双动髋臼内衬安放不良的影像学准确性因假体设计而异
该尸体骨盆影像学研究评估两种设计的模块化双动内衬(平齐缘与高缘)安放不良的X线识别能力,由2名盲法外科医生阅片。平齐缘设计诊断错误率5%(2/40),高缘设计40%(16/40),高缘组误诊风险显著更高(比值比13)。
要点
- 平齐缘设计安放不良的X线诊断错误率为5%(2/40),高缘设计为40%(16/40)。
- 高缘设计误诊安放不良的比值比为13,16例误诊中12例为未识别出安放不良。
- 平齐缘设计观察者内一致性几乎完美(κ=0.90),高缘设计仅为一般(κ=0.35)。
核心结论
- 全面的X线系列可可靠检出平齐缘设计的模块化双动内衬安放不良,准确率达95%。
- 高缘设计在X线上准确识别安放不良更为困难。
研究设计与样本
- 尸体骨盆影像学研究,使用5具尸体骨盆标本共10髋,植入两种设计的模块化双动内衬。
- 共构建40个组合,其中20个安放良好、20个故意安放不良,由2名盲法外科医生阅片。
- 统计分析包括卡方检验、逻辑回归和kappa统计。
主要发现
- 高缘设计安放不良的影像学评估不准确,误诊率为40%(16/40)。
- 平齐缘设计的诊断错误率为5%(2/40;P=0.0002)。
- 逻辑回归显示高缘组误诊安放不良的风险显著更高(比值比13)。
- 高缘组16例误诊中12例为未能识别出安放不良的内衬。
- 平齐缘设计观察者内一致性几乎完美(κ=0.90),高缘设计一致性一般(κ=0.35)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Dual-mobility constructs have gained popularity to mitigate dislocations after high-risk primary and revision total hip arthroplasties. Contemporary data have indicated that malseating of modular dual-mobility liners occurs in up to 6% of cases. The purpose of this cadaveric-based radiographic study was to determine the ability to accurately determine if modular dual-mobility liners were seated. METHODS: There were 10 hips (5 cadaveric pelvic specimens) used to implant modular dual-mobility liners of 2 designs. One had a liner that seated flush and the other had an extended rim. There were 20 constructs that were well-seated and 20 constructs were intentionally malseated. A comprehensive series of radiographs was reviewed by 2 blinded surgeons. Statistical analyses included Chi-squared testing, logistic regressions, and kappa statistics. RESULTS: Radiographic assessment of liner malseating was not accurate with an elevated rim design with misdiagnosis in 40% (16 of 40). The flush design had diagnostic errors in 5% (2 of 40; P = .0002). Logistic regressions demonstrated a significantly higher risk of misdiagnosing a malseated liner in the elevated rim group (odds ratio 13). There were 12 of 16 misdiagnoses in the elevated rim group failing to recognize a malseated liner. Each surgeon had almost perfect agreement for intraobserver reliability for flush designs (k 0.90) and fair agreement in the elevated rim design (k 0.35). CONCLUSION: A comprehensive series of plain radiographs can reliably detect a malseated modular dual-mobility liner with a flush rim design in 95% of cases. However, elevated rim designs are more difficult to accurately identify malseating on plain radiographs.
引用
- Rames RD, Couch CG, Sierra RJ, et al. Radiographic Accuracy of Malseated Dual-Mobility Liners Varies Based on Implant Design. J Arthroplasty. 2023. PMID: 37209910. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2023.05.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。