肱骨干骨折钢板接骨术与髓内钉固定术后的功能与临床结局:HUMMER多中心前瞻性队列研究结果
HUMMER多中心前瞻性队列研究纳入245例成人肱骨干骨折(OTA/AO 12A或12B型),比较钢板接骨术(76例)与髓内钉固定术(169例)的功能与临床结局,随访至1年。钢板组肩关节功能恢复更快,植入物相关并发症更少,但术后暂时性桡神经麻痹更多。
要点
- 钢板组DASH评分随时间改善更快,但12个月时与髓内钉组无显著差异。
- Constant-Murley评分及肩关节外展、前屈、外旋、内旋显示显著治疗效应, favoring钢板组。
- 钢板组植入物相关并发症2例,髓内钉组24例(包括13例钉尾突出和8例螺钉突出)。
核心结论
- 成人肱骨干骨折钢板接骨术可实现更快恢复,尤其是肩关节功能。
- 钢板接骨术与更多暂时性神经麻痹相关,但植入物相关并发症和手术再干预更少。
- 尽管植入物和手术入路存在异质性,钢板接骨术似乎是这些骨折的首选治疗方案。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心前瞻性队列研究,纳入2012年10月23日至2018年10月3日期间OTA/AO 12A或12B型肱骨干骨折成人患者。
- 共纳入245例患者,其中76例接受钢板接骨术,169例接受髓内钉固定术。
- 结局指标包括DASH评分、Constant-Murley评分、肩肘关节活动度、影像学愈合及至1年的并发症,采用重复测量分析并校正年龄、性别和骨折类型。
主要发现
- 钢板组患者更年轻,中位年龄43岁 vs 髓内钉组57岁(p < 0.001)。
- 钢板组平均DASH评分随时间改善更快,但12个月时与髓内钉组无显著差异(钢板组11.7分[95%CI 7.6至15.7分] vs 髓内钉组11.2分[95%CI 8.3至14.0分])。
- Constant-Murley评分及肩关节外展、前屈、外旋、内旋显示显著治疗效应(p治疗 ≤ 0.001), favoring钢板组。
- 钢板组植入物相关并发症2例,髓内钉组24例,包括13例钉尾突出和8例螺钉突出。
- 钢板组术后暂时性桡神经麻痹更多(8例[10.5%] vs 1例[0.6%];p < 0.001),骨不连有减少趋势(3例[5.7%] vs 16例[11.9%];p = 0.285)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,尽管植入物和手术入路存在异质性,钢板接骨术似乎是这些骨折的首选治疗方案。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Plate osteosynthesis (referred to throughout as plating) and intramedullary nailing (referred to throughout as nailing) are the most common operative strategies for humeral shaft fractures. However, it is undecided which treatment is more effective. This study aimed to compare functional and clinical outcomes of these treatment strategies. We hypothesized that plating would result in an earlier recovery of shoulder function and fewer complications. METHODS: From October 23, 2012, to October 3, 2018, adults with a humeral shaft fracture, OTA/AO type 12A or 12B, were enrolled in a multicenter, prospective cohort study. Patients were treated with plating or nailing. Outcome measures included the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (DASH) score, Constant-Murley score, ranges of motion of the shoulder and elbow, radiographic healing, and complications until 1 year. Repeated-measure analysis was done with correction for age, sex, and fracture type. RESULTS: Of the 245 included patients, 76 were treated with plating and 169 were treated with nailing. Patients in the plating group were younger, with a median age of 43 years compared with 57 years for the nailing group (p < 0.001). The mean DASH score after plating improved faster over time, but did not differ significantly from the score after nailing at 12 months (11.7 points [95% confidence interval (CI), 7.6 to 15.7 points]) for plating and 11.2 points [95% CI, 8.3 to 14.0 points] for nailing). The Constant-Murley score and shoulder abduction, flexion, external rotation, and internal rotation displayed a significant treatment effect (p treatment ≤ 0.001), in favor of plating. The plating group had 2 implant-related complications, whereas the nailing group had 24, including 13 nail protrusions and 8 screw protrusions. Plating resulted in more postoperative temporary radial nerve palsy (8 patients [10.5%] compared with 1 patient [0.6%]; p < 0.001) and a trend toward fewer nonunions (3 patients [5.7%] compared with 16 patients [11.9%]; p = 0.285) than nailing. CONCLUSIONS: Plating of a humeral shaft fracture in adults results in faster recovery, especially of shoulder function. Plating was associated with more temporary nerve palsies, but fewer implant-related complications and surgical reinterventions, than nailing. Despite heterogeneity in implants and surgical approach, plating seems to be the preferred treatment option for these fractures. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic Level II . See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
引用
- Den Hartog D, Mahabier KC, Van Bergen SH, et al. Functional and Clinical Outcomes After Plate Osteosynthesis Versus Intramedullary Nailing of a Humeral Shaft Fracture: The Results of the HUMMER Multicenter, Prospective Cohort Study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2023. PMID: 37220192. doi:10.2106/JBJS.22.00647
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。