John N. Insall奖:非骨水泥与骨水泥胫骨假体的随机临床试验:平均10年随访时耐久可靠
本研究为随机临床试验,2003至2006年纳入389例初次全膝关节置换术,随机分为传统模块化骨水泥胫骨、混合型单块胫骨和非骨水泥单块胫骨三组,平均随访10年。结果显示混合型与非骨水泥单块组无翻修生存率均为96%,传统骨水泥模块化组为89%,且传统组无菌性胫骨松动翻修显著更多(7% vs 0%)。
要点
- 10年无翻修生存率:混合型单块与非骨水泥单块组均为96%,传统模块化骨水泥组为89%(P=0.05)。
- 无菌性胫骨松动翻修率:传统骨水泥模块化组7%,混合型和非骨水泥单块组均为0%(P=0.003)。
- 三组临床结果相似且优良,非进行性放射透亮线传统组24%、混合组12%、非骨水泥组9%。
核心结论
- 非骨水泥和混合型单块胫骨假体具有优良的假体生存率(96%),至今无无菌性胫骨松动病例。
- 传统骨水泥模块化胫骨组10年无菌性松动累积发生率为7%。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性随机对照试验(证据等级I级),2003至2006年纳入389例初次全膝关节置换术。
- 随机分为三组:传统模块化骨水泥胫骨135例、混合型(骨水泥基板带非骨水泥柱)单块胫骨128例、非骨水泥单块胫骨126例。
- 平均年龄68岁(范围41至85岁),男性46%,平均体质指数32(范围21至59),平均随访10年。
主要发现
- 10年无任何翻修生存率:混合型单块组与非骨水泥单块组均为96%,传统模块化骨水泥组为89%(P=0.05)。
- 10年无菌性胫骨松动翻修:传统模块化骨水泥组7%,混合型和非骨水泥单块组均为0%(P=0.003)。
- 非进行性放射透亮线:传统模块化骨水泥组24%、混合型单块组12%、非骨水泥单块组9%,传统组显著更多。
- 三组临床结果相似且优良。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Cementless fixation is gaining popularity for primary total knee arthroplasties (TKAs). The prior 5-year results of our randomized clinical trial that included 3 different tibial designs found minimal differences. The purpose of the current study was to investigate the 10-year results in the same cohort. METHODS: Between 2003 and 2006, 389 primary TKAs were randomized: traditional modular cemented tibia (135); hybrid (cemented baseplate with uncemented pegs) monoblock tibia (128); and cementless monoblock tibia (126). Implant survivorships, radiographs, and clinical outcomes were analyzed. Mean age at TKA was 68 years (range, 41 to 85), 46% were male, and mean body mass index was 32 (range, 21 to 59). The mean follow-up was 10 years. RESULTS: The 10-year survivorship free of any revision was similar between the hybrid monoblock and cementless monoblock groups at 96%, but lower (89%) for the traditional modular cemented tibia (P = .05). The traditional modular cemented tibia group had significantly more revisions for aseptic tibial loosening than the other 2 groups (7 versus 0%) at 10 years (P = .003). The traditional modular cemented tibia group had significantly more nonprogressive radiolucent lines than the hybrid and cementless monoblock groups (24, 12, and 9%, respectively). Clinical outcomes were similar and excellent between all 3 groups. CONCLUSION: Cementless and hybrid monoblock tibial components have excellent implant survivorship (96%) with no cases of aseptic tibial loosening to date. The traditional cemented modular tibial group had a 7% cumulative incidence of aseptic loosening at 10 years. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level I, Prospective Randomized Control Trial.
引用
- Gibon E, Lewallen DG, Larson DR, et al. John N. Insall Award: Randomized Clinical Trial of Cementless Versus Cemented Tibial Components: Durable and Reliable at a Mean 10-Years Follow-Up. J Arthroplasty. 2023. PMID: 36931364. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2023.03.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。