不同模块化双动髋臼假体机械辅助缝隙腐蚀的评估
研究通过10对回收的两种模块化双动(MDM)假体分析微动与腐蚀,并在体外腐蚀舱中对三种MDM系统的钛合金外壳与钴铬钼内衬进行测试。结果显示MDM2内衬腐蚀评分高于MDM1(P=.006),MDM2微动电流高于MDM1或MDM3(P=.011),起始载荷也更高(P=.001)。作者认为MDM2锥部似乎易发生非机械性腐蚀模式,其较高起始载荷和微动电流提示抗机械辅助缝隙腐蚀(MACC)能力更强但一旦开始腐蚀则更严重。
要点
- 回收内衬中MDM2腐蚀评分高于MDM1(P=.006),锥部区域外差异更明显(P=.00003)。
- 体外测试中MDM2微动电流高于MDM1或MDM3(P=.011),起始载荷也更高(P=.001)。
- 三种系统电流均<5 μA,远低于头颈锥部所观察到的电流。
核心结论
- 回收内衬中MDM2锥部似乎易发生非机械性腐蚀模式。
- MDM2锥部较高的起始载荷和微动电流提示抗MACC能力更强,但一旦开始腐蚀则严重程度更高。
- 器械间差异可能源于锥部设计和表面光洁度。
- 三种系统电流均<5 μA,远低于头颈锥部所观察到的电流。
- 作者认为在这些MDM设计所观察到的腐蚀类型中,机械驱动腐蚀可能并非最重要。
研究设计与样本
- 研究对10对匹配的两种商用MDM假体(MDM1和MDM2)回收件进行微动与腐蚀分析。
- 体外测试将三种商用双动系统(MDM1、MDM2和MDM3)的原始钛合金(Ti6Al4V)外壳与钴铬钼(CoCrMo)内衬配对,每种三对放入电化学舱。
- 测试中逐步增加循环压缩载荷,同时测量外壳-内衬锥部产生的电流。
- 计算起始微动载荷和微动电流。
主要发现
- 回收组件腐蚀损伤评分低,但MDM2内衬高于MDM1内衬(P=.006),尤其在锥部区域外(P=.00003)。
- MDM2微动电流高于MDM1或MDM3(P=.011)。
- MDM2起始载荷也更高(P=.001)。
- 三种系统电流均<5 μA,远低于头颈锥部所观察到的电流。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Modular dual mobility (MDM) acetabular component use is rising in total hip arthroplasty. However, concern of mechanically assisted crevice corrosion (MACC) at the shell-liner interface remains. We investigated shell-liner corrosion using retrieval analyses and corrosion chamber testing. METHODS: We analyzed fretting and corrosion on 10 matched pairs of 2 commercial MDM constructs (MDM1 and MDM2). Also, pristine pairs of Ti6Al4V shells and CoCrMo liners from 3 commercial dual mobility systems (MDM1, MDM2, and MDM3) were tested in vitro to model MACC performance. Three pairs of each were placed into an electrochemical chamber with stepwise increasing cyclic compression loads while measuring currents generated at the shell-liner taper. Onset fretting loads and fretting currents were calculated. RESULTS: Corrosion damage scores on retrieved components were low but higher in the MDM2 to MDM1 liners (P = .006), specifically outside the taper region (P = .00003). Fretting currents were higher in the MDM2 than in MDM1 or MDM3 (P = .011). Onset loads were also higher in the MDM2 (P = .001). CONCLUSION: Among retrieved liners, MDM2 tapers seem prone to non-mechanical corrosion modes. Higher onset loads and fretting currents in MDM2 tapers indicate greater MACC resistance but higher severity once corrosion begins. Differences among the devices were likely due to taper design and surface finish. Currents in all 3 were <5 μA, much lower than those observed with head-neck tapers. Our findings suggest that, among the types of corrosion observed in these MDM designs, mechanically driven corrosion may not be the most significant.
引用
- Steele JR, Shenoy AA, Pekmezian A, et al. Evaluation of Mechanically-Assisted Crevice Corrosion of Different Modular Dual Mobility Constructs. J Arthroplasty. 2023. PMID: 37088224. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2023.04.036
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。