 231, New). The interrater agreement was judged as almost perfect (κ 0.81 [95% CI 0.78 to 0.84], Pipkin), moderate (κ 0.51 [95% CI 0.44 to 0.59], Brumback), fair (κ 0.28 [95% CI 0.18 to 0.38], AO/OTA), substantial (κ 0.79 [95% CI 0.76 to 0.82], Chiron), and substantial (κ 0.63 [95% CI 0.58 to 0.68], New). In addition, the intrarater agreement was judged as almost perfect (κ 0.89 [95% CI 0.83 to 0.96]), substantial (κ 0.72 [95% CI 0.69 to 0.75]), moderate (κ 0.51 [95% CI 0.43 to 0.58]), almost perfect (κ 0.87 [95% CI 0.82 to 0.91]), and substantial (κ 0.78 [95% CI 0.59 to 0.97]), respectively. Based on these findings, we determined that the Pipkin and Chiron classifications offer near-complete universality and sufficient interobserver and intraobserver reproducibility to recommend them for clinical and research use, but the other classifications (Brumback, AO/OTA, and New) do not. CONCLUSION: Based on our findings, clinicians and clinician-scientists can use either the Pipkin or Chiron classification systems to classify femoral head fractures based on CT images, with equal confidence. It seems unlikely that any new classifications will substantially outperform these, and the other available systems either lacked sufficient universality or reproducibility to recommend them for general use. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, diagnostic study.
引用
- Wu S, Qian G, Huang Q, et al. Clinical Evaluation of Femoral Head Fractures: Which Classification Systems Have the Best Universality, Reliability, and Reproducibility? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2023. PMID: 37326487. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002731
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。