「外科医生冠军」与高手术量医生是否有更低的假体周围股骨骨折发生率?来自全州质量改进登记处的视角
基于2012至2019年95,948例全髋关节置换病例的全州质量改进登记数据,评估外科医生手术量与「外科医生冠军」角色对术后6个月内假体周围股骨骨折发生率的影响。结果显示「外科医生冠军」和高手术量医生更可能成为高表现者(绿色),但并未更不可能成为低表现者(红色),积极参与质量改进和/或高手术量与更好结局相关,但并未赋予并发症豁免权。
要点
- 全部外科医生中19.6%为红色(显著高于均值)、72.1%为黄色(无差异)、8.3%为绿色(低于均值)。
- 「外科医生冠军」中17.2%为绿色,非冠军中6.2%为绿色(P=0.01);红色比例分别为20.7%与19.3%(P=0.82)。
- 手术量与表现显著相关(P<0.01):最低两个四分位组(<84例;84至180例)无绿色医生,较高手术量组(181至404例;>404例)绿色比例分别为4%和29%。
核心结论
- 「外科医生冠军」和高手术量医生更可能成为高表现者,但并未更不可能成为低表现者。
- 积极参与质量改进和/或高手术量与更好结局相关,但并未赋予并发症豁免权。
- 作者认为绿色医生应指导同事,通过重新评估可改变因素来帮助减少骨折。
研究设计与样本
- 基于全州质量改进登记处的查询分析,纳入2012年至2019年95,948例病例,识别术后6个月内假体周围股骨骨折。
- 采用漏斗图比较个体外科医生特定的骨折率,将骨折率低于置信区间者标记为绿色(低于均值),在区间内为黄色(无差异),高于区间为红色(显著更高)。
主要发现
- 全部外科医生中19.6%为红色,72.1%为黄色,8.3%为绿色。
- 「外科医生冠军」中17.2%为绿色,非冠军中6.2%为绿色(P=0.01);红色比例在「外科医生冠军」中为20.7%,在非冠军中为19.3%(P=0.82)。
- 手术量与表现之间存在显著关联(P<0.01)。
- 最低两个四分位组(<84例;84至180例)无绿色医生,较高手术量组(181至404例;>404例)中绿色医生比例分别为4%和29%。
- 红色状态按手术量比较无统计学差异(P=0.53)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Recently, a state-wide registry identified fracture as a major cause of total hip arthroplasty revision. There were 52.8% of revisions occurring within 6 months (fracture leading cause). Registry sites have a 'surgeon champion' who acts as liaison and advocate. This study evaluated the effect of surgeon volume and role of 'surgeon champion' on fracture rates. METHODS: There were 95,948 cases from 2012 to 2019 queried with peri-implant femoral fractures identified (within 6 months). Funnel plots were generated to compare individual surgeon-specific fracture rates. Surgeons who had a fracture rate below the confidence interval were labeled 'green' (lower than mean), within were 'yellow' (no difference), and above were 'red' (significantly higher). RESULTS: For all surgeons, 19.6% were red, 72.1% yellow, and 8.3% green. There were 17.2% 'surgeon champions' and 6.2% 'nonchampions' that were green (P = .01), while 20.7 and 19.3% were red (P = .82). There was a significant association between volume and performance (P < .01). No surgeons in the lower two quartiles (<84; 84 to 180 cases), while 4 and 29% of higher-volume surgeons (181 to 404; >404 cases) were green. There was no statistical difference in red status by volume (P = .53). CONCLUSION: 'Surgeon champions' and high-volume surgeons were more likely to be high performers but not less likely to be low performers. Active involvement in quality improvement and/or high volume was associated with better outcomes but did not impart complication immunity. 'Green' surgeons should mentor colleagues to help reduce fractures by re-evaluating modifiable factors. Analyzing outcomes to promote quality and decrease complications is paramount.
引用
- Markel JF, Adams NA, Srivastava AK, et al. Do 'Surgeon Champions' and High-Volume Surgeons Have Lower Rates of Periprosthetic Femur Fracture? Perspective From a State-Wide Quality Improvement Registry. J Arthroplasty. 2023. PMID: 37084923. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2023.04.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。