单纯前交叉韧带重建与联合前交叉韧带及前外侧韧带重建术后膝关节骨关节炎的影像学发生率:SANTI研究组的前瞻性匹配研究
SANTI研究组前瞻性匹配队列研究,比较单纯前交叉韧带重建(ACLR)与ACLR联合前外侧韧带重建(ACLR+ALLR)术后中期影像学骨关节炎发生率。随访104个月,两组胫股及外侧髌股关节间隙狭窄无显著差异,但单纯ACLR组内侧髌股关节间隙狭窄发生率显著更高(36.8% vs 11.9%,P=0.0118)。
要点
- ACLR+ALLR与单纯ACLR中期随访时胫股及外侧髌股关节间隙狭窄无显著差异。
- 单纯ACLR组内侧髌股关节间隙狭窄发生率36.8%,显著高于ACLR+ALLR组的11.9%(P=0.0118)。
- 外侧半月板撕裂使外侧胫股关节间隙狭窄风险增加近5倍(OR=4.9,95%CI 1.547-19.367,P=0.0123)。
核心结论
- 中期随访时,与单纯ACLR相比,ACLR+ALLR未增加外侧胫股间室骨关节炎风险。
- 使用骨-髌腱-骨(BPTB)移植物的单纯ACLR与内侧髌股关节间隙狭窄风险显著增加相关。
研究设计与样本
- 队列研究,证据等级3级。
- 2011年1月至2012年3月期间接受ACLR+ALLR(腘绳肌腱自体移植)的患者,按倾向性评分与同期接受单纯ACLR(BPTB或腘绳肌腱自体移植)的患者匹配。
- 共分析80例患者(ACLR+ALLR组42例,单纯ACLR组38例),平均随访104个月。
主要发现
- 内侧或外侧胫股间室及外侧髌股间室关节间隙狭窄两组间无显著差异。
- 内侧髌股间室狭窄:单纯ACLR组36.8% vs ACLR+ALLR组11.9%(P=0.0118)。
- 外侧半月板撕裂增加外侧胫股间室狭窄风险近5倍(OR=4.9,95%CI 1.547-19.367,P=0.0123)。
- 单纯ACLR增加内侧髌股间室狭窄风险>4倍(OR=4.8,95%CI 1.44-19.05,P=0.0179)。
- 二次半月板切除率:单纯ACLR组13.2% vs ACLR+ALLR组11.9%(无显著差异)。
关键数值与推荐
- 影像学评估采用国际膝关节文献委员会(IKDC)影像学骨关节炎分级量表、改良Kellgren-Lawrence分级及表面拟合法定量关节间隙狭窄百分比。
- 临床结局评估采用IKDC、膝关节损伤和骨关节炎结局评分(KOOS)、Lysholm、Tegner及ACL损伤后重返运动量表。
- KOOS、Tegner或IKDC评分两组间无差异。
- 任何分类系统的骨关节炎改变分级两组间均无差异。
- BPTB移植患者内侧髌股关节狭窄发生率66.7% vs ACLR+ALLR组11.9%(P=0.118)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Combined anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction (ACLR) and anterolateral ligament reconstruction (ALLR) have demonstrated reduced risk of graft rerupture as compared with isolated ACLR. However, concerns remain that the risk of osteoarthritis (OA) may be increased by the addition of ALLR. PURPOSE/HYPOTHESIS: The aim of this study was to evaluate the incidence of OA with isolated ACLR in comparison with ACLR + ALLR at medium-term follow-up. We hypothesized that there would be no differences between the groups. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: Patients who underwent ACLR + ALLR with hamstring tendon autograft between January 2011 and March 2012 were propensity matched to patients who underwent isolated ACLR with bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB) or hamstring tendon autograft in the same period. Medium-term radiographic evaluation was performed using the International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) radiographic OA grading scale, modified Kellgren-Lawrence grade, and the surface fit method to assess percentage of joint space narrowing. Clinical outcomes were assessed with the following measures: IKDC, Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS), Lysholm, Tegner, and ACL Return to Sport after Injury. RESULTS: A total of 80 patients (42 ACLR + ALLR and 38 isolated ACLR) were analyzed with a mean follow-up of 104 months. There was no significant difference between groups for joint space narrowing in the medial or lateral tibiofemoral or lateral patellofemoral (PF) compartment. However, 36.8% in the isolated ACLR group versus 11.9% in the ACLR + ALLR group had narrowing of the medial PF compartment (P = .0118). A lateral meniscal tear increased the risk of lateral tibiofemoral narrowing by nearly 5 times (odds ratio, 4.9; 95% CI, 1.547-19.367; P = .0123). The risk of medial PF narrowing was >4-fold with an isolated ACLR (odds ratio, 4.8; 95% CI, 1.44-19.05; P = .0179). Between the isolated ACLR group and the ACLR + ALLR group, the secondary meniscectomy rate was 13.2% versus 11.9% (not significantly different). There was no difference between groups in KOOS, Tegner, or IKDC scores. There was also no difference between groups for grades of osteoarthritic change for any classification system. Patients who received a BPTB graft had medial PF joint narrowing in 66.7% of cases as compared with 11.9% in those who received ACLR + ALLR (P = 0.118). CONCLUSION: ACLR + ALLR did not increase the risk of OA in the lateral tibiofemoral compartment when compared with an isolated ACLR at medium-term follow-up. Isolated ACLR using BPTB was associated with a significantly increased risk of medial PF joint space narrowing. REGISTRATION: NCT05123456 (ClinicalTrials.gov identifier).
引用
- Shatrov J, Freychet B, Hopper GP, et al. Radiographic Incidence of Knee Osteoarthritis After Isolated ACL Reconstruction Versus Combined ACL and ALL Reconstruction: A Prospective Matched Study From the SANTI Study Group. Am J Sports Med. 2023. PMID: 37154412. doi:10.1177/03635465231168899
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。