当代关节置换实践中全髋关节置换术治疗髋部骨折的结局是否劣于关节炎
这项回顾性多术者研究比较了2010至2020年间由关节置换外科医生实施的177例股骨颈骨折全髋关节置换术与354例匹配的骨关节炎全髋关节置换术。5年随访时股骨颈骨折组死亡率显著高于骨关节炎组(15.3% vs 1.1%,P < .001),但并发症、再手术率和牛津髋关节评分无显著差异。作者认为由关节置换外科医生实施的股骨颈骨折全髋关节置换术是可靠选择,结局满意。
要点
- 股骨颈骨折全髋关节置换术后5年死亡率15.3%,显著高于骨关节炎组的1.1%(P < .001)。
- 两组并发症(7.3% vs 4.2%,P = .098)和再手术率(5.1% vs 2.9%,P = .142)无显著差异。
- 未使用双动关节的患者脱位率为1.7%,不稳定不是常见失败原因。
核心结论
- 作者认为,全髋关节置换术治疗股骨颈骨折是可靠选择,结局满意;尽管未使用双动关节,不稳定并非常见失败原因,可能归因于由关节置换专科医生实施手术。
- 作者指出,当患者生存超过2年时,与骨关节炎择期全髋关节置换术相比,可预期相似的临床和影像学结局及低翻修率。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性、多术者研究,来自一个学术中心。
- 2010至2020年间,177例股骨颈骨折患者由关节置换外科医生实施全髋关节置换术,平均年龄67岁(范围42至97岁),女性占64.4%。
- 按年龄和性别1:2匹配354例由同一批医生实施的骨关节炎全髋关节置换术。
- 未使用双动关节。
- 证据等级III,病例对照研究。
主要发现
- 术后平均下肢长度差异为0 mm(范围-10至-10 mm),平均髋臼杯外倾角和前倾角分别为41°和26°。
- 股骨颈骨折组与骨关节炎组在影像学测量上无差异(P = .3)。
- 5年随访时,股骨颈骨折全髋关节置换组死亡率显著高于骨关节炎全髋关节置换组(15.3% vs 1.1%;P < .001)。
- 两组并发症发生率无差异(7.3% vs 4.2%;P = .098),再手术率无差异(5.1% vs 2.9%;P = .142)。
- 脱位率为1.7%;末次随访时牛津髋关节评分相似(43.7分(范围10至48)vs 43.6分(范围10至48);P = .030)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,全髋关节置换术治疗股骨颈骨折是可靠选择,结局满意。
- 作者指出,当患者生存超过2年时,与骨关节炎择期全髋关节置换术相比,可预期相似的临床和影像学结局及低翻修率。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Outcome of total hip arthroplasty (THA) for femoral neck fractures (FNF) has been associated with higher complication rates. However, THA for FNF is not always performed by arthroplasty surgeons. This study aimed to compare THA outcomes for FNF to osteoarthritis (OA). In doing so, we described contemporary THA failure modes for FNF performed by arthroplasty surgeons. METHODS: This was a retrospective, multisurgeon study from an academic center. Of FNFs treated between 2010 and 2020, 177 received THA by an arthroplasty surgeon [mean age 67 years (range, 42 to 97), sex: 64.4% women]. These were matched (1:2) for age and sex with 354 THAs performed for hip OA, by the same surgeons. No dual-mobilities were used. Outcomes included radiologic measurements (inclination/anteversion and leg length), mortality, complications, reoperation rates and patient-reported outcomes including Oxford Hip Score. RESULTS: Postoperative mean leg-length difference was 0 mm (range, -10 to -10 mm), with a mean cup inclination and anteversion of 41 and 26°, respectively. There was no difference in radiological measurements between FNF and OA patients (P = .3). At a 5-year follow-up, mortality rate was significantly higher in the FNF-THA group compared to the OA-THA group (15.3 versus 1.1%; P < .001). There was no difference in complications (7.3 versus 4.2%; P = .098) or reoperation rates (5.1 versus 2.9%; P = .142) between the groups. Dislocation rate was 1.7%. Oxford Hip Score at the final follow-up was similar [43.7 points (range, 10 to 48) versus 43.6 points (range, 10 to 48); P = .030]. CONCLUSION: THA for the treatment of FNF is a reliable option and is associated with satisfactory outcomes. Instability was not a common reason of failure, despite not using dual-mobility articulations in this at-risk population. This is likely due to THAs being performed by the arthroplasty staff. When patients live beyond 2 years, similar clinical and radiographic outcomes with low rates of revision can be expected compared to elective THA for OA. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: III, case-control study.
引用
- Verhaegen JCF, Bourget-Murray J, Morris J, et al. Is Outcome of Total Hip Arthroplasty for Hip Fracture Inferior to That of Arthritis in a Contemporary Arthroplasty Practice? J Arthroplasty. 2023. PMID: 36889530. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2023.02.069
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。