文献速递脊柱外科

成人脊柱畸形手术费用:更高费用的手术是否带来更好的结局?

Costs of Surgery in Adult Spinal Deformity: Do Higher Cost Surgeries Lead to Better Outcomes?
PubMed 文献 · Spine (Phila Pa 1976) · 2023-05-10

这项回顾性研究纳入421例成人脊柱畸形患者,按手术费用三分位分组并进行倾向评分匹配后各102例,比较高低费用组患者报告结局。高费用组在Oswestry功能障碍指数、脊柱侧凸研究学会总分和背部数字评定量表上达到实质性临床获益的比值比更高,但并发症率无显著差异。作者认为费用效率虽重要,但单纯降低费用可能损害结局并增加未来再干预费用,尤其对基线畸形更严重者。

要点

  • 高费用组与低费用组并发症率无显著差异。
  • 高费用组达到Oswestry功能障碍指数实质性临床获益的OR为2.356(95%CI 1.220-4.551,P=0.011)。
  • 高费用组达到脊柱侧凸研究学会总分实质性临床获益的OR为2.988(95%CI 1.515-5.895,P=0.002)。

核心结论

  • 虽然增加费用并不保证理想结局,但高费用组患者报告结局优于低费用组。
  • 费用效率仍是卫生政策的重要优先事项,但单纯降低费用可能损害结局并增加未来再干预费用,尤其对基线畸形更严重者。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性研究,纳入年龄18岁及以上、有基线和2年数据的成人脊柱畸形患者。
  • 手术费用按2021年Medicare平均报销额以Current Procedural Terminology代码计算,故意排除并发症和再手术费用。
  • 患者按手术费用三分位排名分为最高费用组和最低费用组,并进行倾向评分匹配以校正基线年龄和畸形差异。
  • 采用双变量逻辑回归评估达到结局的比值比。

主要发现

  • 共421例患者符合纳入标准(年龄60.7岁,女性81.8%,Charlson合并症指数1.6,体重指数27.1 kg/m²),其中最低费用组139例、最高费用组127例。
  • 倾向评分匹配后每组各102例,平均报销额最低费用组为12,494美元,最高费用组为29,248美元。
  • 匹配队列人口学和基线健康相关生活质量相似,基线矢状面垂直轴最高费用组59.0 mm vs 最低费用组56.7 mm,骨盆入射角与腰椎前凸差值最高费用组13.1° vs 最低费用组13.4°,骨盆倾斜角最高费用组25.3° vs 最低费用组22.4°。
  • 并发症率在费用组间无显著差异。
  • 相比最低费用组,最高费用组2年内达到Oswestry功能障碍指数实质性临床获益的OR为2.356(95%CI 1.220-4.551,P=0.011),达到脊柱侧凸研究学会总分实质性临床获益的OR为2.988(95%CI 1.515-5.895,P=0.002),达到背部数字评定量表实质性临床获益的OR为2.739(95%CI 1.105-6.788,P=0.030)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 最高费用组平均报销额29,248美元 vs 最低费用组12,494美元。
  • 最高费用组达到Oswestry功能障碍指数实质性临床获益的OR为2.356(95%CI 1.220-4.551,P=0.011)。
  • 最高费用组达到脊柱侧凸研究学会总分实质性临床获益的OR为2.988(95%CI 1.515-5.895,P=0.002)。
  • 最高费用组达到背部数字评定量表实质性临床获益的OR为2.739(95%CI 1.105-6.788,P=0.030)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

STUDY DESIGN: This was a retrospective study. OBJECTIVE: To assess the impact of surgical costs on patient-reported outcomes in adult spinal deformity (ASD). SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: With increased focus on delivering cost-effective health care, interventions with high-resource utilization, such as ASD surgery, have received greater scrutiny. MATERIALS AND METHODS: ASD patients aged 18 years and older with BL and 2-year data were included. Surgical costs were calculated using the 2021 average Medicare reimbursement by Current Procedural Terminology code. Costs of complications and reoperations were intentionally excluded. Patients were ranked into tertiles by surgical cost: highest surgical costs (HC) and lowest surgical costs (LC). They were propensity score matched to account for differences in baseline age and deformity. Bivariate logistic regressions assessed odds of achieving outcomes. RESULTS: Four hundred twenty-one patients met inclusion (60.7 yr, 81.8% female, Charlson Comorbidity Index: 1.6, 27.1 kg/m 2 ), 139 LC and 127 HC patients. After propensity score matching, 102 patients remained in each cost group with an average reimbursement of LC: $12,494 versus HC: $29,248. Matched cohorts had similar demographics and baseline health-related quality of life. Matched groups had similar baseline sagittal vertical axis (HC: 59.0 vs. LC: 56.7 mm), pelvic incidence and lumbar lordosis (HC: 13.1 vs. LC: 13.4°), and pelvic tilt (HC: 25.3 vs. LC: 22.4°). Rates of complications were not significantly different between the cost groups. Compared with the LC group, by 2 years, HC patients had higher odds of reaching substantial clinical benefit in Oswestry Disability Index [odds ratio (OR): 2.356 (1.220, 4.551), P =0.011], in Scoliosis Research Society-Total [OR: 2.988 (1.515, 5.895), P =0.002], and in Numerical Rating Scale Back [OR: 2.739 (1.105, 6.788), P =0.030]. Similar findings were appreciated for HC patients in the setting of Schwab deformity outcome criteria. CONCLUSIONS: Although added cost did not guarantee an ideal outcome, HC patients experienced superior patient-reported outcomes compared with LC patients. Although cost efficiency remains an important priority for health policy, isolating cost reduction may compromise outcomes and add to future costs of reintervention, particularly with more severe baseline deformity. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 3.

来源:Spine (Phila Pa 1976),查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Joujon-Roche R, Dave P, Tretiakov P, et al. Costs of Surgery in Adult Spinal Deformity: Do Higher Cost Surgeries Lead to Better Outcomes? Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2023. PMID: 37163657. doi:10.1097/BRS.0000000000004716

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。